Sailors Choice Party Fishing Boat & Anglers Choice Sport Fishing private Charters

Everything about our experience with Sailors Choice was positive. After arriving at another charter only to be told it was being cancelled, we were looking for an alternative at the last minute. When I called, the morning option had already been removed from the site, but the representative assured us we could still go. The boat was clean, equipment was ready to go, and they allowed us to bring a personal cooler with drinks and snacks on board with us. The crew had a lot of experience and kept things upbeat and fun, as well as family-friendly. We were able to fish a few different spots on the trip and they had fish cleaning services available when we got back to shore. Their recommendation to take our catch over to Sharkey's afterward was a good one too!

The Captains, Joe and Alice, were fantastic! The mates, Andrew and Kader, were top notch! Went out several days while in Key Largo. Even on what the crew considered slow days, I caught no less than 6 fish, on good days up to 15! Not all keepers but still fun to catch and release. I caught Strawberry, Mutton and Yellow Tail snappers, Porgies, too many Grunts to count, a remora and the largest catch, a 16 to 18 inch Black Grouper (out of season and undersized, so catch and release). The Captains go above and beyond to get you on hot fishing spots. The mates are running around like chickens with their heads cut off responding to all the calls of, "fish on!" I had a great time everyday we were able to go out. If you want to fish the keys without breaking the bank, I cannot give a higher recommendation, than Sailor's Choice Fishing Excursions!

Great experience, I booked with Sailors Choice because it was reasonably priced compared to other charters wanting $900 for half a day of fishing, we paid 1/3 that price as a family of 5. They have everything you need to have a great time. We even were able to bring a cooler with drinks and snacks for our kids. The crew were very friendly, and accommodating. They walked around several times throughout the tour, ensuring everyone was okay and assisted when needed. They went to a few different fishing sites to improve chances of everyone catching fish. 10/10 recommend and would do again. My kids ages 17, 12, and 6 absolutely loved it.

This is my 2nd time in 12 years that I fish off sailors choice. Capt Alice, Kaiter(I hope i spelled his name right) and Kristen are like family. Very helpful but most importantly making memories is all that matters. My dad and I will coming back again and fish on sailors choice

Today was so much fun! We caught the biggest fish on the boat about an 18" Jack Crevalle! Captain Miss Alice really knows what she is doing! Kader the first mate was top notch and went above and beyond to make our trip special. The boat was very nice and clean and the bathrooms were nice too. The sharks kept taking our catches so the captain moved us a couple times. They did their best to put us on the fish. All in all it was a beautiful memory we would do it again. P.S. I have done a few party fishing charters in the past with other companies. Often they leave late and take a long time to get where your going to fish. Sailors choice left exactly on time and in 35 minutes we were fishing in waters between 75-125 feet deep. Way to go, you guys are awesome!

Awesome experience today with Sailor’s Choice Party boat fishing charter. It was myself and my adult daughters. We each caught 2-3 fish (Grouper, Porgy and Yellowtail). Forrest and the crew were really helpful as we went to 4 different locations to find the fish! Would recommend! Also- they filleted our catch for us so we could take it to a local bar to have it cooked up for lunch!! Now that’s fresh fish!!

An amazing fishing trip. The “mates” were so lovely and kind. Such patience and humour throughout the whole trip. Unfortunately the fish weren’t biting for me but everyone else had more success! Highly recommend and will definitely visit again when in the area. Thank you!!

To be honest with you the only reason that I got on the boat is because this was my daughter's graduation trip and deep sea fishing was one of the things she wanted to come to the Keys to do. I get sea sick but enjoyed the first 3 hours of the 4 hour trip. Also VERY IMPORTANT: Wear sunscreen and a long sleeve dri shirt! I highly recommend this! The captain did his best to make sure that we were in the area where we could catch fish and yes we caught enough for dinner that night. The first mate was on point and was right there when we needed him, he also filet the fish for us to prepare later for dinner. The captain came out on the boat to help and talked with us too.

