Brothers Of New York Pizza

Had a large pepperoni and it was Fantastic! I love pizza. I grew up in NJ and had 3 pizzerias within a mile of our house so pizza became my favorite food group. This pie had some high quality mozzarella and an awesome sauce 🤪. The crust was done just right and has a great flavor too. Service was fast and friendly. The store was decked out with souvenirs from New York City, including the doors off of a subway train. This is the kind of place you bring your family when they come down to visit so you can show them that there is "real" pizza in NC. They serve Pepsi products and I'd rather have coke ... But soda is not why I came in. Enjoy

Low key pizza spot. Pleasant and accommodating on Halloween and a subsequent visit with my grandson. They have multiple kinds of pizza you can order by the slice. The slices are large like we got in NJ. Quite a few pizza options to choose from. Fast service and clean. Grandson was happy.

My husband and I had the best experience here. Everything was amazing from the food to the service. Their housemade balsamic dressing is to die for! Best mozzarella sticks we’ve ever had. And of course the pizza was perfection. The decor was also super fun and felt like we were in New York. We can’t wait to come back!

Pizza is NY style, super yum, thin, toasty, and large slices. They have a large variety of pizza and other items. I have had their calzones and stromboli's too. We usually do the lunch special and end up super full & satisfied.

The pizza was not great at all - the meat tasted old and dry, but the service was amazing. They cut up my son’s slice of pizza for him, and made us all feel welcome. Our server was fantastic, but they really need to step up their game with the food quality.

Clean nice environment first thing I noticed the staff was very friendly and attentive. Everyone was doing their job the eggplant Parmigiana sub was pretty good. I do feel like it could’ve had a little bit more flavor to the eggplant but I could just be comparing it to how I make my eggplant cutlets at home. My kids love the pizza I would definitely come back very good.

Being from NJ, I have a high bar for NY style pizza. The crust should be thin and crispy and should not flop over when held aloft. The sauce should be slightly sweet, topped with freshly grated mozzarella cheese. A Margherita pizza should have a good balanced amount of fresh basil. The one from Brothers was very good. Could have used a little more cheese and more basil but the taste and texture were excellent. Also ordered a cheesesteak which is always a challenge outside of the Philadelphia area. The one here included green peppers, onions and mushrooms standard. You’d be hard pressed to find a cheesesteak in the Philly area with green peppers but outside of Philly everyone seems to think they’re essential. Otherwise, it could have used more cheese but it was certainly tasty. Overall, food and service were good, especially so far from NY and PA.

Pizza is excellent with a variety of different kinds of pizzas other than pepperoni or sausage, including Sicilian that wasn't too thick and white pizza.

Bottom line: I had a good visit to Brothers of New York Pizza. My cheese pizza slices hit the spot and were what you would expect for NY style slices. Service was friendly/positive. Nice casual atmosphere inside. Enjoyed it for a slice or two, would visit again. The Deets: I had the chance to check out Brothers of New York Pizza with some friends that live near there, so over we walked for a slice or two. Definitely a NY vibe inside including subway station signs etc. There is a sizable bar available as well with drink specials listed. The large menu consists of regular and speciality pizza choices, pizza by the slice, appetizers including wings, salads, rolls, pasta choices, heroes, stromboli & calzones, and desserts. I kept it simple with ordering a couple of slices of cheese pizza, as you order at the counter then they bring your order to you when ready. Service was friendly and positive here this visit. Food came within reasonable amount of time for us, delivered to our table. It was noted they they grate their own Parmesan cheese there for use at the table. My cheese pizza slices were just as you'd expect from a true NY slice, I enjoyed mine. Although my fave pizza is more the thin and crispy crust type, this crust was the NY slice type and not too doughy (not a fan of doughy type of crust). Sauce and cheese were in good proportion for a good flavor. I'm definitely glad we went over to enjoy Brothers of New York Pizza and would definitely hit these guys again for some eats in the future.

