Screamer's Pizzeria

What an amazing place!! Best vegan pizza I've ever had, you must try the Screamer pizza. At around $3 to $5 a slice this place is really good value for money. The wings are so good too. An absolute must visit for vegans when in New York. I cannot rate this place highly enough. Thank you guys!!

Update: I waited a week and went back. The pizza was still a hit. Take all my money! Wow! The pizza here really lives up to the reviews! It's really good! The staff was real cool too. I got the mushroom and the pepperoni with jalapeno and pineapple. Omg. I cant wait to go back for more. Do yourself a favor and try it. Even non vegans will enjoy.

Screamer’s has been on my must try list for SO long and it absolutely blew me away. Not because it was this out of this world vegan pizza experience but because it just felt like a regular no frills pizza shop serving amazing slices/wings and just happened to be vegan. I went w my non vegan friend who loves a pepperoni slice and she told me she couldn’t tell the difference between this and a non vegan slice. So good - probably for the best I don’t live closer or else I’d be here all the time 😂 - we tried the pepperoni and Buffalo cauliflower and they were both perfect! Esp the Buffalo cauliflower

My girlfriend and I are obsessed with this place!!! Literally the best vegan pizza ever. I personally really love when places get creative with their food, and Screamers does just that! They also offer wings now and them Thai Chili wings really did what they needed to do. The service is always really sweet and friendly too. HIGHLY recommend coming here!

It’s a small vegan pizza joint with plenty of options. I got the Buffalo pizza slice which had tomato sauce, buffalo cauliflower, almond ricotta and vegan cheese. It was a little too spicy for me though the crust was thin and crispy. I generally prefer lots of veggies on my pizza and don’t like seitan or fake meat so this wasn’t the place for me! Try with your own preferences in mind! And it’s slightly overpriced too! This one slice was $4.75!!

Tiny hole in the wall with limited seating, but holy wow these pizzas were very good. Getting real NYC pizza is a great treat. I can say from experience that most cities in the US don't have quality like these pies had.

I love every different slice I’ve tried. The chorizo, buffalo, and pepperoni slices are my favorites so far. Makes my life easier when everything on the menu is vegan. Update 5/30/18: this place has been taking credit card since December 2017. 👍

Always love screamers pizza. Sometimes they’re out of a lot but that’s a good thing for them. Small place with maybe 3-4 seats but not much space. Normally we order and take out. Apple Pay accepted.

Big win for vegan pizza. Brought my non-vegan friend and she was a fan. You can tell the cheese is different, but not in a bad way. Atmosphere is small and fairly grungy, but not bad for dining in if you've got the space. They have a nice little assortment of pepper flakes, oil, and some other powders to put on your pizza. I got the Screamers slice and a Mac and Cheese slice (both white pizzas, oops), and both hit the spot. Was full after two. $5 each isn't the cheapest thing in the world but worth it imo. For sure would come back.

So good weeks later I'm still thinking about Screamer's. It's an eclectic little shop with a couple tables and chairs, and also some standing room. When I walked in, they were blasting loud music from the 80s... it was definitely a vibe. I got a slice of the cauliflower buffalo and the screamer's (garlic-y mushroom) for $5 each. The slices are thin-crust and served warm; the flavor of the sauces and texture was amazing, really savory. I definitely liked this better than a lot of non-vegan pizzas I've had in the past -- the "cheese" tasted great. There were also some jars of chili flakes, dried parsley, and garlic salt available on the tables. Lots of pizza flavors to choose from, would love to try more.

The hamburger pizazz was on point..... I had order to PU took a lol a while but some tasty cegsn pizza.....

Despite not being vegan I think they have some really great slices. As a lot of others said there's pretty limited seating and they often run out of slices, but it's a good slice shop all the same. Depending on the slice you can spend about $3-5 per slice. Last time I came I grabbed a plain and a buffalo chicken. They'll ask if you want it heated up and they'll do that for you as well. Personally I love when pizza places can get a little creative with their slices and they do just that at Screamer's.

