Big M.
Yelp
I do really like the products that Shinola has to offer. However, my Christmas shopping experience at the Ann Arbor store was far too overwhelming and made me quite frustrated. I will echo the sentiment read in an earlier review, though: This experience likely does not represent Shinola at large.
I was shopping for my boyfriend's family, and had very specific instructions from him on what to get. When I walked in, I went to the journals/planners (each person was going to get a monogrammed journal or planner of some color/size). First, the journal specifics I was looking for were no longer available. This is not a big deal, because the Christmas shopping was belated and I did not secure the products early enough. That is on me. It was the very bizarre service I was provided after this realization.
An employee came up to me and asked me if I had been helped. I smiled and said no, and she attentively came up to help me. So far so good.
Employee: "What can I help you find today?"
Me: "I am looking for some journals and planners. I need (insert colors/sizes/page style here, times three). I do not see those out on display though. Do you still have them?"
Employee: "Ok, ok. First, who are you shopping for?"
Me: "Well, I am shopping for my boyfriend's family. But I already have all of the details sorted out, and I know what I want."
Employee: *walks over to display and grabs a completely different journal in burgundy* "Ok, I really love this one for mom. If you get this and have a monogram imprinted in rose gold, its just beautiful."
Me: "That is very pretty, yes, but I already know what I need."
Employee: (sounding taken aback) "Oh, ok. Well what would that be?"
Me: *repeats myself*
That was off-putting because I didn't feel like I was being listened to at all. After repeating my specifications, she very kindly went downstairs to look for the products I needed. When she returned and informed me that they did not have any more of the specifics that I wanted, I improvised and started picking out similar products based on what my boyfriend was willing to compromise. The employee continued to hover over me and every time my hand went near a journal, she had an abrasive comment about the differences between what I asked for and what I was grabbing, which I was aware of because she already explained that what I wanted was no longer available.
Ok. So journals have been chosen. I tell her I need each monogrammed. She then takes me to the back of the store to ring out my purchase. After putting my information into the system (which took way too long because she took it upon herself to assume my e-mail very incorrectly, rather than asking what my e-mail was... I had to correct her), she rang me out and then led me to the monogram station.
To be brief, pretty much the same thing with the monogram specifics happened with the journal specifics from earlier. I knew what I wanted and she did not seem to listen and had different ideas/suggestions. While I appreciate a knowledgeable opinion and tasteful eye, usually those suggestions are made for a customer who is on the fence or unsure of what to do. If someone seems certain, it seems odd to disregard their certainty.
Lastly, she did not ask me where I wanted placement for the monogram and the first journal had very awkward placement. At this point, I felt quite overwhelmed and was willing to just get on with it when she asked me how I liked the placement (which is my fault, I should have corrected her placement for the next two). After confirming that the placement was fine, she proceeded to shift the placement for the next journal, which I was very confused about.
Ultimately, I feel that I paid $65 for 3 products that I had to fight for and settle for, that I got after a very overwhelming customer service experience.