Sicilian Pizza & Pasta Downtown

On a road trip and wanted some quick pizza. It was actually pretty good (we are from Long Island,NY) so I tend to be a pizza snob. The service was quick the pizza was hot and cheesy. We also got the chicken Alfredo pasta and that was pretty good as well. For pizza in Kentucky this was pretty good 😊

Whatever you do, DO NOT ORDER chicken wings or the salads here. Awful Awful chicken wings, whats the opposite of fresh ? Old and smelly chicken wings , same applies to the salad. Cant believe I just spent 40 bucks on frozen food and an old salad.

The place is quiet. We had the place basically to ourselves. Staff is welcoming. My father is very picky/particular when it comes to pizza and he loved the pizza. Everyone loved the pasta. The salad exceeded expectations also.

ZERO STARS. PLEASE DO NOT ORDER DELIVERY FOR PIZZA. GARBAGE TO BE POLITE ABOUT IT. TASTED SOUR, MOST CHEESE WAS STUCK TO TOP OF BOX LIKE THEY STACKED BRICKS ON TOP. HORRIBLE AND PUTRID and Big waste of money.

Got a late night calzone. Customer service was great. Good was amazing, probably best calzone I’ve ever had, didn’t get the best pics but.. HIGH QUALITY FOOD

I’ve have to say, the staff is super friendly and nice atmosphere. The pizza was awesome too. I guess that’s important because that’s what I came for.

Awesome pizza, pricing and staff! Very quick service and no wait! Food came out very hot and everything was delicious. Ingredients were fresh and loved the crust! Definitely recommend to anyone!

Pizza was awesome! Service was awesome! We will be back!

This place never disappoints. The food is excellent, service is nice and friendly, there are loads of food options, and the restrooms are clean. Quick service, clean dining area, and nice ambiance. Situated conveniently down Theatre Square between Broadway and Chestnut streets. The Sicilian knots were scrumptious today. I got mine loaded with spinach, mushrooms, pineapple. Halt your judgement; pineapple tops things off deliciously. I hadn't been here in a while and had almost forgotten how tasty and high quality the food is here.

I was looking for a specific type of crust and Sicilian pizza seemed to fit the bill. It only took a few more minutes than predicted, however the flavors were a smidge lackluster and way too greasy. Our stomachs were pretty upset the next day. I wish we would've just done a frozen pizza.

they love to close 30 minutes earlier. maybe they should change the time it says online?

You know im a true blue buffalo pizza eater, BUT I always try what Yelp states this cities best pizza. Well, here in downtown Lousville, this was it. Sicilian Pizza and Pasta. We are not in Buffalo anymore, but this was decent. I do love a good crispy, thin crust pizza. The flavor was good. Got a sub, too (just in case for backup), went to the meatball, and it was good. The pizza was good, if this is their best..

It wasn't busy when I went in, and I ordered the Sicilian calzone. I ordered the small, and I couldn't finish it. It was baked to perfection with a very tasty seasoning on top. I ordered an extra sauce, because well, sauce is important to me! The service was polite. There's places to sit down, but I chose to take it to go back to my hotel.

I have loved this establishment ever since I discovered it 10 years ago. The taste and consistency of the pizza is always great. I especially love the garlic butter blend they have on the crust. The service is always very good. We used to order and sit outside in the front. Now I mostly order to go. You can't go wrong with this pizza place.

Small business on 4th Street that has fantastic pizza and stays open late. Staff was friendly every time we visited. If you're in the Louisville area and want some pizza you should give them a try.

The food I received was great. One of the very best gluten-free pizza that I have had anywhere. Additionally, delivery to the hospital was very convenient. Great food and service.

Typically I won't review a place before I have gotten food. This is the exception. Still sitting here 1 hour after we ordered our pizza and 20 min after we asked about it. They apologized but the fact that many other orders are coming out and we are waiting is unacceptable. I get that things happen but no attempt to make it right leads me to believe they don't care. Don't come here. You will wait a long time for what (as I was told by someone who actually came in AFTER us and FINISHED their pizza) is so-so.

The ultimate hand tossed pizza was very good. There were tons of toppings on the pizza. The 12 inch must have weighed 3 pounds. Really enjoyed it.

I will say this place is definitely underrated and doesn't get nearly the recognition it should. I definitely have it as my top Pizza/Italian place in Louisville. Located next to the Mercury Ballroom in Downtown Louisville. Both visits I got the Calzone and the best calzone if you ask me, my friend got the Lasagna first visit and finally got the calzone the 2nd visit. I love to load mine with extra cheese along with my meats. Their mozzarella cheese is fire. I have yet to try any pasta from here, I have had the pizza but that was from pre pandemic days. This is definitely a must if you're visiting/staying/ or local and you come to Downtown Louisville for an event or whatsoever. They do have salads/wings etc if you're not up for Pizza or Pasta.

Staying in a nearby hotel, stopped in for a quick bite to eat. I enjoyed the meatball sub and decided to come back for the pizza. Both experiences were great, was able to get food quick and it was hot and tasty. Definitely a place to stop into if you want a quick meal

Good food, decent prices. Love the cheese bread. Hot brown pizza was really good! Would recommend for a casual dinner or takeout option.

Was in town in order food for delivery. I got the supreme pizza. Wow! I wasn't expecting the pizza to be this damn good. It was one of the best pizzas I've had in years. Was delivered very quickly and still hot. Thank you.

An okay spot for pizza in downtown Louisville. The place itself is pretty, and it has a relaxed sort of atmosphere. Not too, too many people dining in. We ordered on the touchscreen in the store and just waited for the food (average wait time). I tried their cheese calzone (CYO own the addition of feta) in a medium size. The medium was enough for me, but it wasn't huge though. The place has a nice ratio of cheese to breading. They did load it up with cheese like I had hoped. However, there was a slightly strange aftertaste to the calzone. Maybe it came from the feta. It was also quite greasy. They served it with a huge packet of ranch, which is store-bought. Wasn't a big fan of the ranch. All in all, a fine spot for pizza. Nothing special, but it did the job. Calzones are okay for the average price.

