Two Fat Guys Italian Gourmet Deli

This was the first time having Christmas dinner catered this year, so we were a little bit nervous, but we love there sandwiches and figured why not give 2 Fat Guys a try. Well, it couldn't have been any better, everyone loved it. Everything was delicious and I for one, am a tough critic. We ordered trays of chicken parm, meat lasagna, eggplant parm, orreciette with peas and pancetta, an antipasta tray and a dessert/ cookie tray. It was all packaged very well. We will definitley be ordering from them in the future. Not to mention they have a great friendly staff for all your help. A+ 👍🏼

I had the "Bay Ridge" Hero. Honey Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo & Mustard on a Hero sub. I paired it with a side of Pesto & a Hank's Birch Beer. Let me tell ya! Two Fat Guys really Delivered, it was Delicious AND Satifying. DEFINITELY GOING BACK AGAIN.👍👍

Always a good sign when the line is out the door! I am a snob when it comes to Italian sandwiches, and this place absolutely delivered! I wish I didn’t live 3 hours away or I would eat here every week. Such an incredible menu. These guys are doing it right.

I went to Two Fat Guys for the first time today. I will say I was very impressed. Not only was my hero amazing, but the other products they sold inside made me feel like I was young again going shopping with my Italian grandmother. I also took home a little container of the rainbow cookies which are delicious. I’m not really big into peppers, but I will say my hero was not only packed full of fresh boars head prosciutto, but the roasted red peppers added a nice taste. Definitely recommend you try it out! I will definitely be back.

First time in—- wow what a delight!! We got 2 sandwiches both were excellent! My hubs got a chicken parm and I asked them to make me a custom sandwich— which they happily did. My version of a chicken cordon blue sandwich. The price was awesome for $11 the sandwiches were huge!!! And packed stuffed! We also got a cannoli but were both too full to enjoy it at the moment. Dessert later!!!

OMG. What a great find. We were in PSL and stopped in the deli. What a wonderful experience. The menu offerings are extensive. It took us over 15 minutes to decide which sandwich we wanted. We ordered and then looked around at all the other amazing offerings. We each got a sandwich on a roll : perfectly cooked and sliced roast beef with mustard and cole slaw-delcious combo (The Yankees). Chicken cutlet, fresh mozz, tomato and red pepper, our second choice (The Prospect Park). Both were fresh and perfectly crafted. We also puchased a eggplant parm dinner and 2 mac and cheese balls. The staff was super helpful.

I got The 15th Avenue and added horseradish, this sandwich is what dreams are made of. 🤤😮‍💨 Thick cuts of fresh mozzarella, stacked with juicy roast beef. It hit the spot. I don't know how I haven't been here before but I already can't wait to go back and check out the rest of what they have.

I went here on my lunch break and I'm glad I did. Me and my coworker got the Anthony special and the Coney Island on rolls. They were packed with meat and it was so delicious. I really wish I lived in the area so I could come here all the time. I'm down in Wellington and we don't have a deli like this. I highly recommend this place and can't wait to enjoy it again.

Great service & Subs are really good!! We've been back several times since we moved to PSL.

Being brutally honest with 45 years of experience, this place reminds me of something potentially out of the 50s 60s. They definitely have the ingredients I ordered an old-fashioned New England grinder. It was excellent. As far as the staff 0000. I will never go back. I will recommend it because the quality of the food is good. Maybe you'll have better luck than me. This is why they only get two stars. They could've got five.

Like a little slice of New York in Florida. This place is awesome. Ordered a couple of sandwiches and I kid you not drove down the road and had them 6 minutes later. All kinds of deli meats, sandwiches, and Togo meals that looked and smelled great. Service was super fast! The place feels like you are stepping into your favorite spot in the city. Almost forgot it was 95 degrees and humid as heck outside!

OMG ~ What a delightful Lil gem I found here is PSL Service was superb, friendly and oh so warm and vey welcoming made me feel as if I grew up w/them in NY

Delicious Italian Deli in Port St. Lucie. It reminds me of the places where I grew up in Bensonhurst. I ordered the Mediterranean (Prosciutto di parma, mortadella, soppressata, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, oil and vinegar on a hero) and a cannoli. All the meats were cut super thin just how I like it. The cannoli had a crispy shell and the cream had the perfect consistency. They make their own homemade mozzarella and have lots of dinners prepared that change daily.I highly recommend.

Literally the next day we got the same sandwiches because they were so good! My boyfriend's mom went and got a dessert as well and his dad came and he really enjoyed the food as well! Staff is super kind and we will be back if we are in the area.

