COMFORT by the Cross-Eyed Cricket

Excellent service! (Sit in Rick's section!) We each ordered the 2-piece blacked catfish and it was OUTSTANDING! The quality, portion size and flavor was spot on. $22 for 2 pieces of fish also includes soup or salad AND two sides!!! I chose the potato soup, cucumber salad, and dressing. My husband opted for Caesar salad, baked potato and Mac & cheese (don't judge; we had skipped lunch!) We didn't have any special beverages but they do offer a full bar. We'll be back sooner than later!

We went for the Valentine’s Day dinner at Comfort. I have been there 2-3 times before this and the food and service was way better. To start my boyfriend went to the bathroom when we first arrived and said there was toilet paper everywhere and the bathroom was disgusting; I wanted to give them the benefit of the doubt because I liked the restaurant the last time I went but this is where it goes south. So we get our first course the spinach dip looked like it had been sitting out so long he was scared to try to shrimp cocktail in fear he might get sick. They did have good rolls and strawberry butter which sadly that and the desert was the best part of the experience for the meal supposedly worth $168, and DRINKS a sweet tea and a coke weren’t included apparently. Which to me is insane considering it was t even alcohol but oh well I guess. Next we decided to get the Filet Mignon out of the other courses we could’ve had that came with roasted veggies and a twice baked potato, the potato was okay but we had ordered a WELL-DONE steak and when it came out the FIRST time it was still bloody, we have had this happen before and we just asked very nicely if the waitress could send it back; she ignored my please and thank you and just grabbed the plates and took them. When the steaks came out the SECOND time they were still red as can be and looked as if they just made sure to burn the outside and sear the part that was cut. Now I understand everyone’s steak preferences are different but if we are paying $168 for the meal we wanted our steak cooked how we like it. What is sad is that I used to really like this place and I wasted money trying to have a nice outing with my boyfriend and I definitely won’t be back. Also would like to add the fact the steak knife provided was not even clean SEE PIC BELOW.

We were excited to try Comfort in Evansville, but our experience ended up being just okay. The mac and cheese had almost no flavor, (even my three year old wouldn’t touch it) which was disappointing considering how good it looked on the menu. We also asked for my daughter’s meal to be served without grapes because she’s young and has choked on them in the past. Unfortunately, her plate still came out with two grapes on it, which was concerning. With the cost of food today, the meal really should be great, not just average. The atmosphere was nice and the staff was friendly, but the execution in the kitchen needs improvement.

Definitely my favorite restaurant in Evansville. I’ve went three times, and each time I ordered something different. Everything was delicious. The dining area is a nice rustic feel inside and there’s a seating area out front. The waitresses/waiters were nice enough and kind of attentive. Can’t wait to return and try another dish!

Never Again! We ordered from there over the weekend country. Fright's steak was way undercooked and the batter still had flour. Two of our sides were missing and there were no rolls. This is our very first time eating there.And I promise I would not recommend it to anybody.

Good vibes. The atmosphere is just like the name. Comfortable, but classy. First time at a cross-eyed cricket establishment and I can say I’m impressed. Todd is super genuine and that’s so nice to see coming from such a conservative area to here. I came here looking for a good time, and the good times just keep on rolling! Got to try to strawberry butter! So good! Good food and good fun start with Comfort!

Everything was good. Seasoning on the food, temperature was good, friendly staff and the price is good for the portion of food you get.

D'Shae was such a great server and the food was fantastic! She went above and beyond. Highly recommend the loaded tots, and the Beef Manhattan!

Amazing food, amazing service! It was super cute, perfect for our birthday celebration!

The atmosphere was wonderful the wait staff and all their employees were helpful, a little more pricey than other restaurants but worth it

All of the food here is worth the price, good quality, service and atmosphere. I love coming here with my boyfriend for special occasions:)

We visited this past weekend and stayed downtown so we decided to eat at Comfort, which we previously had eaten breakfast at. We were sat in the basement bar area which I didn't know they had. Collins was our server and he took such great care of us. He was knowledgeable on what was or wasn't gluten-free. We got the Brussel sprouts as an appetizer and they were so good! My salmon dinner was cooked perfectly. Collins made me an apple cinnamon margarita and it was so delicious, I could've drank a lot of them. The atmosphere of the bar area was so relaxed. We didn't feel rushed at all. I highly recommend visiting Comfort if you're in the area.

