Blake G.
Yelp
Okay, full disclosure...After reading the negative reviews, I went in here for lunch today, really wanting to hate this place. I placed an on-line pick-up order and drove over to get my sandwich, fully expecting the employees to be a-holes and the sandwich to suck. None of that happened.
I parked in the loading zone out front, walked in, the guy behind the counter said, "Sup?...You here for an online order?" I told him I was, gave him my name, he handed me my sandwich, and I was on my way. Granted, my exposure to the guy behind the counter was limited, and I very well may have not liked him if I got to know him better, and he may very well have been a 1st class d!ck, but for the purpose of what he and I were trying to achieve with that interaction, I think it went well...For both of us.
I got home, opened my sandwich, and it was a solid looking turkey sub. I'm kind of a sandwich snob, so I doctored it up with some Marconi "medium hot" giardiniera relish and some of my home-made oil, vinegar, and Italian seasoning, and then dove into the sandwich with 2 hands while my two 160 lb English Mastiffs stared at me from the couch where they sleep 23.5 hours per day with a look of envy on their faces.
The sandwich wasn't mediocre, as I was expecting it to be based on some of the reviews...It was actually pretty darn fantastic! I wouldn't say that it's the absolute best sandwich in Chicago, but I would put it in my TOP 5, and that's saying something, because I also frequent Bari, L' Appetito, J.P. Graziano's, and Conte Di Savoia...Not to mention Manny's, although Manny's is a completely different kind of sandwich shop, obviously.
I am definitely going to be returning to Rosie's, in fact, I'm going to add it into my lunch rotation...And if the guys/gals behind the counter are mean to me in any future visits...Screw it! I'm not going to let some a$$hole get between me and a damn fine sandwich.