David W.
Yelp
So it has been over four years since my last review and I wanted to provide an update. To be up front, I would consider myself to be a regular at Sheldon Inn so that may bias my opinion a bit. With that said, I'm going to be as honest as I can be about my experiences.
When I started going to Sheldon Inn, it had a different vibe about it than I was previously used to, and I wasn't sure if it was going to be a place I'd enjoy hanging out at. However, what I have found after four plus years of going there is that it an all around great place, and here's why I feel that way.
1. Staff:
This is where Sheldon Inn in my opinion is different than any other bar/restaurant I've been to. I have found pretty much every single person who works there, past or present, to have been really amazing people. I am treated far better than I have ever deserved, and even after having made some mistakes in judgement there being hitched to a barstool maybe a little too long, I have always been made to feel welcome, appreciated, and respected.
Aron, who has been the manager since my first time there is a great guy. I have frequented other restaurants just as much as Sheldon, but never have I been made to feel more appreciated. The bartenders, such as Mia, John, Ryan, and James are all great. Attentive, funny, and dedicated to their craft. I'm often in awe of the juggling and running they need to do, because I certainly couldn't do what they do. The wait staff is always approachable, and friendly towards me. I have become friends with many of the employees there, and that is such a departure from other places I've been that I felt it's worth mentioning. To me, this is the thing that sets Sheldon apart. Even the owners are always cordial towards me, not that I feel I deserve it.
2. Ambiance:
I think Sheldon offers a good mix of dining or as of recently, happy hour experiences. You can sit inside for a more formal setting, hang out in the bar area (bar top and tables) for a more casual night, you can sit outside on the patio next to a very nice venue, enjoy live concerts/events, or sit upstairs in a more "club" type atmosphere. They offer a lot of variety, and I think many people who have not been there much don't realize that. If I had a critique, I wish they had a bit more bar top space since that always seems to be jam packed. I must also commend the other patrons - lots of great people go there.
I also commend the owners for taking such great care of not only the building, but the entire property. It's truly a very nice place to be, and from my first visit to today, I'm always seeing improvements across the board. I can say that's often not the case with other restaurants, and I commend their dedication to not only preserving such a staple of the community, but for continuing to make it better. It's an old historic building, but it's extremely well maintained.
3. Food/Drinks:
Let's face it, we're all going out to a bar/restaurant to indulge a bit, enjoy an evening with friends, relax with a nice cocktail, or celebrate an event. I have found the food at Sheldon to largely be good. The drinks are always great, and the service that comes along with everything for me, has always been top notch. When I say top notch, I mean like it would be hard for any place to be better than what I've experienced. They also have an ever-evolving wine selection, and unfortunately for my wallet, I've become quite a wine snob because of this place.
If I had some constructive feedback, it would be this. For us regulars, I do wish there was a bit more variety on the menu, and a little less focus on seafood and steak specials. A nice chicken dish (besides fried) or something like a chicken club sandwich would go a long way for me, and while there's an occasional special that hits the mark, not being a seafood guy, or someone who wants to eat red meat all the time, I can struggle sometimes to find something for a dinner entree. That's not their fault, it's mine, because I'm there too often. :)
When it comes to happy hour and apps, I have found their current September 2025 menu to be great. The shishito peppers are amazing. The chicken satay is always very tasty. I really enjoy the seasonal heirloom salad - super fresh tasting and oozes quality.
4. Conclusion:
Is Shelson Inn the only place I frequent? No, it is not, but it is by far the #1 on my list of places in the Elk Grove area. It has the perfect combination for me, and based on how many other regulars I see there, I know I am not alone. The ironic thing is, I drove by this place for many, many years, and never tried it until I had a reason to one day. After that, I was hooked. Many thanks to everyone there who makes my every visit there, a memorable one. If you're on the fence, please try it, you might just like it! I've seen many first timers there become frequent fliers, and I truly believe in supporting local businesses over big commercial chains.