It was just about 9pm on a Friday night meaning the pickings were getting slim. There weren't anymore Buffalo wings but the two slices of pizza I had were a good amount. Filled me up with out the greasy heavy feeling non-vegan slices of these would have created. The Buffalo slice had cauliflower and Buffalo sauce and a vegan blue cheese (I'm guessing). It smelled really good and tasted even better. My chorizo slice was also very tasty. I think I preferred the Buffalo slice because it's something I love having. Buffalo sauce is a thing for me. But the chorizo was really good and they both had great flavor. The dough was soft but still managed to cut up the roof of my mouth. A me thing.. not the pizzas fault. The nutritional yeast and other toppings were a nice addition The employee was helpful and patient and explained all the different slices that were left and answered all of our questions. Brought our slices to our little table hot and ready. It's a tiny spot so not much room to linger and hang out which we did anyway. It was cool. The few people inside eating their pizza were friendly and everyone was cool sharing the close space. Will definitely be back for more slices!

Seriously one of the best pizza places I've ever had the honor of enjoying. I love the down to earth vibe and the 80s music that was blasting through the cozy little restaurant! Service was super fast as our pizza was heated within minutes. I got a Buffalo chik'n, mac n cheese, vampire, and truffle pizza slice to share! I think my favorite was the truffle since it had such a delectable creamy taste - the Buffalo slice also had a slice of my heart bc I love tangy flavors! Insane that everything is vegan - all the more reason to love this place!

Delicious New York pizza spot. Very small with three barstools if you do want to eat in. They have lots of different flavors of vegan pizza. I got the pepperoni it was absolutely delicious also got the buffalo cauliflower amazing! Definitely a place you want to stop for good New York vegan pizza.

I love New York-style pizza, slices hot out of the oven and loaded with cheese, but my lactose intolerance makes it hard to enjoy these days. The solution? Screamer's. All their pizza is vegan, the slices are delicious, and when I'm eating them, I don't even miss the (dairy) cheese. They usually have a bunch of different slices available to choose from, or you can order whole pies. On our last visit, we got the (seitan) pepperoni, which was great, and the Screamer slice, with garlic oil, vegan cheese, cremini and oyster mushrooms, and almond parmesan, which was amazing. If we lived close enough to do regular delivery or takeout, I think we would probably be ordering that Screamer pie all the time.

This was quite a find by my lovely wife. All vegan pizza shop in Brooklyn. Not open too late for NYC so make sure you come before 10. Also, as we saw, the variety for slices is more limited near closing, which makes sense, but just keep that in mind. We each got a slice of sausage and onion, pepperoni, and Buffalo cauliflower. I enjoyed them in that order. The sausage was very good. Looked to be homemade sausage, but maybe not. Certainly not beyond or impossible. The pepperoni was a fair attempt at real pepperoni but not quite there. Finally, while I definitely enjoyed the Buffalo cauliflower, it just wasn't the best. The crust was excellent NY Pizza crust. If I had any complaint and I obviously do since I'm only going 4 stars, it was the sauce. It was good and while I don't like my pizza drowning in sauce, this wasn't enough. It was very light and mostly dried out/evaporated from sitting out. Still, the pizza was delicious. One last complaint would be the death metal music playing. I know, you're edgy, you're Brooklyn, and you don't have much seating anyway so you may as well listen to the music you want. But you do have a few seats so maybe bring the anger music down from a 12 to maybe a 7 or 8? Regardless, great vegan spot in Brooklyn.

On the third to last day, we went for a take out pie and sadly disappointed and not the same as it used to be... the dough was under cooked, too thick and just didn't taste the same. Sad to see our regular Friday night take out leaving the neighborhood and extra sad for our last experience to be sub-par.... Goodbye Screamers...

This is a vegan slice joint, Called Screamer's in trendy Greenpoint, Its toppings are fun, Its crust best well-done, Can't believe there's no cow and no oink.

I would say the best vegan puzza i have ever tried in ny! Came late at night and they still have a few option to choose from. Had the regular margheritta and it was so good. Place is super small but they got a couple of tables.

I found Screamer's on TooGoodToGo and I didn't even realize it was vegan! I THINK they gave me buffalo, pepperoni, and margherita slices (I should have asked) and they were all absolutely fantastic. Usually vegan cheese doesn't melt nicely and gets congealed easily, but not this place!!! I will 100% be back (and with friends)!!

