Eric T.
Yelp
Finally tried this place. I'd been put off a bit by the trendy fusionosity of the ramen choices and was prepared to be that guy complaining about Saratoga ramen (more disappointing than Saratoga pizza, if such a thing is possible). Also pricey-ish. The place is capacious yet not intolerably trendy, and a good choice for fiveish pm when the mob rush to get to the bar at Hamlet & Ghost becomes too tiresome. Made the acquaintance of two friendly bartenders, which is always a good start. Tried the Saratogarashi cocktail (cooperstown beanball bourbon, togarashi, mirabelle plum, fresno pepper, ginger, lemon) which was delicious and not too sweet. Then the charming Zsa Zsa behind the bar offered to make me her specialty Old Fashioned and, again, yum. Spectacular cherry they use. Extra points. My friend had a daily special smoky margarita which was also a delight. Richer and, well, smokier than your average margarita.
Ended up splitting two apps with my friend. First, Shaved Beef Sliders (wasabi/horseradish aioli, kimchi dusted chips, ppang bakery milk bread bun, ramen broth dip). Holy cow. Thrilling layering of flavors and textures, with a decent amount of horseradish. And crunchy chips. Dip your slider in the ramen broth before each bite and, well, heaven.
Decided to be braver and try the Cheesesteak Lo Mein (wok-seared sirloin, bone marrow xo sauce, peppers & onions, provolone cheese), which is exactly the kind of fusiony thing I'd usually avoid like the plague. Surprisingly, I loved it. The sirloin bits were melt-in-your-mouth soft, and I liked the combination of flavors in the sauce. I guess there was some tang from the perhaps melted provolone; I couldn't identify any actual pieces of cheese, which is perhaps just as well, but I think it added some layers to the enticing flavor. I will say places upstate seem to be fond of thicker, chewier noodles for lo mein than I'm used to (and would prefer), and Rhea is no exception. In the dish as prepared the noodles were fine, but I'd hate to discover they were using these in their ramen, too. (Also, while I liked this lo mein, I don't think I'd be in a hurry to get it again. Unlike the fantastic sliders, for which I am already jonesing.)
I was too happily full to try any of the ramens, so can't comment, except my experience on this visit might help quell my skepticism about some of the choices. Definitely next visit.
I must observe that I was both horrified and amused at some of the ramen-eating antics I saw among bar patrons. The male member of an apparently just-engaged couple fished some noodles out of his bowl with his fork, laid them on a nearby plate, and cut them into bite-sized bits before daintily stabbing and ingesting the result. (This would be obscene enough for spaghetti Marina; for ramen, well, this town apparently needs Ramen Jail.) His partner twirled up her noodles using fork and spoon which would've been fine if she had been eating the aforementioned spaghetti. Never before in my life have I witnessed such at a ramen place.
Perhaps Rhea could use an enormous poster/mural illustrating exactly how one eats ramen (noisily) like they have on the wall at Ivan Ramen Slurp Shop at that ridiculous food hall in my nabe in the city. (Or maybe not; I hate that, too.)
Dessert was a sort of deconstructed cheesecake-in-a-jar which tasted far better than it had any right to, which my friend and I happily demolished.
With prices going into orbit as they are these days, I don't know how pricey one might consider this place. It's definitely not inexpensive, and everything is probably a good five bucks more than it might've been only a year or two ago, but that's life. Three drinks, two apps, and dessert came to around $107 before tip. Perhaps this is the new normal. Considering how damn delicious everything was, I can't say it wasn't worth it every penny. I really want those sliders again!
Decor, service, presentation, all excellent. I was glad it wasn't eardrum-bursting loud like so many places today, although perhaps when it is at capacity that might change.
Anyway, based on my admittedly small samplings and only one visit, I can't recommend this place enough.