Another excellent experience on the FinChaser with Captain Ryan and 1st Mate Hunter. My 2nd trip and both times excellent catch results. If you want to catch decent sized fish instead of floating all day on a party boat catching little guys spend the money.

Our family of 4 did the 1/2 Day Reef and Wreck Private Fishing Charter on Fin Chaser- 38' Topaz Express at 5pm with captain Jordan Edinger and first mate Kishian. We had an absolutely incredible experience! My brother wanted to catch a shark on his graduation trip, so we set up the evening charter trip with these guys and they did NOT disappoint! Not only did we catch A shark, but we caught 4! Overall we caught 2 nurse sharks, 2 lemon sharks, a few barracuda, yellow tail snappers, blue runners and a bonito fish. (picture of all but the sharks hung up at the dock) Jordan took us over a reef and a shipwreck. He was knowledgeable about both locations and was able to get us catches at both locations. We were the only boat on either location. He also made quick but effective work when filleting the fish when we got back to the dock. He gave us suggestions on where to take our fish or how to prepare it. There wasn't a single pin-bone in any of the fish! Kishian was absolutely incredible and made the trip 10x more enjoyable! He had the fishing gear all set up and ready to go by the time we docked at the 1st and 2nd sites. Kishian taught all of us how to properly reel the fish in for this area and made sure we had the right bait and helped us keep an eye on the lines as we really didn't know what we were doing at the start of the trip (and only knew very little of what Kishian and Jordan knew by the end!). Kishian was encouraging and helped you reel in fish that were big and made you feel that you accomplished it on your own. Jordan and Kishian made an amazing team and really made this trip absolutely incredible! If this company's other employees are half as good, they are amazing!

Had a great day fishing w my son aboard Reel Good. caught many fish mostly mahi some tuna and half eaten grouper! Had another memorable trip! Captain Billy and mate Justin both great to work with. Wouldn't hesitate to go again with them.

amazing day on the water with Captain Jordan and Hunter!! really a great experience, caught 5 species of fish. Monster barracuda, sting ray, and a couple of black tip and bull sharks! definitely will be back again to book with them!! TJ

1/2 day with Capt. Bill & Hunter. My 1st time- such an amazing experience and he was extremely patient teaching me from scratch. The captain/sea jokes were terrible! Terribly good! You can bring food and drinks onboard, just make sure you're not so seasick that you never even touched not one piece of wing Fed his pets & saw manatees by dock as we waited for him clean, filet & bag our catches. PS: Fish house down the street can cook your catches soo yup, take it straight there after and thank me later.

Fantastic Fishing trip even without catching anything bigger than a 10lb King Mackerel. Captain Ryan was a total pro and his equally pleasant mates Eric and Sean worked their butts off to stir up the action on multiple reefs resulting in 4 or 5 lbs of good eatin dog snapper, grouper and yellow fish, which we had prepared 3 ways for terrific dinner on the dock at Skipper's. Sharkeys does the same "cook what you catch" right next door. The No Fear isn't fancy but the more than ample cabin was super comfortable for lunch and hanging and to warm up during this cold front. It's a luxury to have you hooks constantly baited, the catch cold stored and cleaned at the end of the trip. We'll be getting back on the NO FEAR, hoping to land a big sailfish or tuna next time.

10/10 Eric is a hell of a fisherman and he really made this experience. Took out "No Fear" and caught a ton of fish. Had an interesting technique that did not fail. A bunch of fighters and a lot of good eating. Even threw out the big reel and my son caught a lemon shark (video is better than photos but won't post for some reason). Gorgeous sunset, great company, great experience. Will book again!