First time! I was brought here by a group a friends who had nothing but wonderful things to say, so I was very excited to get a taste. I had the fried catfish, sweet potato fries, Mac & cheese, and a side salad. The catfish was good. It was fried well, and the texture was nice. However, the flavor was more mild than I would usually prefer. Still good, just didn't really have the signature "catfish" taste to it. The sweet potato fries tasted good, but weren't crispy at all. They were soft on the outside, and most could bend in half without breaking. Would've liked a tiny dusting more of salt, but the flavor itself was satisfactory. The Mac & cheese was also okay. Not bad, but certainly didn't taste like homemade comfort style Mac & cheese. The cheese tasted heavily professed and was giving me the idea of velveeta. It was more cafeteria style Mac & cheese than comfort food style, but again, not bad; just not really what I expected. Our service was wonderful. All of the staff was kind and communicative. I really wanted to try a cheesecake, but they were unfortunately completely sold out of all of their cheesecakes. I will certainly come back when I am in town again, and I look forward to trying more on their menu. I feel like there are probably some real gems on there that I didn't get to try this time around.

If you ever crave homecooking while in Evansville, stop by here. The food was really good and filling. I had the Chicken and Noodles with Green Beans. The homemade roll with the strawberry butter was a nice surprise. Next time, I will make sure to save room for dessert.

Went in for Sunday brunch. Omelette, waffle, and a Bloody Mary. Worst excuse for a Bloody Mary I've ever had. This is a very basic drink probably learned day one of bartender school. Vodka, tomato juice, some spicy stuff to add flavor (salt, pepper, Worchestershire sauce, Tabasco sauce). This abomination had whiskey in it. That's NOT a "Bloody Mary" - that's a Bloody Derby or Bloody Molly (depending on what else is in there). If you're going to sell a Bloody Mary, sell a Bloody Mary. Don't sell something else and call it a Bloody Mary. i noticed the difference on the menu and specifically asked for a proper Bloody Mary. Didn't get that. Some nice matron came by and asked how my meal was (I hadn't gotten it yet, but she pointed at my drink and asked about it). I told her all of this and she seemed somewhat aghast that their Bloody Mary wasn't just Vodka, tomato juice, et al. and promised to speak with the bartender. I never heard from her again. Drink wasn't comp'd and wasn't replaced. The food itself was middling to good. The arthichoke hearts in the omelette were inexplicably tough and chewy and the waffle was undercooked. A bit under $40 for this mess. Probably won't be back.

What a perfect place to celebrate my son's birthday. We were seated downstairs. Our server was simply impeccable! So willing to make our dining experience a pleasant one!!! She catered to our every need. Our food was OUTSTANDING! The pineapple mimosa was a wonderful treat! Another table was celebrating a birthday, so we celebrated and sang Happy Birthday together!!! Probably one of the best dining experiences I've had!

One of the best meals I have ever had easily. Very impressive in pretty much every way! Service was very fast as well and it was a very nice and quiet atmosphere. High recommends.

Me and my family ate here today and Andrew was our server. He was amazingly kind, polite, great manners and just all around great Server! We will be back because of him!!

So many items to choose from plus everyone in our party of got something different and we all loved what we got. The waitress was very friendly and checked on us a number of times. I love the decor of the restaurant, it's both homie and relaxing.

Food tasted okay although quantity of fried chicken was MUCH too low for price. Rolls served late and without plates. (Who does that?) Waitress was inattentive not listening well. Requested drinks and to-go boxes had to be requested multiple times. Electronic device used by waitress needed to be replaced and then appeared to be difficult to use. Was with a group and didn't want to make a fuss. Online reservation system also malfunctioned requiring multiple calls.

Great food, drinks and service. Went for lunch and had a Buffalo Chicken sandwich. It is tasty and big. Had a good selection of drinks.

This place is a great choice for a cozy brunch in Evansville. The place was pretty busy during regular breakfast weekend hours, so that has to be a good sign! Full of quirky decor and interesting food options! An egg's Benedict on a fried green tomato is an innovative idea! However, I felt like it was missing a bread component, the portion felt a little small without it. I was glad I ordered the biscuits and strawberry butter, which were delicious! The omelets are huge and full of toppings!

Food - is simply delicious-the banana pudding French toast OMG this is a must order. The location is convenient, it's downtown. Staff is friendly

The reviews and photos make this place look amazing. They don't do it justice. We were here for a family dinner on the Sunday before Christmas and we had a lovely experience. The ambiance is great and we love the eclectic décor, especially the lighting fixtures and the metal cross-eyed cricket riding a bicycle mounted on the wall. The natural-edged wood tables are beautiful. We had a variety of entrees and sides - filet, pork chops, and fried chicken, all of which were excellent. There are three types of gravy options for the mashed potatoes, three types of fries (French, American, and German) and multiple other side options. The green beans are truly old-school and delicious. The creamed corn was very good, as were the mashed potatoes and fries. The portions are HUGE. Prepare to take leftovers home. I have rarely seen such beautifully prepared pork chops and they were excellent. The steaks were perfectly prepared, and the fried chicken was light, crispy, and got a rave review. Our server, Niah, did an outstanding job - she was attentive, friendly, got the smallest details right (I like extra ice in my water and my dad likes his water room temperature), etc. The old-fashioned was excellent. My dad is very particular about this classic drink and Comfort nailed it. We all loved it. This downtown Evansville gem is our new go-to.

