Roberta's

Italian restaurant · Montauk

1

@infatuation

"The Brooklyn favorite known for its wood-fired pizzas has a new year-round outpost, in the space that used to be Arbor, just outside town by the train station. They’ve come a long way from their original Bushwick-based converted warehouse, but this spot feels somewhat similar to their newer location in Domino Park. Expect a mix of current Brooklynites, former Brooklynites relocated to the suburbs, and wannabe Brooklynites all vying for pizzas like the Bee Sting, Famous Original, and Ursula’s Parade. " - Melissa Kravitz Hoeffner, Team Infatuation

The 19 Best Restaurants In Montauk - New York - The Infatuation
Emily Schindler

240 Firestone Rd, Montauk, NY 11954 Get directions

robertaspizza.com
@robertaspizza

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Bird on the Roof

Restaurant · Montauk

This cozy Montauk spot serves up everything from pancakes to crab cakes, with a full bar and a friendly vibe that keeps diners coming back.

3 Postcards

Montauk Yacht Club

Resort hotel · Montauk

Gurney’s Star Island Resort is a chic lakeside haven perfect for Montauk getaways, boasting nautical decor, a bustling marina, and fab dining experiences.

7 Postcards

Marram

Hotel · Montauk

Nestled on the sandy shores of Montauk, Marram offers a chill beachfront vibe with stylishly minimalist rooms and access to yoga, surfing, and an inviting cafe.

6 Postcards

Ditch Plains

Beaches · Montauk

This popular vacation spot boasts sandy surf beaches, dramatic cliffs, and the beloved local snack shack, Ditch Witch, perfect for families and surfers alike.

2 Postcards

Montauk Manor

Hotel · Montauk

Nestled in a historic 1927 Tudor Revival building, Montauk Manor offers cozy condos with beautiful views, a spa, pools, tennis, and a charming Italian restaurant, perfect for a laid-back getaway.

1 Postcard

Herb's Market

Deli · Montauk

A beloved family-run deli and butcher shop that’s a go-to for epic fried chicken, hearty sandwiches, and perfect beach picnic provisions.

2 Postcards

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

Hotel · Montauk

Gurney's Montauk Resort offers a stylish, beachfront escape with stunning ocean views, cozy cottages, and a luxurious spa, perfect for a summer getaway.

12 Postcards

Scarpetta Beach

Restaurant · Montauk

At Scarpetta in Gurney's Montauk, indulge in handmade pastas and classic Italian fare while soaking in stunning ocean views from the chic outdoor terrace.

3 Postcards

Placēbö Montauk - Restaurant

Restaurant · Montauk

Discover a vibrant eatery in Montauk where Latin flavors meet American classics, boasting delightful seafood, creative cocktails, and a lively party atmosphere.

1 Postcard

Kenny's Tipperary Inn

Motel · Montauk

Kenny's Tipperary Inn is a cozy retreat in Montauk, featuring homey rooms, a lovely garden, and a seasonal pool, all just steps from the docks and local eateries.

0 Postcards