An amazing group of guys running these boats! After taking two different charters during my vacation time the thing that stands out the most is that I wouldn't hesitate at all to book again! We caught more fish than I can count and had a most memorable experience. Huge shout-out to Capt. Bill on the No Fear for making our Christmas fishing adventure one that will always be remembered. A freezer full of excellent fillets and pictures that make me smile more every time I look at them. What a great trip! Also, the trip on the Fin Chaser with Capt. Jordan was excellent, they did a great job putting us on fish in challenging conditions. Highly Recommended!

My family and I had a great day out with Captain Bill and Mate Matt. Professional, knowledgeable, friendly and hard working crew! Definitely recommend.

Great Fishing Trip Capt Jordan and Ryan did an excellent job keeping us busy catching quality fish. I would recommend them every time This company stayed in contact with us leading upto to Trip with updates and info Very professional and hospitable company.

My wife and I had the extreme pleasure of joining John and Jordon on a full day fishing charter in November, 2020. This was the first day out following a hurricane / tropical storm which had threatened and ravaged the area for a couple weeks so we weren't sure what to expect. Josh and Jason made sure we had an amazing day. Besides catching enough yellowfin snapper for dinner for four, our captain and mate threw aside all else when we came upon a leatherback turtle in distress. This poor guy had the ropes from a lobster trap wrapped around his neck and flippers. As he struggled, the ropes were getting tighter and tighter. The Captain and mate of the John and Jordon wasted no time in pulling up alongside this amazing creature and struggling for over 15 minutes to free him. What an amazing experience! Josh and Jason made sure we had a great experience all day...they engaged us in all aspects of fishing and made sure we were comfortable and having fun. When we returned to the marina they cleaned our catch for us so we could take it up a local restaurant to be prepared. We would wholeheartedly recommend spending a day on the water aboard with them. It will be a day to remember!

Amazing experience! My husband and I took our two boys (15 & 13) and we all had the best time and caught tons of fish. Jordan and Keshawn were great. Will definitely book again the next time we are in the Keys!

This was one of the best fishing trips I've ever been on. Captain and crew were very professional We had a ton of action and were able to bring in a 79" Sailfish.

This is fun y'all!!! We went out on NO FEAR today and these guys were so accommodating and fun to chat with too! We caught fish and made some good memories we can laugh about for years to come. Thank you again for being part of our memory making and keeping us all safe and catching those big fish!

Had a fantastic time fishing with Captain Jordan. He knew all of the spots to find a catch - we caught a lot of mahi mahi and rainbow runners. Jordan was also very attentive - set up all the lines, poles, everything we needed. We had so much fun and can't wait to come back.

Captain Jordan and First Mate Andrew were AWESOME at putting us on the fish. We got lots of them!! The only thing that bothered me was the Fin Chaser was not at all as described on the website. The inside cabin was not able to be used at all. We couldn't escape the heat for a break in comfort. It appeared to be under construction. The bathroom was not ideal. We have a big family and wouldn't have chosen this boat if we were aware of this ahead of time. Great fishing but hope you get the boat fixed up so we can come back next year!!

We loved our morning charter on the Fin Chaser with Capt Jordan and Mike. Had a blast, caught a bunch of keepers, threw back some crazy creatures, and learned more about the reefs. Capt Jordan filleted the fish like a pro- because he is one!

Captain bill and mate hunter were amazing. This was me and my wife's first offshore fishing experience and it was amazing. Capt and mate were very knowledgeable and understanding especially when my wife felt nauseous. We had a blast and would recommend to anyone looking for a fun safe trip of a lifetime.

John and Jordan did a great job on our 1/2 day charter. We took 4, 13-year old boys on our excursion, only one of whom had been deep sea fishing in the past, and they made sure that it was a positive, memorable experience for them. Once back at the dock, John cleaned our catch for us, took pictures, and recommended a local restaurant that would prepare our fresh catch for us. We have had several deep sea charters in various locales around the world and this was the best 1/2 day charter yet.