If you are looking for authentic fresh made sweet, or hot Italian sausage, then look no further than the Two Fat Guys from Brooklyn. Their sausage is made fresh each week in house using fresh lean pork and fresh Italian herbs you will taste in every bite. Upon another visit I tried their fresh made eggplant rolletini. The heat and serve meal will rival some of the best Italian restaurants in our area. When you visit take time to browse the many Italian delicacies, including Italian pastries.

Looking for the best Italian subs around? Look no further than this spot. Delicious fresh mozzarella and subs are amazing.

This place is my go to place for quality sandwiches. My 2 go to sandwich subs are meatball parm and egg plant parm. First, the bread is the right size, texture and has a great taste. Next there is no skimping on the ingredients, which taste awesome. Last, the value is there for what you get. I've tried these types of subs from their competition in the area and they remain my top choice. Finally, while I am only focusing on take out sandwiches, there is plenty of other tasty items to choose from. Give it a try.

We did A take out! Sandwiches were beautiful( I Had the #8 roast beef, plenty of it too! Sexy perfect med rare, tomatoes, fresh mozzarella Yum! Others had the #2 was a hit!! We had ours in a hard roll. Can't wait to try another! Sadly messed up and forgot to snap one! Place is great and had lotsa things. Casual and yum!

My boyfriend and I were on the hunt for a sub spot and so glad we picked this spot to check out! Frankie took care of us when we told him it was our first time. Feels like a place straight out of NY filled with authentic goods and true Italian hospitality. The sandwiches are the best bang for your buck. They're LOADED and flavorful. Their cannoli is the best I've had. We were also introduced to a new dessert, sfogliatelle, which they got in fresh from NY that day and that blew my mind. Beautiful crispy layers with cream filling - it's a must try if you've never had it. Can't wait to go back and try more things!

Frankly I'm disappointed! I called the store to ask them if they had Italian sausages with no fennel, a gentleman told me that they had some. In the afternoon, we stopped at the store to buy all sorts of things, and Italian sausages with no fennel. Today for lunch, I made myself a nice sandwich in a panini with eggplants and peppers and sausage. I was disappointed when I tasted fennel in my sandwich, I hate fennel, it tastes like licorice and it ruins the flavor of everything! I threw away two pounds of sausages, I hate being taken for a fool like that!! Era la nostra prima e ultima volta li! Hai perso un cliente!

Excellent food. And sandwiches. Feels like you transport to ny when you walk in. Great service

I'm born in Brooklyn and grew up on LI. This is the real deal! You will not find a better hot hand made sub anywhere. This place is spectacular. I got the sausage and peppers with sauce and cheese. Delicious!!!

Great selection of Italian products! It's a tiny place but they have a lot of stuff. Give it a try!

Absolutely love this place. Not very many Italian specialties market up in the PSL area. This place hits the mark. Very friendly staff and owners. Small places , but they carry a lot of products. Sandwiches are out of this world. If you don't see it on the board, they will probably make it for you. Excellent prepared counter and nicely stocked accompaniments for your meals. Don't pass up this little gem.

Had a party for my daughter's 40th birthday. Ordered trays of ziti, chicken Franchise, penne with broccoli & shrimp and an antipasto. I have to say the boss went over and above. Everything was delicious and beyond my expectations. Thank you so much. For making this day so special and saving me a lot of work. We will cater all our events and will spread the word. Thank you again.

I don't know how you can not like this place other than they may not have what you want . I get a sandwich and it's a sandwich . Not some jersey sandwich place . You get what you pay for and that's meat on a sandwich. Staff is friendly and always busy . Take care of them folks !! Thank you carmine for always treating me like family .

I will send another review with pictures later but I couldn't let another day go by without reviewing this place. AWESOME! A little slice of Italian heaven in PSL. if you're lucky, when you go in they'll have the breaded chicken pasta salad. My fave. My boys always get the Italian sub. It's really good aside from the bread being a little too hard. That is my only negative. The staff are great! Although we are sad when we think of going on Sunday, they are closed and I'm glad they take one day off. This place is definitely a staple for us.

We ordered take out on the rating in Yelp. The heroes were excellent. Fresh meats and cheeses. Plenty of toppings. The eggplant sandwich was fabulous. Tried the Italian cookies and sfogliatella - delicious!!! Loved all the Italian specialties in the store and all the fresh salads on display. We will definitely be back to try more!!!

As soon as you walk in, you're greeted by multiple people who appear to take pride in their business. The couple items we purchased were not enough to truly rate the food, however we will be back. It looks like everything is good, and the owner is very friendly and worth supporting.

Small little run in and run out place. All the food in the cases are homemade and really beautiful looking. I ordered a chicken cutlet hero with roasted red peppers and mozzarella. Really good but could only eat half. Staff were friendly and fast.