Ordered the NY supreme under gourmet pizza ($29.95 for a large). Fresh ingredients and a nice cheese pull when you take a bite while it's hot and fresh. The dough had a good thickness. A family friendly vibe with booth seating. Quick service on a weekday night. Patio seating outdoors as well.

Really good N Y style pizza, the staff is very friendly, and location is easy in and out

Very good American-Italian food! Extremely friendly service and fair price $ Chill NY & lowkey ambiance Really beautiful outdoor seating area nearby water

An impulse decision on the way to Publix brought me here for a late lunch. Not much seating inside but the have outdoor seating too. Walk up and give your order, no table service. Half of the small place is set up like a bar, the other part some booths. They have a special for $9, two cheese slices and a drink so because it was my first time here, thought I would start with the basics. There's cheese, garlic, oregano and red pepper on the table and I sure am glad. I added a lot of garlic and oregano and still found this pizza lacking flavor. The crust was ok, but the sauce and cheese was just not up to the quality I get at other places. I will not return.

Good pizza and service on a busy day. Servers were helpful and friendly. Gave Popsicles to all the kids.

We are from New York and Brothers of New York Pizza is very close to the pizza we grew up with. We have ordered their plain large pie, and it's really good and consistent every time we order. We aren't in this area of Cary often but when we are, we get pizza from here. I also wanted to point out a 1-star review by "Rosalind A." Note that this Yelp user should be flagged. I looked at her profile, and she had just left 92 consecutive 1-star reviews for small businesses in the area. This destroys businesses, and it's not fair for our local restaurants to be treated this way. Report and flag this user to Yelp.

Excellent NY style pizza in North Carolina! Great sauce too - no agita! Love the NY decor inside too! Very authentic.

Back home in Pennsylvania we had a local chain of pizza restaurants called Brothers pizza, so I had high hopes that maybe, just maybe this place would have legit tasting New York style pizza. They have a special for lunch, two slices and a drink for $7.99. the pizza certainly looks the part, but it was very bland, I had to dump half the container of Parmesan cheese on it to give it any sort of flavor. Maybe I should have gotten some toppings on it but I feel a good indicator of good pizza is how it tastes with nothing on it. And the plain pizza here is exactly that, plain!

Brothers of NY Pizza is a rare find here in NC. Truly authentic NY pizza. They are not just trying to capitalize on the "NY Pizza" name. All of the food created here is 100% on the mark. In addition to the great food, customer service is top notch. The environment is fun and nostalgic for anyone from NY as the restaurant is decorated with familiar NY items. Prices are absolutely reasonable, and the Garlic Knots are chef's kiss! This is it friends, travel if you need to, this is what you have been looking for. You won't be disappointed.

I've been searching for an amazing buffalo chicken pizza and this by far has been the best I've found in the area! I've seen most places sprinkle plain chicken on top of regular cheese pizza with a drizzle of hot sauce which is disappointing, so I'm happy this place got it right.

It's all in the name, this pizza spot will give you NY vibes. We stopped in to grab lunch, beers and to watch football. My mom and I both started off with a beer then split a small garden salad with ranch dressing, the NY Supreme Pizza and a slice of cheesecake with half drizzled in chocolate and the other drizzled in strawberry. My husband ordered a large Brothers salad. The service and all of the food was so good.

found a hair in my boneless wings, mozzarellas sticks weren't cooked, and terrible, fries were bad too. cost 28 for food I had to throw out. I could have gone to public's and bought frozen.

The Customer service here is outstanding, makes me want to put an application in here to work these awesome group of people, food was great I was wanting a homestyle pizza parlor absolute overall great place to eat prices are very reasonable! Can't wait to come back!

Ordered a large sausage, mushroom, and onion pizza with a large Greek salad. Everything was spot on and delicious! Will definitely be back!

