Daniel B.
Yelp
We liked Reverence OK, but the experience was a little underwhelming. You never know what you're going to get with hotel restaurants. In my experience, they've been a mixed bag: https://bit.ly/3j7lC0b. Generally, the restaurants are nice and service is fine. It's the food that's hit or miss. The food at Reverence wasn't bad. However, it's not one of the first restaurants I'd recommend. That's a shame because this is one of those places that "I really wanted to like" after reading and seeing social media posts about it. The restaurant is certainly suitable if you're staying at the hotel, but I'm not sure I'd go out of my way to dine here.
Reverence opened in September 2021 in the relatively-new Epicurean Hotel on West Peachtree Street in Midtown. During our visit, complimentary valet parking was available in front of the hotel for restaurant guests. If you valet, remember to bring cash to tip. When we visited, there was only one valet guy and, as a result, valet service was slow. You can also park in the pay deck next door at 1105 West Peachtree -- same driveway. The cost was $3 per 30 minutes. Reverence did not validate parking in this deck.
Reverence piqued my curiosity because it's the signature restaurant of the Epicurean. The Epicurean is a first-of-its-kind hotel for Atlanta, I believe. A quick Google search revealed only one other Epicurean location: Tampa. These are "food-focused" and "culinary-inspired" hotels that are part of Marriott's independent and upscale Autograph Collection. As someone who loves to dine out, I like the concept.
The restaurant, kitchen, bar, lounge, and patio are integrated into the hotel lobby. It's so seamless that we thought the hotel check-in counter, which is at the end of the bar and in front of the kitchen, was where we were supposed to check in for the restaurant. When the hotel employee realized we were trying to check in for the restaurant and not the hotel, he said, "Story of my life." I booked our reservations on OpenTable.
The space is absolutely beautiful. Five stars for interior design and aesthetics. It's definitely got a modern, swanky, and sophisticated vibe. Big, tall windows that look out onto West Peachtree, glossy floors, pendant lighting, an open display kitchen and sleek wraparound bar, see-through wine coolers with a library ladder (neat), and classy button sofas in the lounge. This place looks straight out of a magazine.
The restaurant serves New American cuisine. At the time of writing this review, they're open for breakfast daily, dinner Monday-Saturday, and Sunday for brunch. They used to serve lunch, but announced an end to that in December 2022: https://www.instagram.com/p/ClzQkT7Swo9/?hl=en.
Here's what we had:
Appetizers
* Bacon-Wrapped Ricotta Dates ($15) - maple chili glaze, rosemary, black garlic aioli
* Loaded City Fries ($11) - poached egg, truffle, aioli, chorizo, chimichurri
Salads
* Seasonal Caprese Salad ($15) - tomato, burrata, seasonal fruit, basil, aged balsamico
* Epic Umami House Caesar Salad ($15) - butter biscuit croutons, bonito, romaine, radicchio, egg, green goddess dressing
* Chinese Chicken Salad ($17) - napa cabbage, radicchio, cashew, sesame, wontons
Entrees
* Avocado Ricotta Tartine ($21) - smoked salmon, pancetta, poached egg, yellow frisee
* House Ground Wagyu Burger ($26) - refried 'nduja, tomato chutney, remoulade, local Gouda cheese, fries, plus a fried egg (+$4)
Drink
* Latte ($6)
The food ranged from OK to good. I like what they offered on the menu. The dishes were fun and creative and there was lots to like. Generally, the food was fresh and presented beautifully. The only exception was the House Ground Wagyu Burger. The burger patty looked and tasted overcooked, like too well done. The patty wasn't as juicy, rich, and flavorful as I had hoped. Instead, it was a bit on the tough and chewy side, as far as hamburger patties go. Disappointing. Other than that, I didn't have a problem with anything else. I did like the refried 'nduja (spicy Italian pork sausage) which was spread on the top bun and the tomato chutney. Nice, unique touches.
The apps - Bacon-Wrapped Ricotta Dates and Loaded City Fries - were the best dishes. The fries were decadent and gratifying. The salads were perfectly fine. I preferred the Caprese. The burrata was yummy and the tomatoes were fresh and ripe. I wouldn't describe the Caesar as "Epic," but it was decent. I looked forward to trying the Tartine, but it sort of fell flat for me. It was good, but I was expecting more. The pancetta was a little too tough, and something seemed to be missing from the flavors overall.
Service was good. Our server was Mimi. She was polite and attentive, as was everyone else we interacted with including the manager, an assistant, a chef/food runner, and the hotel check-in staff. There was a lot of staff for not many customers, which felt somewhat awkward until more customers arrived. Again, that's hotel restaurants for you. They can be different.