Sgt. Pepperoni's Pizza

Alright, these pizza are fire. Genuinely one of the best places I have some SOLID pizza and literally never had a bad slice. I don't know what truly makes it different than saying the dough is crispy and soft, the flavors and pepporoni meat lover, just too good. Absolutely recommend this to anyone coming into town or just hanging out because these pizzas are amazing. Staff is always super kind and easy going, definitely not afraid to tell what to get or have them surprise you and just let the food speak for itself. Get yo self a SLICE! I'd give 10 stars if I could honestly

Decided to give Sgt. Pepperoni’s Pizza a try after a horrific visit at Dominic's Ristorante Italiano and Sgt. Pepperoni did not disappoint! A good cheesy pizza is the perfect balance of crispy, golden crust and rich, gooey cheese that stretches with every bite. Not to mention, the garlic knots are to “dive” for - gone in an instance.

Had a few allergies (including milk and nut) and they were very responsive and kind in accommodating. They went out of their way to make sure everything was safe. That's on top of the fact that everything was delicious! The meatball pizza was incredible and the works was also great. Although we took it for takeout, the vibe and atmosphere seemed great inside as well. Appreciate their kindness and will be back next time we're in town!

14" meatball ricotta, 6 garlic rolls, and 2 beers. Food was amazing. Well worth the price. Will definitely stop by again when I'm back in the area.

I can't believe I forgot to review this place! Sgt. Pepperoni's is my go-to for consistently good pizza. They always have a monthly special flavor, which isn't something a lot of pizza places do. The meatball ricotta is top tier, but I also love the Brooklyn Bomber and the pinwheels. The parking lot isn't very big, but there are usually a few spots available at dinner time. My to-go orders are always hot and fresh when I pick them up, and the workers are friendly.

I had a great experience at your pizza restaurant! The pizza was delicious—crispy crust, fresh toppings, and just the right amount of cheese. The menu had a good variety of options, and everything we ordered tasted fresh and flavorful. The staff was friendly and the service was fast. The restaurant had a nice, cozy atmosphere, perfect for a casual meal with friends. I’ll definitely be coming back for more. Keep up the good work!

Used to love this place. Now they put out a product you can’t even recognize. Always undercooked or missing dough in center. If you order light sauce or well done they don’t care. Owners won’t return calls and manager Nina has ZERO control of staff or quality control. This place went from 5* to 1* in 6 months. What a joke!!!!!! Pictures shown were supposed to be extra ranch on buffalo chicken pizza and light sauce with extra crispy on square pizza. What a joke!!!!!!

If you’re from New York or anywhere that has an example of decent pizza, run the other way don’t come here! I have no idea how they are allowed to call this pizza on the West Coast. They must have a different food dictionary than I’m familiar with - but toppings don’t make the pizza ever… the dough! It’s the dough! And the dough here should be taken out back in shot so that nobody would ever suffer eating it