We are here for a baseball tournament and my son wanted pizza. We passed by this place and decided to go. The pizza is delicious. We all got the lunch special which is two slices of pizza and a drink and my husband got a sandwich and garlic knots we just got back from New York and they said it taste just like New York style pizza.vonne

I have been coming here for years and order pretty much the same.. it's either my spinach and eggplant roll or pizza.. tonight I went with the Roll, I only wish I took a picture. Mario the Master Pizza maker, out did himself . I didn't even leave a smell.. Great Job Brothers's

Delicious! One of my favorite white pizza in the RTP area. Will definitely go back. Friendly service and simple atmosphere.

It's so hard to find pizza here. I've been in NC 6.5 years and have tried every single persons "this is my go to NY pizza spot" and I'm sorry but all yo ur pizza spots are not great. This spot is decent- reminiscent of the joints back in NY and they sell by the slice- but I do find it to be overpriced. I will say the slices are quite large. Their sauce on the regular cheese pie is a bit tangy- but not in the best way and I don't think they use the highest quality cheese.. however I will say the Buffalo chicken slice is very good and one to be repeated. I'm definitely a solid 3/5 here but wouldn't go any higher

This used to be my go-to place for pizza but I'm lowering my rating for three reasons: 1.) The pizza doesn't have enough cheese, but then if you order extra cheese there's way too much 2.) Prices are very high. I ordered two large pizzas with only a few toppings and it was just shy of $50 3.) The staff isn't wearing masks. Sorry but I take my health seriously.

Great customer service, great food, family-friendly, and tons of variety on the menu. This will be one of my go-to pizza places from now on.

We used to frequent Brothers when we moved to NC. The pizza was good. Large pie, commercial level stringy cheese, loaded with pepperoni. Cost was a bit up but worth it. Over the last year the size of the pie has shrunk. Toppings are sparse, not much cheese. In fact the crust has become like cardboard. Not really edible. Overpriced for a smaller pizza and decrease in quality. I can pay $10.50 for the same pizza from Costco and get a bigger pie with better quality. Save about $8. We got Garlic Bread in our last order. It was just some semi thicker bread with melted butter and a tiny bit of seasoning. The Zeppoli are about the lone star of food. Very good desert. Customer service was good. Friendly staff. Young staff and very nice. I never write a joint off. Things can always change. But Brothers is not worth the price at the moment.

This place was clean and had a lot of specials. The food came swiftly and was delicious. The staff was super nice.

Omg we were vacationing from New York and..... we just stumbled upon this place while shopping! This place is authentic New York pizza no joke! We were so happy because we were just grabbing something on the go but, we were a party of 4 ordered different things...pizza sub salad and specialty! We all shared as we chose to judge the authenticity and I can assure you it DELIVERED AUTHENTIC NEW YORK JUST LIKE IT STATES 100%! It may be a while before we return however this place is on our places to eat definitely! EXCELLENT JOB BROTHERS OF NY FOR AUTHENTICITY! Truly a gem for familiarity on vacation!

I ordered a large pizza it was absolutely horrible the crust was soggy I couldn't even hold a slice without half of the cheese and toppings falling off it was that flimsy.The sauce is also a joke it was straight up bland and flavorless the whole pizza was trash and that is exactly where my $27.00 went in the garbage can I am pissed.I wasted $27.01 on that mess it was my first and last time going there they will ever get any money from me again.These people need to take the name New York out of the restaurant name this restaurant is a disgrace to New York an absolute disgrace

An email incredible pizza and pasta restaurant. We usually order and pick up since we live less than mile away.

First time here. We usually stick to our area of Holly Springs. After years of saying "let's try it" we did. My husband ordered mild wings,pepperoni pizza. He enjoyed his pizza. Wings just not what we are use to. They were oily and just ok. I ordered a Margarita pizza. I had to laugh. It was thin layer of cheese and Dan's of sauce. Never saw anything like it. Crust very thin,dry. Not great for the price. The sizes of the pizzas were generous but you do pay. 15.95 for small. The attitude of we got was like warm at best. Almost felt not welcomed. I will not return. Sorry,but there are much better places to go. Have to add. I get they close at 9 but at least keep all the lights on and not act like " get out we are closing"

LOVE this place. I'm from NJ so I know good pizza!! This place taste like pizza from home!! Even the best NY pizza places here in NC doesn't get as close to NY bc I KNOW it's the water from the Hudsen!! Water makes a huge difference believe it or not!! And these guys must get their water from up north bc their pizza taste as close to home as you can get! Love this place! I def recommend! We eat here every Friday night! And everyone is friendly!

delicious food and amazing customer service! They drove our order here when the delivery app messed up!! I am from New York and their meatballs are fantastic! pizza too!!

