Adam S.
Yelp
Rye still has it after all these years, y'all.
It's amazing to have a great LOCAL spot on the Plaza, especially as it's in a major state of flux right now. This spot should be high on anybody's list of spots to peruse when venturing out on the Plaza, IMO.
Most recently, we hit this for birthday brunch for my wife as we've found it's a way better time for the kids to tag along than a dinner might be.
We had:
-The famous Rye cinnamon roll, shared four ways. It's perfection, with loads of frosting and perfectly baked cinnamon dough.
-Black coffee that has a great flavor + a cappuccino, dito.
-The Rye Breakfast; a biscuit and small side of gravy, two eggs, a piece of bacon, piece of sausage, and the best hash brown I've had in a while.
-Kids split a gigantic pancake which is crispy, buttery and tasty all the way around.
-Wife had Eggs Benedict and it got rave reviews as well.
Simply put, EVERYTHING was so good and the service was nice as well. Vibes were high.
I've been here a bunch over the years, including dinner and it always lands well. One thing that stands out from the past, a late summer dish, their
Heirloom Tomato Salad. I could've just eaten ten plates of this and called it a night. Late summer heirloom tomatoes over a yogurt cheese labneh with some crisp sweet corn to contrast. (Side note, they won't have tomatoes off season which is a great sign. No one wants those hard, whitish "tomatoes," and to me it shows their commitment to real, local produce)
I made a reservation on Tock which in theory was easy enough, but it was a bit annoying that I also had to call and wait on hold to confirm my reservation, as well as confirm it again via text a day later.
All in all, this spot does an amazing job without an atmosphere that "tries too hard" and it's in a perfect spot on the eastern edge of the Plaza overlooking the Nichols fountain.
If it's been a minute since you've been here, I'd highly recommend it!