Omg, it was super hot outside and the line was out the door. I was like no thank I got back in and then the little voice inside said go back inside. I am so happy I did it was like I died and went to Heaven. The food was amazing and the line went so fast. Definitely go! I come down from Vero two times a month now.

I heard about this place from so many people from my foodie friends.I decided to go and it wasn't what to expect! When I walked in, I saw wall to wall of Italian goodness. The place was busy but the food was everywhere ! You named it they had it.customer service was spot on! I kinda took a quick view of the kitchen area prep area to it was clean and organized!

OMG There are no words! You must experience it yourself!!! The best sandwich!! I felt like I was on Arthur Ave . In the Bronx again ! Best sub ... everything nice and fresh ! A real Italian deli !!! Service is fast . Don't get scared that it's packed ! They move fast !! For a tiny place , they have a great system!

We don't get on the Gatlin side of town very often but when we do, we stop at two fat guys. Subs are outstanding we love the old school Italian deli style of the establishment and my wife loves the fresh Motz.

Would you just look at all this deliciousness! The Flatbush sandwich was absolutely amazing. Hubby had the Yankee and he couldn't finish the whole thing it was so big. The prepared food also looked great, as did the various types of sausages. Will be back to pick up some for the grill. Liked that they also had a variety of products from Italy too. Will be back!

Came here recently for lunch. Anything here in Florida that comes from NY is always worth a try. Got a roast beef sandwich. Even though it looked small it was very good and held together excellent. No mess at all after eating it. For the price and the economic conditions we are currently in, it's very reasonable. You definitely feel the new yorkness when you come here and definitely the Italian with all the items, products and selections they have here.

Their sandwiches are fresh and delicious. Their ready-made meals, while pricey are very good.

Heard about this place through Baldy Eats. We love a good sandwich shop. Be prepared to have some patience when you come here. We thought 2:30 would be a slow time to try it out and it absolutely was NOT. It went from 4 ppl ahead of us to a line to the door by the time we paid. Some people walked in, saw the line and left. The sub rolls they use for their hoagie are not my jam. It left the corners of my mouth raw. If we ever go again I'll try out a roll which looks a lot softer. The contents of the hoagie would slide out of the bread with every bite. This is just a personal gripe. I got a small container of the German potato salad which was the best I've had in a long time. My husband got the cucumber salad to go with his hoagie and loved it. We also tried canolis. So good. I had the Anthony special and my husband had the Coney island.

Everyone is very friendly in this establishment and we felt quite welcome! We ordered 3 heroes- Anthony-awesome and oh so filling, the Islander - husband was bursting with joy, the Mediterranean delicious!!! We all will eat the other halves tomorrow night. Everyone said why didn't we know of this place earlier in our lives? What a great find!!!!!

Wow. We ordered food for 12 for my Dad's 75th Birthday gathering. As Italians from New York we are very picky about Italian food. We LOVED it! Absolutely delicious with generous portions. Friendly delivery and all around great service. We ate still talking about the eggplant parm. YUM!!!!

So I came here to get some gifts for my wife as we just had our baby. I got the same hero's again carmines. Also bought a pound of mozzarella and half pound of stuffed peppers. Everything was delicious. !!!

Best around 100% , great family owned business and they do amazing job.... Every need you could want ..fresh chicken cutlets the best I ever had Amazing subs and premade meals are outstanding

We really really like it here! This place is located right off Gatlin in a strip mall - parking is super easy and it's very visible from the road. This is a small, family-owned and run Italian market with old school vibes. They have pre-made full blown meals, and a counter full of rotating pre-made goodies to take and heat/eat. Arancini balls for days, and they're all delicious! Multiple types of salads and sides, as well as homemade mozzarella and many specialty imported items. In addition to the market items mentioned above, There are also homemade Italian sausages to take and cook and an extensive sandwich menu with over 20 choices. It's a great place to stop in during the day to grab a sandwich for lunch while I work from home, and their choices are endless and they're happy to customize anything for you. Most recently I was in there and told the wife that I really wish they had rainbow cookies. That's one of my favorite Italian treats and it's hard to find a good homemade version! She mentioned that her daughter had a special order and will be making them this week and told me I could order some for myself! After confirming I would pick it up Saturday, I was pleasantly surprised on Saturday when they were not only ready for me and my husband... but they are DELICIOUS! You guys have to make these perfect rainbow cookies a regular thing, because now I can't live without them!

I was in PSL and finally got to try out the place. I ordered online which was very easy. The staff were all working hard except for the little Polish guy. He was the entertainment while you waited. The Bensonhurst was excellent ! Portions were really huge. I only saw the salads by the pound! Macaroni salad was very good but to much. You need a location in Stuart or Palm City where there is way more traffic during the day and people can access easier. Sales would more than double. I had passed the entrance and had to turn around. Most people will go to the next place.