I am a neighbor to this restaurant. Its New York styled pizza and I love it. Its delicious like the sweet sauce. Fried pickles are my go to for appetizers. I take my family when they are around just need a beer and some good pizza. Salads are pretty good too. Garlic knots also delicious. Glad to have a decent pizza place so close to the house.

I'm pretty picky when it comes to pizza and thankfully, Cary has some good spots for thin-crust pie. So I was pretty excited to hear about Brothers of NY pizza. Located in a strip plaza with Wake Tech on Kildaire in S. Cary, Brothers doesn't look like much from the outside. But inside it's bright, airy and open. Grab a couple of slices for lunch and drink, options range from $6 to $7.50 for cheese, pepperoni or specialty slices. That's one area where Brothers of NY excels, they have 8 to 10 specialty pizzas ready to go by the slice! And how are their slices? A bit thicker for thin crust, crisp and without much grease on top. Plenty of toppings make for a filling meal. Service at Brothers of NY is pleasant and friendly, nice job there so if you're looking for pizza and in the area, stop on by! I'm pretty certain you'll be pleasantly surprised...

I ordered a pizza and was told it would be ready in 15 minutes. When I arrived, I was told that I would need to wait 40 mins because they just opened. When I questioned why they told me to pickup in 15 mins, not one, but two men, began yelling at me. The manager or owner was one of them. He even told me to never come back, as if I ever would after being treated in such an uncalled for and ridiculous manner. I would not know if their pizza is any good. I didn't get any. They didn't even offer to substitute it was the pizza in the case that was ready to sell. I would leave zero stars if it was a choice.

Not sure what the pizza is like, tried to call in an order at 8 pm , my call went to voice mail I double checked their web site , their site says open 7 days a week Mondays until 9 pm, I was not going to review on yelp until I had seen there was others that had the same problem. hope to hear they had problems with their phones tonight , the pics of their food look great! if they call me back , I will re-review remember, you need to take care of easy things like this if you value our business.

i was shocked to read some reviews saying that the pizza lacked flavor, and then i realized they must not have ordered the chicken bacon ranch. this is the best pizza i have ever had in my life. i swear im not glazing. get the chicken bacon ranch you will not be disappointed

I was ready for a change. Our family was stuck in a pizza rut, so we ventured outside our normal DT Cary area to grab some slices. Brothers might have the best garlic knots I've ever had. Definitely try these. My wife and son shared a small margarita pizza - this is a BIG small pizza! My daughter got a slice of pepperoni..she couldn't finish it, ha. I had the Italian cold sub with fries. The kids stole half my fries, and I ate half the sub..again, huge. We brought home enough food for a great dinner. A great dinner. PS they had about 6 beers on tap for a decent beer selection. PPS they have great looking lunch specials, slice and a drink for like 6 bucks.

Legit NYC pizza by dudes from the city. Consistently amazing, and everyone there is very friendly. My only complaint would be the hours. Guys, I love your restaurant but it's the only pizza place I've ever seen that closes at 8pm on Friday and Saturday night! That's peak dinner time for most people on the weekend. You really may want to consider extending to at least 10 those nights and see how it goes. I can't tell you how many times I've had to order elsewhere cause I looked at the time and it was past 8. I really hope these guys stick around. Having moved down from NYC, it's like having a piece of home here with me.

Very expensive to just be a pizza parlor. An order of wings and an Alfredo was $40. Way too much price wise. Customer service was lacking as well. I waited for the girl at the register to get settled and she just stood and looked at me then went to doing other things, never acknowledged me or even said hello. In fact no one behind the counter did. That would be my first and last time. There are way better places to go than this. If you want mediocre food and high school kids running around watching Tik Tok then by all means visit.