Great food and service. Everything is always wonderful! Definitely recommend the buffalo chicken

The food here is AMAZINGLY good!!! The chicken tenders were tasty and the fries hit the spot man, service did take a while but the wait was worth it! Would recommend 89/100

I attended a private event on the fourth floor in the "Upper Room" Grand Ballroom. What a wonderful event space! Upon entry, many of the guests complemented the chandeliers and overall rustic yet elegant design of the space. It would make for a a great wedding reception venue. The catered food was just okay - primarily fried foods and sliders. My only note is that it was not wheelchair accessible and required going up four flights of stairs. Per their website, it looks like elevator access is coming soon, but not in place as of March 2024.

Our dinner out with friends was a highlight of our visit to Evansville. The staff was extremely attentive and accommodating. We didn't just one server -- but two! And the food was delicious! We will return on our next visit to the city.

The food was delicious---I was eating so forgot to take pics! The catfish was spot on--so much food! The rolls were excellent! Service and decor were fabulous--what a gem!

For our girlfriend breakfast out, we chose Comfort. I've not been there for quite awhile but remember liking their breakfast. We got there just as it opened at 9 am. I ordered the Veggie Skillet with German fries. The skillet also includes biscuits and gravy. I passed on the gravy. The portions are ample and seasoned perfectly. Our server was attentive, the place was clean, and the meals arrived quickly. We'll go back there again for sure.

Great place to eat. Love the southern modern decor. Waitress was very friendly and great at answering our questions. I had the chicken and dumplings with fried cabbage and Mac n cheese everything tasted great. My hubby got the Buffalo sandwich and really liked it. Portions are big. I also had the pineapple mimosa which was very good treat. The sweet tea is trie southern sweet sweet tea just the way my hubby likes it. We will be back.

What an awesome surprise! We were in town for a basketball tournament recently and came across this little gem of a restaurant in Evansville, and we were so impressed with its eclectic "shabby chic" atmosphere and hometown food. It was delicious. We had a super sweet and attentive server, who never let our glasses go empty and was very happy to make suggestions about the menu choices. She did not disappoint! We loved the strawberry butter with popover rolls!!

Food was hot and flavorful. The menu options made it hard to choose but I think anything you have will be great. Our hostess was friendly and our waitress awesome. Coffee never dropped below a half cup. Atmosphere and ambiance was warm and inviting. Tables and chairs cool and comfortable. Highly recommend

Everything about this place is great! The salmon was cooked to perfection and the service was absolutely incredible

Very, very overpriced. Burger overcooked and burnt on the outside. No dressing of any kind on the Turkey Club sandwich-very dry. Cashier brought back incorrect change from bill. This was corrected.

My wife and I went there on a Saturday afternoon. We were seated in the lower level. Our seats were in the middle where everyone had to walk around us to go upstairs. We kept waiting to at least get our drink order taken....twenty minutes later I'd had enough and proceeded upstairs to the check in desk to voice my displeasure. He was the one that seated us. He presented us with a $50 gift card along with several apologies. We left and never came back. Gave the give card to my son in law.

wonderful experience! Food was wonderful service top-notch. We are repeat customers and love it here.

The best breakfast I've enjoyed in a long time. The biscuits were PERFECT. Denver omelet was exactly right. Service was on point. Can't recommend it highly enough. And priced reasonably. I'll be back often. Amazing on all point.

A very good venue here at this place. Right downtown made it easy for us to get to the Ford Center and watch the show. Excellent drinks and food.

This is my favorite place to eat when we are in Evansville. Food is always so good. We will continue to come back.

I was hoping for a decent experience, instead I got a brand new server that hadn't mastered the menu yet. I spent $30 for one person. I had a veggie omelette with ham and a side of bacon for my dog. They use American cheese in the $13 omelette, which I feel like that's blasphemy! I was up charged for egg whites and ham. I was told I had option said potatoes so o chose hashbrowns. They were burnt and NOT part of the meal . I was charged separately, but they took that off. I chose bacon because they said a side of chicken would be $13!!!!! I am travel all over the country and this $30 breakfast should have been one of the best I have ever had for this price. Sadly, I'd give it 2 stars. Go to Dennys It's cheaper

Bryce at The Collective is the BEST! This place may be Evansville's best kept secret. Off Main Street, take the flight of stairs up to The Collective and ask for Bryce. He'll make sure you have everything you want for the perfect evening out.

