Pope's Pizza

Classy bar and restaurant for a pizza place. Music outside and doors that open when the weather is nice. All around a really nice atmosphere. The pizzas have a real crisp crust, the kind with a slight char on the bottom. We liked the supreme and the chicken pesto. The meatballs and focaccia bread appetizers were solid. The drinks and the service were excellent. Good stuff, just a little pricey for smaller pizzas. We would eat it again.

Food, service, and atmosphere were all excellent. Pizza was very good. Our bartender Devin was excellent, but the drinks here are weak. Not their fault, they have to pour through regulators and it is only a 1 oz shot, rather than a normal 1.5 oz. Didn't realize that at the time until we saw the receipt. My wife had a Tito's and soda, and it tasted like all soda. My advice...stick to beer or wine at this place, then you'll know what you are getting and won't feel ripped off.

From the moment we walked into Pope’s Pizza, we were warmly greeted and seated right away. Our server was incredibly attentive—she checked on us often and even brought refills without us needing to ask. We started with the pesto fries, and they were perfect—crispy, flavorful, and a great appetizer. Then came the pizza... and wow. Hands down the best pizza I’ve ever had. The wood-fired crust was perfectly crisp, not greasy or soggy, and the garnishes, including fresh parmesan, added just the right touch. Every bite was packed with flavor. The atmosphere made the experience even better—relaxed and welcoming, with a live performer playing great music in the background. Pope’s is definitely a place I’ll be coming back to. If you’re looking for amazing food and a great dining experience, this is it!

A very enjoyable evening. Live music, delicious pizza, amazing dessert and attentive service. I thought the prices are a great value. I definitely will be back.

We ordered the Sicilian Meatballs for an appetizer which is a pork and beef blend. It comes in an order of 5. These were nice sized meatballs and were served with a warm red sauce. The meatballs had a little spice to them, but were overall seasoned nicely. For dinner we ordered the Classic Caesar and the Cupped Pepperoni Pizza. The Caesar was a Caesar. The Cupped Pepperoni pizza was a stone baked Neapolitan crust. This is a traditional pizza style from Naples, Italy. The stone helps distribute heat evenly which makes a perfectly cooked pizza, which this definitely was. My wife had a bite and immediately said how good it was and wanted more. (She even ate some later as leftovers, which is huge). Our server, Jacob, was so engaging, personable and just overall wonderful. We spoke with the General Manager, Alex, who informed us that they make almost everything fresh in house. The meat for the meatballs they even grind in house. He said that if they can’t make something fresh in house, that item is made specifically for them. We had a great experience here, and will 100% be back to try more items on their menu. If you want to see other restaurant reviews, follow us on Facebook and Instagram @gbdiningdykes

First time at Popes pizza. Advertised as authentic Italian food which is really stretching it. Ordered Sicilian meat balls and a Pesto chicken pizza. The meat balls were nothing special and the same with the sauce. The Chicken pesto pizza was really not good. The chunks of chicken were dry, and the pizza had some basil laid on top. I couldn’t identify and pesto. I love all kinds of pizza, but this was not good. Service was good. Pizza offering is a bit strange. Prices on the higher side for the amount and quality of food. Very limited draft beer selection. Was not busy for a Friday night.

Can't comment on service as I placed an online pick up order, but it was ready when I went to pick it up and it was delicious. We had the Sicilian style cupped pepperoni and the Marcy-Holmes. Both were very tasty. Love the chewy crust. They are a little pricey for the size. We got 2 and it fed 2 adults, one teenage boy and one pre-teen boy. Not something we can afford to do regularly but definitely a nice treat

This place has a great atmosphere and feels like it would be an ideal spot to hang during a Packers game. It’s new, spacious, and very clean. Unfortunately, that is where the positives end. I ordered the meatball sub for a weekday lunch, and it was dry, lacking flavor, and overall disappointing. The restaurant was completely empty at lunchtime, which probably should have been a sign. The one highlight was our server, who was excellent, friendly, and attentive. She provided great service despite the circumstances. Overall, the environment and service were solid, but the food fell short. I cannot recommend it based on this experience.

Perhaps the best pizza I have experienced in my 55 years on this earth. The crust on our pepperoni was crisp and airy and just leaves you wanting more. Meatballs for the appetizer were also banging. Sauce should be illegal as it's highly addicting. Wow it's good. I'm hoping it was a busy night as the service was a bit under par. I don't need someone hovering, but a check in now and then would be nice. But again, they may have been busy. Loved the duo playing on stage tonight. Made a really great night even greater.

After hearing good things, I thought I would try it out. We got a pizza and the meatballs with a beer. The meatballs were terrible and mostly left uneaten. The fettuccine noodles were thick and almost chewy. It's different, I'm not sure in a good way. The pizza was okay. The pepperoni is good but the napoleon crust was tough. I didn't like the crust at all. We were able to try a friend's ravioli, it's good but a lemon flavor within. Very different than other ravioli that I have had. While the place is very open inside, it was quiet as we were some of the only guests. If it were busy, I'm guessing it's very loud inside. Simply, for the price vs experience, I won't be rushing back.

Decent pizza, but horrendous service and feels like a soulless hotel restaurant despite being nestled next to Lambeau. Had live music, but inside it was just a meh experience.

went on a Sunday afternoon not busy at all. One bartender wasn't charge. I think of the entire bar and seating area took a while to get service at first. Place is beautiful again you can tell it's a new business. We got a pasta and an appetizer both were delicious .

Love this place. Had an awesome bartender, Devon. The food was excellent. We had the meatball pasta, Italian beef sandwich and Quattro pizza. All the food was very good. All the staff were friendly. Will definitely be back next time we are in Green Bay.

Had really high hopes for this place. Food was good, server was very attentive and rounding on us frequently. Only downside is the place was dead - would be really fun atmosphere I'm sure so I hope it becomes more popular!!

I was so SO happy to stumble upon this place during opening weekend! It's located in a new building that is composed of three different restaurants and each had a very different vibe (in a good way)! After eating at Pope's (shoutout to our server Rachel) and experiencing fast, attentive service, we went upstairs to Cowboy Mac's for drinks and good live music. Again, super impressed with the whole vicinity especially during the crowd from the Packer game! Will definitely make this a recurring spot when we come back in town!!

Will was an excellent bartender, made us feel welcome in a setting we are not accustomed to! Absolute legend!

Love this restaurant! Perfect place to take the family with fresh flavors and a great drinks! The menu has something for everyone and the service is great. I love the way that the appearance is classic, yet modern. The patio is a great place to sit and enjoy music on the weekends. Love that everything is made in house and the quality of product reflects that!

The ravioli was amazing, as were the truffle mozzarella sticks. And Cayden was an awesome server!

greasy food, chicken in Caesar salad were thin strips of chicken thigh croutons seemed to be torn up pieces of day old bread truffle mozzarella sticks were greasy and not hot