Lauren F.
Yelp
I'd give this 3.5 if I could, but I'm rounding down because, despite the service being good, the food wasn't up there for me. I went with a group and between us we tried the carne frita con tostones, pastelón (my main), arroz con gandules, mofongo con camarones, and mofongo con carne frita. I've had mofongo before at other restaurants, and this was pretty standard - the portion honestly seemed pretty small for the price, and while it tasted fine it didn't wow any of us. I also missed the crunch I'm used to getting from the kind that has chicharrones in it, but it still hit the spot. The carne frita was well-cooked but not that flavorful, and we ended up using a lot of the sauce on the table (delicious!) with that and the tostones because they didn't have much to them on their own. The same is true for the pastelón. I love plantains and cheese, so I still enjoyed the dish a lot, don't get me wrong, but there could definitely have been more cheese and better spiced meat/more flavor in general. We didn't finish the arroz con gandules for a similar reason. I had a coquito, which was good but not particularly strong - I'd try something different next time. We split the tres leches cake for dessert. The passion fruit made it unique when compared to other tres leches we'd had. I absolutely love passion fruit, but oddly I think I would have preferred the classic tres leches - something about it didn't quite work for me (maybe I'm just too used to strawberries, I don't know). I'm also not a big sprinkles person, so I'm sure that was part of it. Still, it was tender and unique and really tasty, so I'd still recommend trying it!
Overall, I think I would have liked this place more if I felt like the prices matched the quality of the dishes. Granted, I moved here from an area with more options for Puerto Rican food, but I just didn't feel like this place had outstanding flavors. Small portions + high prices + just okay food. Service was great and I liked the variety of options and the overall cozy feel of the place, though! Unfortunately, I don't think I'll be back, but I'm glad to have tried it.