This review is for delivery. We ordered Brothers for our pizza Friday at work and I really liked the toppings. We had a variety with meat, veggie with spinach and jalapeno and then just plain margherita. Our coworker ordered it via phone about an hour before and they cut it in 16 slices and delivered it right on time. They are located in the shopping complex near Ten Ten and Kildaire and deliver within 5 miles.

This is one of our favorite pizza joints and it doesn't hurt that it's really close by our home. Quality ingredients, friendly staff amazing tasting sauce. A definite must try!

Awesome pizza. I have been going to this restaurant for at least 4 years. Delicious grandmas pizza and I also love the chicken bacon ranch slices. I usually get the daily special which includes a fountain drink. Unfortunately, they recently set up two large 50" TVs that greet you when you walk in the door both set to Fox News. Why pick a political side for your business and turn off 50% of your patrons? Hoping they rethink this and go back to a more neutral political stance. Walked out yesterday before ordering. I will poke my head in again soon and see if anything has changed. Yummy pizza.

I enjoyed! Being from NY born in The 70s when pizza I can remember .75 -.80cents. I had a brief convo with a fellow Nyer and was told to try so I did.

The 3 stars are for the food only. I walked in hungry and decided to give the place a try . I'm not sure if it's because they were busy but the service at the bar sucked. I came in, the girl greeted me and I placed my order. I advised I will wait at the bar. I sat at the bar for 10 minutes before ANYONE asked me if I needed anything. I eventually asked the young lady for a beer. Just to give you the scenery , I was there and there was a family of 2 eating......that's it. My food did arrive and the pizza was good. No one asked if I wanted anything else, nor how is everything . To make matters worse, another guy came in and he was serviced immediately . The bartender sparked a conversation with the other patron. When I walked out, no one bothered to say thank you or have a nice day. They definitely have that bad NY attitude.

This is the best pizza place in my opinion in Raleigh. Their price is extremely reasonable. The staff is very friendly. The pizza is by far superior. I don't know if its the cheese or the sauce but it is very good. There isn't an onion overtone like most restaurants and the cheese is nicely textured. If you have not tried this pizza. What are you waiting for? At least try it once and you will see what I am talking about. This is our go to pizza place hands down.

GREAT pizza, straightforward atmosphere. That lady complaining in another review that they didn't take her order... this place is a food counter, there is no waitstaff. There are no candles outside because they sell pizza. If you want to go to a nice restaurant then go to a nice restaurant? So weird. My only complaint is there's no correct version of their menu online and we were ordering pickup. So I took some pics of their menu as of July 2021!

About as authentic as you're gonna get in Cary. The folks who work there are a kick. Totally keep meaning to swing by again. Maybe I will tomorrow...

They got the best pizza in the the Cary area. Do I need to say more? It's legit. Go now:)

If you're from the tri-state are you will LOVE this place. Hands down best pizza in this area! We love the huge floppy slices from the large and xl pies. Definitely a must try

I called to voice my concern. All the guy wanted to was argue with me! Not too professional. Good food Terrible customer service! I do not usually complain about this spot. I work at a business about 5 min away from them. Myself and co workers frequently order for delivery. This is the first time they really dropped the ball. Took 1.5 hr to get a delivery of 3 calzones and a philly cheese steak. They seemed to be more concerned with a special request on one of the orders than with the number to call when the delivery driver arrived. Driver was given a wrong call back number. Came to the address and left to deliver another order. This is not the way to run a business! Think this was the last time they get out business. We usually average around $50 for an order. Food arrived lukewarm. Food was not marked. A stromboli and 2 calzones in the same box with no markings to let you know what was what. Sad Sad service!

Great pizza! My husband says it's the best he's had in the area as NY style goes. We have been twice in two weeks for take-out, and our pepperoni and margherita pizzas were very flavorful. The garlic knots are tasty as well.