Wow!! So glad I passed by this one day and noted it's location in Greenpoint and vowed to come back. It is on the pricier side for sure at ~$5 per slice, but if that's the price for quality vegan pizza, so be it! i got the buffalo chicken pizza and the Kale Seitan pizza. Both fantastic options that highlight how genuinely good their cheese is. I am not a fan of vegan cheese generally but they are killing it here. Will definitely be back as they are right by McCarran park.

Guy at the counter was kind of rude but man they have good vegan pizza. Two slices with toppings came out to around $9. Limited seating inside, but close to the park.

I was pretty anxious to try kale on a pizza but I trusted my gut and went with the Fancy Kale pizza. My friend and I sat in a local park and devoured the pie. It was incredible! Perfect texture and the vegan ranch was insanely good. The cashier was pretty rugged but it fit the vibe.

Love that Screamer's offer vegan pizza - sometimes it's a hit or miss with vegan cheese because of texture and flavor but Screamer's has somehow mastered it. Our group consisted of two vegetarians and two meat-eaters and it was a hit all around. We ordered the Screamer's pizza (named after the restaurant! Of course, had to try it) which came with garlic oil, variety of mushrooms). The crust - by far is the best part of the pizza. It's not overly crispy - it has a good chew and crunch without it being burnt at all. Without marinara sauce, it can be a little too creamy for some but we didn't mind it. The cheese, the longer you wait, starts becoming more gooey so eat it while it's fresh! Will definitely try them again to support a local business!

This is the best vegan pizza I've ever had. Ordered my favorites slices, the screamer- absolutely fantastic. Counter-service was fast and friendly. One of my go to spots when I want some special pizza

Vegan or not vegan, I highly recommend trying this place! It is a small shop with limited seating but the pizza is worth it. The buffalo cauliflower was my favorite and I would come back to order a couple slices next time! If you eat at the shop, they have nutritional year, red peppers, garlic, and some sort of spicy oil to accompany the pizza.

There's a lot of skepticism surrounding vegan pizza, with many asserting that plant-based pies aren't the real deal. Screamer's, however, definitively puts this debate to rest. A medium pizza consists of six slices, large enough to share among three (or two very hungry) people. The Clean Slide has a relatively standard base, except that they mostly use specialty ingredients - sesame seed crust, non-dairy cheese, and tomato sauce. The selection of toppings is where things get interesting: long hot pepper pesto, broccolini, and seitan sausage form a pie that checks multiple boxes: spicy, veggie-lovers, and "meat"-lovers. The broccolini's mild sweetness balances out the spice, and the seitan is a solid stand-in for actual sausage. If you've never had vegan pizza before and you aren't sure which to choose, the Clean Slide is your best bet. I opted for delivery instead of takeout, but wouldn't pass up the chance to stop in for a slice or two if I'm near their Manhattan Ave shop. Because it's specialty pizza, Screamer's is pricier than an average slice at your local pizza joint, but in my opinion, it's well worth it.

If you are looking for vegan pizza, this is a great option. They are open for takeout, no outdoor seating. I recommend grabbing a few slices and finding a nice shaded spot at McCarren. We ended up ordering a slice of the pepperoni, screamers, white, buffalo, and artichoke. My favorite were the buffalo and pepperoni. These slices are a good portion too.

This was seriously the single worst slice of pizza I have ever had. The pizza was just inedible. Just take a look at my pictures to see for yourself. I took a couple of bites and just had to throw it away, which I never do since I hate wasting any food. I'm hoping this place just had a bad day but I surely won't come back to find out. It is crime to serve such low quality of pizza in New York. Eat here at your own risk.

I got a slice of cheese pizza from Screamer's and I thought it was okay. For a vegan pizza it is a solid choice but I was there was more tomato sauce on the slice. The highlight was definitely the crust, which was cooked perfectly.

All items are vegan so there's no need to ask. It's also pretty affordable. Screamer's Pizzeria is one of the cool new places in Greenpoint. Hipsters are moving in and opening crazy businesses. This is a good thing as it gives you a reason for coming around here. Before this opened up you had to go to Williamsburg for hipster vegan food. It certainly feels like that neighborhood a little, but sketchier. The pizza here is all vegan. It doesn't matter which it is, there's no dairy or anything. They sell by the slice. It's $4 for a slice of most. The one I like the most is the Supreme. It pretty much comes with everything. They even have vegan nutritional yeast. It tastes like grated Parmesan cheese. They also have calzones, which are filled with anything you want to get inside it. It doesn't have that much room inside. It doesn't have any bathrooms, which is the worst thing about it. The atmosphere is cool so consider just bringing a small group to eat there.