Will definitely order from this business again!!! We called in a last minute order, friendly guy answered the phone and took our order for The Bay Ridge and The Islander hoagie. We thoroughly enjoyed both of the items, plenty of ingredients within both of the sandwiches and everything was super fresh. I fell in love with the bread which is crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. Our order was ready immediately with no wait. We also order 2 slices of lemonciello cake, also delicious. Was born and raised in Florida, this was possibly one of the better sandwiches that I've had outside of my home. It's nice to have a new place to eat that isn't chicken. Not sure how long they've been here but now I'm glad they are here!!!

Wow. Not overrated at all. Great sandwich got the Anthony special. Extra vinegar. 1/2 pound of mixed olives two cannolis Daughter got the Met. Both wonderful. Service was friendly and accommodating it was like a small store. No seating available everything was great parked at front

What's up with this place? Focaccia Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich That's what's up!

Deli / Italian specialties. I have to admit, the guys that were working there were not exactly fat and well, I subscribe to the old saying "never trust a skinny chef".... but nevertheless, the guys working here turn out very good sandwiches and other delights. Essentially a deli, TFG has a large board with a bunch of named sandwiches (or sangwiches depending on what part of NYC you might hail from) and they all have NY names: Coney Island, Levittown, the Babylon etc... definitely a NYC / Long Island bent on the names. If you do not like that selection of sandwiches, they will also just make you whatever you want. The bread is good- and that is the whole heart of the sandwich: bad bread = bad sandwich. Getting good bread outside of NY is a crap shoot but these guys get some good stuff. I usually buy some extra bread when there. The sandwiches are good sized and can be messy to eat but they will fill you up. Beyond that, there are deli cases with Italian specialties: stuffed olives, marinated mushrooms, mozzarella / tomatoes etc. There are Italian meats: Soppressata and sausages; because nothing says I love you like fatty, salty meats! There are also some heat & eat meals available in case you are too tired or lazy to cook. Outside of the deli cases they have a cross section of dry goods: Pastas, sauces and cookies. Phew- if you are like me, when they are done ringing you up, there is smoke coming off the register... but it is all worth it and I recommend this place at least once a week to someone. Parking in front.

Fuhgettaboutit! This place is legit. From the epic Italian sandwiches packed with all your favorite toppings, to the wide array of pasta salads, to take-home dinners, they have it all. We got a couple sandwiches, some salads, some deserts and what a treat it was. Everything was filling, fresh and served with a smile. For the price, you can't beat it when you see how big the portions are. You gotta try this place and pick up a Manhattan Special out of the fridge while you're there.

Recently visited my family in Port St. Lucie and when I asked my brother what was new in town worth checking out, he mentioned this establishment so being born and raised Brooklyn NYC, I said let's do it and boy what a great experienced it turned out to be! They have a list of at least 30 different types of sandwich's (Boar's Head cold cuts or homemade chicken/eggplant/sausage options) of which you can either get on a roll or hero! Authentic NY style Italian bread!! They also over a variety of deli style salads, olives, mushrooms and sides, precooked meals and Pastosa stuffed pasta, sauces, dried pasta, cookies, desserts (the list is endless)! We tried the Anthony and the Chicken Parm hero's and they were delicious!! We are spreading the word to all of our local family members and next time I am back, I will definitely stop in to try something different!

Service was good. Ordered meatball parmigiana hero, very good and sauce is on point. Hot stuffed peppers were awesome. For Florida, this is the deli to go to!

Excellent family run deli everything you can get there from homemade fresh mozzarella to custom-made subs to dinners that are made from scratch to all types of salads and olives to frozen products. It's such a wonderful place and we're very well needed up in Port St. Lucie. I hope they build one down here in Martin county Really great menu all types of dishes, authentic Italian deli style.

Great food, authentic, good portion sizes. Large selection of sandwiches to choose from

Good location - it's not it the highest traffic area which is great! Tons of options, great looking dishes. The sandwiches are loaded! Not a dine in option but the orders are taken and made pretty quickly. Variety of authentic Italian items available there. My only complaint was no mayo after I asked for it, I'm thinking maybe I was misunderstood. That made the sandwich significantly drier, since it was so loaded with sliced meat. The sandwich options are on a roll which is nice, not a common option but definitely an original NY option.

one can only get better pizza ,made by latinx, in new york it is that close to being new york authentic!

I did enable the first half lol but this is the best sandwich I have had. Me and my fiancé saw it driving by one day and we finally made it there before they closed and I am so glad we did. Everything is so tasteful 10/10 would recommend

Amazing sandwiches, meatballs, cheese. Sandwiches come out very fast as they are ordered.