Roberta's

Italian restaurant · Montauk

Roberta's

Italian restaurant · Montauk

240 Firestone Rd, Montauk, NY 11954

Highlights

This laid-back Mediterranean haven near the train station serves up wood-fired pizzas and a chic vibe, making it a must-visit for both locals and visitors.

240 Firestone Rd, Montauk, NY 11954 Get directions

robertaspizza.com

@robertaspizza

$30–50 · Menu

@infatuation

"The Brooklyn favorite known for its wood-fired pizzas has a new year-round outpost, in the space that used to be Arbor, just outside town by the train station. They’ve come a long way from their original Bushwick-based converted warehouse, but this spot feels somewhat similar to their newer location in Domino Park. Expect a mix of current Brooklynites, former Brooklynites relocated to the suburbs, and wannabe Brooklynites all vying for pizzas like the Bee Sting, Famous Original, and Ursula’s Parade. " - Melissa Kravitz Hoeffner, Team Infatuation

The 19 Best Restaurants In Montauk - New York - The Infatuation

View Postcard for Roberta's

jakuvded

Google

brooklyn style in a montauk vibe. delicious apps, great pizza and speciality drinks to match. a word of mouth find that lived up to the recommendation. server was a delight and food got better with every course. really enjoyed the decor and vibe in and around the venue. just one slight recommendation, upgrade on the bar games. a must go for any local or tourist.

The BTONE Show

Google

Great atmosphere and very good pizza and drinks right off the Montauk train line. 1 minute walk from the train station.

Stacey Corrigan

Google

The servers were very nice but our food came out at completely different times. The kids pasta came out 15 mins before they delivered 1 or our pizzas for a party of 5. We then waited another 20 minutes before I had to ask the busy boy who was clearing our table to check on our food. Then the find out the kitchen forgot our order. Pizza was yummy but would never come back again.

David Laster

Google

Faithful reproductions of the originals plus some additions. The Stracciatella is fantastic.

Xiangyu Yin

Google

Food and service and both excellent. We had a white pizza and bee sting. They are thin Neapolitan style pizzas cooked to perfection. Our favorite appetizer is the asparagus. Not sure why this new restaurant gets so many bad reviews. I feel compelled to share my positive experience.

Linda Holm Soenderskov

Google

Really disappointing experience. The hostess and servers were not only unfriendly, it was as if they made an effort to be rude. When you drop $200 for a meal you expect service to be a little better than what you would get at an airport fast food restaurant. My husband and I got our food fast but my daughter got her pizza after waiting 40 minutes. No explanations or excuses from the staff and had to wait long after our table had been bussed to get our receipt and card back.

PEL Laura

Google

Absolutely the best pizza in Montauk, hands-down! These people get it! The dough, the sauce, and the mozzarella are on point! The appetizers were awesome! The service and the vibe are great!!! Will definitely be back!!

Marek Waldin

Google

I decided to come for one hour while waiting for my train. The service was incredible, and the staff made me feel at home. They were smiley and also kind. The only thing I observed was that the pizza I chose was slightly salty; however, it was not a big deal because I had a great time there.