What a great find given the lack of pizza joints serving vegan pizzas, it was awesome to find an establishment with such a wide variety of vegan pizzas. The spot itself is quite small with a seating of about 6-8 people. We came here on a cold rainy Saturday night and ordered the a white pie and an artichoke pie. Both pies were banging and we loved the flavors and texture of the dough. This spot is heaven for vegan pizza lovers. We will definitely bee back, and please open up in Jersey City soon!!

Vegan Pizza ... my two favorite words. I've been to Screamers in the past but visited their other location. There is something so homey and sweet about this location and the workers seemed generally nicer here than there. It was such a great experience and really amazing food. My sister and I had gotten a couple cheesy slices, ate those then got a vegan sundae at van leeuwen then went back to screamers for more pizza :O lol!! The pizza is VERY thin but that isn't a bad thing .. possibly New York style?! Idk I'm from Jersey.. don't hurt me :P. My favorite part about it all .. is unlimited nooch........ vegans rejoice. woohooooo!!!! Definitely check out screamers for decadent pizza.. don't be wasting your time on cows milk pizza.

Wow! This place has been on my vegan bucket list for a while. I finally made it happen. I had the two slices that everyone seems to reference as the best. I loved them both. Both have crispy crust. Both very NY style pizza. The pepperoni is BY FAR the best slice of vegan pizza I have ever had. And I have had a lot. If you get the chance check this place out! I believe even omnivores would love it.

Really good vegan pizza. I purchased a white slice, & a regular. It got it to go. It is a tiny indoor space, but it you wanted to stand and eat your slice at the stand up counter you are welcomed to do so. I opted to just take it to the park up the block, and enjoy it via open air. Go check out Screamers, if you want a quality vegan slice at a reasonable price. The staff is very chill too & will answer any questions you have.

One of the best vegan pizza slices I have had! You cant even tell the difference. Quick service so you're in and out. Pretty cool ambiance must check out !

I'm so glad vegan pizza is a thing! I'm not vegan, but if all pizza tasted like this I probably could be, you know? I impulsively stopped by late at night after getting dropped off at a friend's place because the suggestion of vegan pizza looked/sounded too tempting to pass up. And boy am I glad that I did! The inside is very narrow, so it's a great option to-go. Their toppings are sort of standard/sort of adventurous, but definitely tasty. I got a slice of Fancy Kale, which was spicy with a flavorful, fluffy crust. But my favorite was the Screamer slice. It had a creamy, Alfredo-esque sauce with mushrooms, and the crust was so thin and crispy. I am looking forward to coming back here and trying many more of their toppings. Bonus: it's right next to a Van Leeuwen's ice cream shop so you can follow up your 'za with a scoop!

Finally had the chance to grab some pizza from here and I was not disappointed at all! Honestly, if you are vegan or not, their pizza is amazing. The spicy jack is really spicy and so good and their buffalo chicken slices, it legit melts in your mouth. Also very yummy. The slices are a decent size too. I have a hard time keeping my vegan diet and I always break it because it's hard to find NY pizza that is vegan. This did it for me. If you're looking to transition to a vegan diet and worried you'll be missing pizza, please give this place a try. I am honestly so impressed. Also their colas are great too. Had the orange one and Mexican cola. 10/10 pizza & drinks The area is very busy. So wherever you get parking, just park and walk it. Lol, def recommend this place to everyone.

Definitely the favorite spot for nyc style pizza in the entire nation. Don't expect much seating room. I like how they're open late. Toppings on point, but some of them aren't always available. More reason to come back. Treat the workers right and tip them.

Ordered Take-Out for their regular Cheese Pizza, half and half of Screamer and Supreme with a side of Garlic Knots. The Cheese felt a bit lacking. There was a thin layer of cheese and not enough tomato sauce. The taste was okay. The Screamer half of the pizza sounded so good in the description however the garlic flavor was not there. You can not go wrong with the mushroom topping tho. The Supreme half of the pizza was simply the best. This one contains all the vegan meats and tasty onions and peppers to go with! The Garlic Knots were the star however. Super tasty bites of garlic bread with a side of marinara. I would like to return to try more of their offerings and perhaps experience a dine in experience.