Meal was fast-food average in taste and presentation. Vegan and vegetarian choices were highly limited - nearly non-existent.

Started with a peach Bellini and vodka berry. Peach Bellini was the best drink. We ordered two breakfast scrambles (veggie and chorizo). Ended with bread pudding French toast. Everyone within the restaurant wanted to know about the French toast as it sizzled on the skillet with fruit on top. Melt in your mouth. Would def come back.

Delicious food, amazing service, and reasonable prices! Megan was an outstanding server! Try the Buffalo chicken tenders - they are the best around. And don't get me started on the rolls and strawberry butter.....wow!!!!

Ricky was an EXCELLENT server. He was knowledgeable and friendly. Food was fantastic! Gorgonzola- pear salad, blackened catfish, German fried potatoes and the best-ever cream corn! Will be back as often as possible. Even had great cheesecake for a birthday treat!!! Thanks Comfort!!

Have been there for lunch or brunch several times when I visit the city. Great menu choices, sizable portions, well-served. Experienced wait staff. Can get a trifle noisy, but won't drown out conversation. I like it a lot.

We decided to eat here on Thanksgiving with family. So glad we did The meal was fabulous! Very festive too. Because of following Covid safety guidelines, instead of a buffet, everything was brought to the table, and then guests could ask for whatever else they wanted to eat beyond the initial first plate. Our server went above and beyond; was friendly, attentive and worked hard to see that we had everything we needed. The server even told a few jokes and kept us entertained. The food was all homemade and delicious! Cooked to perfection! Seasoned very well. My favorite items were the roast beef, corn, sweet potato casserole and the chicken and dumplings. This is an excellent place for your Thanksgiving meal. Highly recommend eating here but make reservations. We had reservations so didn't have to wait to be seated.

Delicious food and Jocelyn V was an excellent server. I couldn't decide what to order and her recommendation was perfect!

First time there and I enjoyed it. Nice environment. Good cocktails and food. Everyone appeared pleasant.

I love going to Comfort when I am here for work. The vibe is comfortable and welcoming. I sat at the bar downstairs and Tosha is very personable and accommodating. She sings to the songs in the background while cleaning glasses and makes drinks for the customers. Jocelynn is funny too! I always get the fillet with the stuffed mushrooms for an app, but next time I venture out on the menu. I will definitely be coming back!

So disappointing-especially after hearing good things! Took a long time friend visiting from out of town for breakfast. The waitress was very poor- no silverware, no drink follow up, no meal follow-up. The turkey sausage gravy had a very un-appetizing shade of yellow-too gross to eat! The bacon was not crisp-but cold as were the eggs. Everything was obviously not freshly prepared but taken from their earlier buffet? Definitely not returning! Definitely sub-par. Sticking with Nellie's- if you want a HOT fresh, reasonably priced and generous breakfast! Really cannot recommend this establishment in any way!

Stopped by here for lunch while visiting Evansville. The ambiance in this place is awesome -- very welcoming and friendly! Service was amazing! My spinach and chicken salad with hot bacon dressing was PERFECT! There are so many amazing things on the menu that I wish I could have tried but I was looking for a lighter lunch option and the salad did not disappoint! The raspberry mule was a bit sweeter than I would prefer but not enough to deter my 5-star review! And, if you would have told me that strawberry butter was something I needed to try, I would have told you that you were crazy, but being that it was a bonus to the meal, I figured I'd give it a shot! So glad I did! Delicious!!

If you're looking for some good comfort food, this is place. The fried chicken was cooked perfectly crispy but not greasy. The Mac n Cheese was excellent. And Coke slaw was tangy. Great service and nice family atmosphere.

Bread Pudding French Toast absolutely blew my mind. It is a must have. Do yourself a favor and experience the magic

Excellent ambiance and service at this nicely located restaurant on main which had plenty of options for breakfast lunch and dinner. Walking in there was a very delicious Alma.Permeating is permeating the hostess stand. I tried the veggie skillet with german potatoes and a pear and gorgonzola salad. Both were great, but I wish that there were more plant based options.

Neat place my first time visiting I had the chef's salad it would be better if served in an over size bowl. Nothing would stay on the plate. Ut it was delicious.