My wife, 16yo, 10yo and I Took the 4 hour excursion w Jordan and John and the day was awesome. We hit two spots. The first to catch dinner and the 2nd for some sporting fish. We were at the first spot for more than 2 hours and proceeded to catch upwards of 18 fish. Some we kept and some we used to bait for larger fish. It was nonstop action and both John and Jordan were helping the kids work the poles and both were hands on when there was a fish on to help them haul them in. They made it appropriately challenging for the kids and they never stopped smiling. We moved to the wreck fishing spot for the final hour or so and the lines weren't in the water for more than 5 min before we started hitting some bigger sport fish. We caught two barracudas but had at least half dozen other LARGE fish on that we'd fight for a few minutes only to see them get eaten by something even bigger. The action was awesome and the look on the kids faces with each barracuda was priceless. These guys run a great shop. Very polite, great with the kids and fun guys all around. This Is a no brainer. We just wish we had done the 5 hour tour.

Had a great experience with the owner greg and the guys on the boat david and Jeff We got the 3/4 day trip and we had such a great time, good job guys we will definitely come back to see you.

Had a great time fishing this weekend with Capt Billy and first mate John. We went on No Fear and had a blast!! The waters started rough but on No Fear we still came home with 3 Mahi's and 2 Tuna. John and Billy knew where to great and extremely knowledgeable. Thanks again for a great trip!!

One of the highlights of our trip to Miami area. Kevin is so very accommodating. All we had to do was enjoy ourselves. Kevin took care of everything else. You will not go wrong with him. He directed us to a restaurant who prepared the fish that we caught. The fishing trip and the meal were excellent.

Amazing half-day fishing charter with Captain Jordan and first mate Ben, on the boat the Fin Chaser! This was the first off-shore fishing excursion for my husband & I, and this crew gave us an experience that we will not forget, because the very first catch of the morning was a 4-5 ft Wahoo (40+ lbs)! And our crew was as excited & thrilled as my husband was about this spectacular catch. And we ended our trip with a total of 9 fish, a wahoo, yellow-tail snappers, Bonitos, little Tunny, Trigger fish and a rainbow runner. Capt. Jordan and first mate Ben are incredibly knowledgeable about all things fishing: their boat, riggings, lures, bait, the sea & all the creatures in it. This outfit and organization are top notch professionals, but are guys that make it enjoyable to spend 5 hours with out on the beautiful waters around Key Largo. Thanks Capt. Jordan & first mate Ben

We had a great time. My wife and 8 year old son were novices. The captain and mate kept them involved - they had a great time. Did we catch fish? OF COURSE!!!!! I recommend captain Jordan and The Soz! You won't be sorry.

We had a great day fishing with Capt. Jordan and mate Eric. Capt. Jordan is very knowledgeable and kept us on the fish. We caught Mahi and Grouper! So happy we decided on the 3/4 day, next trip will be a full day for sure!

.My in laws were in town last week and we went on a fishing trip on the Fin Razer. It was an amazing time. Billy (captain) and Adrian (first mate) were great! They helped us with everything, explained things and were understanding if we forgot things. They went out of there way to make us happy and have any enjoyable trip. I can say without a doubt I will definitely do a return visit and I would recommend them to anyone. You can tell they care of the boat cleanliness and up keeping and care about providing a great experience

What a great time! We were lucky enough to fish on the Fin Razer with our new-found friends (Jerry and Irene) and had a great time. The skipper knew exactly what to do and led us right to the fish. Extra kudos go to Randy, the deckhand/first mate. He was AWESOME to fish with. A positive attitude and super-helpful demeanor really made the trip pleasurable. We will see you again soon! Darrinn & Kimberly

I have been bringing a business group to the area for many years and always fish with Key Largo Fishing Adventures! The Captains always know where to find the fish and the deck hands are the hardest working in the business. I have never had a boat come back without a ton of fish! The captain always cuts them up on the dock when we return so guests can try FRESH sushi and they love it. I wouldn't fish with anyone else in the keys. Fabulous job no matter what kind of group you have!!! I would give more than 5 stars if I could