This was a great decision by my wife. We were in the Williamsburg area and was looking for something to eat. She said she heard of vegan pizza spot in Brooklyn. Went to yelp typed in vegan pizza and Screamers pop upped. We got a Sicilian pie and a regular pie. It came up to over $50. I was skeptical at first because of the price but it was worth every penny. The Sicilian pizza was thick and "cheesy" with zesty tomato sauce dripping off of it. Both pies were amazingly delicious.

It was amazing but now it's closed. Checked their IG and it's permanent. Such a shame that they're only operating in Crown Heights now. And that it's been closed a week but they haven't updated Google maps or Yelp or even their IG bio. It was good while it lasted.

If you've never had California pizza but always heard how bad it is then this is the closest place in NYC to experience it. As someone who is lactose Intolerant there aren't many options in the area. I don't understand how Paulie Gee's Slice Shop can make vegan pies so good you can barely taste the difference but a full vegan pizzeria is so lackluster. The cheese tastes like Cheez Whiz and the crust isn't up to snuff. I don't know if they don't feel they have to do better bc they're the only game in the area or if they legit can't do any better. Either way I'd like to see them step it up. Until then Brooklyn Pizza Crew on Nostrand has a vegan option that blows any of Screamers' slices out of the water

My roommate and I are so obsessed that we've traveled from Hoboken on a snowy day to feast on an entire pie and then ordered two to go. You'll find screamers slices tucked away in our freezer. It's an addiction. I urge non vegans to give the place a shot! My sole complaint in that the seating area can get a bit dirty. It's tight, usually packed...I get it. But it can definitely throw of your appetite when you're waiting for your slice. But that's NY....right? Also, keep an eye on their social media! Not only do they frequent festivals and the like, but they often introduce special pies available for a limited time.

I've been dying to go to Screamer's for months now. I recently attended the NJ VegFest in Atlantic City, NJ and tried Screamer's there. Since they were using toaster ovens to heat the pizza, the cheese was cold and didn't taste fresh at all. I enjoyed the dough but I wasn't blown away. We did however love their walnut sticky buns... But my experience at the NJ VegFest didn't stop me, I went to their location in Brooklyn last Saturday to give it another try. I ordered their BBQ jackfruit along with their Bianca. Again, the pizzas didn't taste fresh nor inspired. They were good but not amazing. I was disappointed. I love their sister stores, Blackbird Pizzeria and Champ's Diner. Somehow, Screamer's didn't hit the mark and should step up their game. First of all, they really need to invest in a larger store. With the rise of veganism, Screamer's should invest in a larger space to accommodate more customers, ovens (for fresher pizza) and events. The store was incredibly small and unfortunately, dirty. The music was loud and I felt crammed. We luckily got a table but felt squeezed in there by the patrons waiting to order. I don't think I'll be back until this problem is fixed...

Since I went vegan a few years ago, I've really missed pizza. Most of the vegan slices I've tried weren't even close to real pizza and they just didn't taste right. Enter Screamer's. The pizza is amazing; it's so good in fact that half the time you can't even tell it's fully vegan!!! I tried the regular slice, the white slice, the mushroom slice and they're all amazing. The vegan cheese that is used on their pizza is creamy and flavorful and the crust is really good. I highly recommend trying Screamer's, whether you're vegan or not. It's definitely worth a trip. Keep in mind, this location is very small and there is no indoor dining. There is a bench right in front. There are some drink options that include different kinds of fancy soda. Service is more or less what you would expect at a small pizza shop staffed with teenagers. Highly recommend!!!

Great for slices!!! Small inside definitely a to go spot but delicious vegan pizza plenty of variety!!!

Although the cheese can't compete with the real thing, the tangy tomato sauce and crust are legit. I got plain, pepperoni, and best of all, Buffalo, which offers spicy Buffalo cauliflower and other ingredients including "almond ricotta dollops." I enjoyed the enthusiastic service, with helpful explanations available to vegan pizza novices, and the music too. Thanks to Shazam I learned that the Shins were better than I thought when they were "that 'Garden State' band." It appears the most ambitious pizza on the menu is the BBQ Jack featuring jackruit and "Canadian faken."

