David Giroux
Google
My opinion comes with all the subjectivity it deserves. After all, who am I to judge the hard work of an entire team, a great chef, and a family pouring their heart and soul into Quattro Passi? I’m just a North American chef who’s had the chance to dine in several Michelin-starred restaurants around the world. So yes, my feedback is shaped by my own background, my palate, and my personal expectations.
It was a beautiful evening. The meal was elegant and, in my opinion, truly reflected the chef’s Italian roots, memories, and love for local ingredients. Everything was well-executed and carefully prepared. Still… I must admit that, at times, I missed that spark, that emotional “wow” moment that leaves you speechless or moves you in some unexpected way. Maybe I just didn’t fully understand some of the culinary messages…could be.
Overall, I tasted good dishes, but very few that I would describe as truly outstanding or memorable. Service was also very good, but I felt that connection between the kitchen and the guests wasn’t always fully there. As a diner, I crave context… stories behind the ingredients, details about the wine pairings, a glimpse into the “why” behind each dish. Unfortunately, I found some inconsistencies: different tables seemed to get different levels of explanation. I even overheard interesting details about dishes I had already eaten, shared with tables that arrived after me.
And then… the desserts. Perhaps it was just the offering that night, but I found them surprisingly simple..not bad at all, but definitely not what I would expect from a three Michelin-star experience. I understand that Italian desserts are often more restrained and less elaborate by tradition… but I still hoped for a little extra creativity or technical flair.
That being said: I ate well, I drank well, and I had a genuinely nice time. But deep down, I left with a small sense of disappointment, simply because I was hoping for something even more unique and emotionally striking at this level.
Again, who am I to judge? This is just one chef’s humble and personal opinion, shaped by taste and life experience.