Haeley G.
Yelp
So, this was a really hard decision to make on stars - I think I'd be a 4.5 but as it wasn't quite 5, I had to lean towards 4. Here's why.
Pros:
-Environment: B-E-A-U-T-I-F-U-L. Wow. Like you're walking into the perfect secret garden cottage, posh style Tons of windows and the restaurant is sectioned in rooms, giving it the feel of sitting in a home with fine dining.
-Food: Overall, good. Details below.
-Service: Perfection. Very accommodating, polite, and the manager person had perfect English. Was able to communicate with waiters in my chopped up Spanish/English. Also, as we were in our taxi up to the restaurant (5-7 minute drive from old town), realized we weren't sure how to get a taxi back. Talked to the manager and they have their own taxi that they will add to your bill for 15 euros! 5 euros more than what we paid getting there, but so worth it for the convenience.
Cons:
-Food: I have to note that I'm from San Francisco and just feel like a spoiled brat about food at times. Also, I'm American and we just have different palettes - I'll admit that! While it was definitely good, it missed the mark on a couple places and it was much bigger than expected, so I wish we hadn't done 3-courses.
-I'm a big dummy and didn't go ask to see the wine cellar that has been rated by Wine Spectator as one of the top 5 in the world (and the only on that list in Europe). My fault, not theirs. Wished they'd offered, but again, all on me for not asking.
(1) Prawn Carpaccio: What a beautiful plate. Seriously. Slightly torn up prawns scattered around a plate with pieces of various fruit (pineapple, peaches, strawberry, pomegranate seeds) and a bit of avocado. Light, refreshing, just way too large of a portion.
(2) Stuffed Peppers with Oxtail: Not the prettiest plate (it was largely brown with the red of the sweet peppers). This was my preferred appetizer. The oxtail had wonderful flavor that was perfectly balanced with teh sweet peppers.
(3) Stuffed Crab: Divine but rich. Holy richness - I couldn't actually finish it and they thought I didn't like it, I felt awful because it was good! Pretty presentation literally baked in a crab shell. Definitely worth the try
(4) Hake with Clams (fresh pea sauce): Tableside plating of the boiled fish in a pretty butter and fresh pea sauce. You could tell everything was farm-to-table.
(5) Apple Cake: My favorite item of the night - amazing! I think there was a translation issue here, it was more of an apple tart. Perfect small puff pastry with the thinnest slices of apples on top that I've ever seen - it felt very elevated! The spices were perfect and complemented by the vanilla ice cream.
(6) Caramelized Bread with Mango Ice Cream: Mango ice cream was wonderful. The bread's texture was a bit odd - felt like when you're making french toast and drench it in liquids. Had a carmelized sugar top.
Overall, definitely a good experience getting you out of the downtown San Sebastian area.