AMAZING vegan pizza- best in NY I reckon. Thank you for existing. This was my first time at Screamer's actual pizza shop in Greenpoint Brooklyn. I've only had it at events/ pop ups. I think their slices are bigger in their store and you definitely get more selection. It is a tiny store with not much seating- maybe 10 people in there max. Best to take to go as a quick bite. I ordered my slices cold, popped them in my toaster oven for 5 minutes and it was perfectly crispy and melty instantly!! I've tried so many of their flavors. One of the best is the Screamer's one- well duh? They named it after the store! Yummy white pizza with GARLIC oil, mushrooms. Really loved the other white pizza as well, topped with a nice nutty almond ricotta. Buffalo cauliflower is a must have. The buffalo tempeh was a special and it was ok- the pizza part itself was great but the tempeh was so-so. Love the crust too!! Crispy when eaten hot with a nice chew to it. And the vegan cheese is so good! It meltssss yaaass. No weird vegan cheese shreds visible on the pizza. It looks like "real" cheese pizza y'all. I think if I had no self-control, I could eat 3-4 slices straight. They sell their pizza by the slice or by the pie. They also have garlic knots and calzones! You can buy their "pre made" flavors or create your own! The slices are generous and you can do that classic new york "fold" when you eat your pizza. Whether you're vegan or not, give Screamer's a try. Dairy isn't good for you anyway!! No more "cheese is toooo gooood" as an excuse. Screamer's has made my vegan dreams come true. If only it was more available everywhere in NY at any time of the day. Everytime I walk past a dollar slice place I just want Screamer's!!

Amazing pizza, one of the best i've had in NYC. The staff is super welcoming and they recommended the cheeseburger slice and boy did it deliver. The vibe inside is very fun, there is a great variety of toppings, and I love the fun stickers they have coating the balls. Will definitely be back!!

Fully vegan so chow down with confidence. Slices + lots of specialty pies to choose from. You can try a lot without spending a lot. I tried the plain, white, artichoke, and vampire. The white was my favorite but honestly, everything was delicious. The negatives? NO BATHROOM. Tiny place with very minimal seating. Loud music (although the selection was good). Also, salt was hard to come by (had to have someone fill a plastic cup in the kitchen).

I decided to check this place out after reading some reviews. I love pizza!! Vegan is even better. Went straight from work had my mind made up as to what I wanted and just like that I ordered it. So for the pizza it wasn't bad, but it wasn't good. If it had been a fresh slice it would have been better. I had a slice of the sausage n mushroom. They had other options to choose from, but I really wanted to try that. The service was wonderful, very friendly, I was the only person there. The price was rather reasonable for two toppings.

Three overall. It's decent pizza for a vegan option. And I like they do by the slice for on the go.. BUT I had a horrific experience today. If I could vote for today alone I'd give it a one. DELIVERY #60731061-7842030 1 Bianca Pizza Overcooked or undercooked: Entire item My photos todriver was clearly doing other orders at same time and stopping at places before and after picking up my food. Please look at the map images attached. My food showed up cold, not fully cooked - literally I had to put the pizza in my oven it looked super under cooked and doughy still, I easily could have been sick. Additionally, hardly any toppings and hardly any cheese. On top of it cheese looks super old and crusty, not fresh at all.

Vegan pizza heaven! I cannot say enough amazing things about screamers. Everything from the buffalo to mushroom slice is beyond delicious. If you're vegan and missing pizza, this place hits the spot. My non-vegan friends also really love it here. Happy eating!

We LOVE this pizza place, with their variety and flavors. For Vegan pizza this truly is legitimate and one of our favorites. I'm sure there are no bad choices here, they have traditional along with some more adventurous toppings. We had a party of 5 and order a variety of slices to try - the Grandmas Pepperoni was pretty much the tables favorite followed by the Mushroom. There's not a lot of seating here, we got lucky to be there as they were opening and had the place pretty much to ourselves most of our meal. Vegans looking for good New York Pizza - should not miss this place.

All the slices I've had were tasty. I really enjoyed the slices with the garlic oil.