So, first things first, the food is horrible. You order pasta and get something that is not pasta and that tastes just bad. Pasta was not even cooked properly. Second, you pay a good amount for the food and service, and what do you receive in turn? Your food is served to you on a plastic plate with a plastic fork, not even napkins. Last but not least, the place smells bad as soon as you step foot in, even though they leave the door open. Overall, I would recommend to stay away from this place. Im not going there again!

Always delicious. I get the cheesy bread sticks. The dough is slightly sweet and the mozzarella is quality.

I received an advert in the mail today which I guess was a sign? I had a rough day and didn't feel like cooking so I ordered delivery from this location. Be warned it is Doordash if anyone has issue with that. They were almost 30 minutes earlier than stated which was nice! I ordered the small hot brown pizza which was amazing. And a ceasar salad. Their prices are not bad with a small and salad enough to feed two people. They got my drink wrong but I'm more involved in how quick and good the food was. This is definitely a place that has a new customer!

Very good food and the staff was friendly!! Right in the middle of downtown the 10 inch pizza looks bigger than ten inches

Visited Louisville with my grandkids and my wife. We decides to try Sicilian Pizza near the hotel on 4th. The grnadkids eat pizza and pasta for the most part. We ordered a large pizza, 2 pasta meals, a chesey bread, and wings. The food came fairly quickly one at a time. The cheesy bread was all chesse and undercooked. It was not very good although the grandkids ate some of it. The caesar salads with pasta meals were ok but not worth ordering. The pizza was bushy and undercooked and tasted very bad. The wings were ok but nt great seemed like they were cooked quickley. The pasta meals were all sauce and mozzarella, looked bad and the grandkid would not eat. This was an Italian restaurant that was all fast food at best, 2 stars are generous for the quality of the food, not good. Don't go!

Terrible service - they have NO space for people to sit and don't plan for seating - wish we would have known that before ordering our food!

This place had very tasty pizza available at an astounding speed. Even facing large lunch rushes, we only had to wait about 15 minutes for our food. Pizza was very flavorful, and the cinnamon sticks were to die for. I think I ended up eating here 3 or 4 times over the course of a weeks stay in Louisville, different groups kept wanting to go back, and I never had a problem with that!

Excellent pizza! The crust has a slightly sweet flavor which we loved! Service was awesome and friendly! Calzone was amazing ! We eat pizza everywhere we go and this we highly recommend!

The pizza was the best thing ever . I went back still good. Good service good treatment. Looks like a awesome place to eat. Going back tomorrow

Fast service, food was hot cheese sticks was very delicious, plenty of tables to sit and enjoy your meal & TV

Sicilian is my go to lunch spot downtown! The baked spaghetti and meatballs never disappoints and it's a large portion so I get lunch and dinner for the reduced lunch price. I easily go here once a week sometimes more

OMG I spent the next day in my bathroom, greasy and uncooked. It look great but after the first bite I knew I was I trouble.

We were looking for an easy night after 6 hours of traveling, 2 distilleries and 2 wineries. We decided to order pizza and found that this placed looked good. We ordered pizza and salad for delivery. It was a little expensive, $26 and some change for a medium and small salad. It took a little over an hour as explained to us. The driver called me when he arrived at the hotel lobby. I met him and provided him a generous tip. The pizza was warm and very delicious. The $26 + tip was worth it.

Great pizza and fair prices. We got the 4th street bourbon pizza and the Sicilia. The lady at the service counter was very helpful in our choice. Both were delicious, but considerably different. The 4th street has a sweet bbq sauce whereas the Sicilian was more traditional. Worth a trip!

I am from NY where pizza is a religious experience & where there is no such thing as bad pizza- unless you are talking Dominos, Pizza Hutt or Pappa John's. I am visiting my sister & b-in-law in Louisville & we ordered a garlic & spinach from Sicilian. If the crust was a bit crispier it would have been one of the best pies I have ever had the pleasure of eating.

This place is Downtown Louisville's pizza destination. Sicilian is one of those spots that always pleases. I drive from work, park on 4th then transport the savory pie across the river. Each time I call in my order over the phone. Occasionally I'm put on hold for a moment and prompted with a 15-20 minutes estimation. They're never wrong. Wait times do increase when the Palace or Mercury Ballroom have shows. So when you walk into the classic pizzeria parlor you may find actual celebrities grabbing a drink before they perform. Additional outside seating is available to enjoy your own local interactions and people-watch.

I was at Cross Con 24. I went with a group for dinner. It was crowded because of the conference, but it had quick service. I had the Sicilian calzone, and it was really good!! It has limited seating but no more or less than other restaurants on broadway. The prices were good. I would go again.

Great service....very quick also.... but the pizza was very greasy ... I'm sure it's "ok" after the bars close and you're starving....but for dinner, we were disappointed

We received a flyer in the mail and I thought we would support a new business. I think our order is a one and done. Our order was late, cold, wrong, and greasy. We ordered two medium pizzas, one buffalo chicken and one cheese pizza. The cheese pizza did not have any pizza sauce, basically cheese stick pizza which was so greasy and leaking through the box. The buffalo chicken pizza had very little sauce leaving the pizza very bland. When I called the restaurant and asked for a refund, I was told they could t refund my order because it was placed online. So overall, not a great experience and will not be ordering again from Sicilian Pizza. Plenty of other good pizza places in Louisville.

the pizza was unexpectedly delicious. I had just artived to town and was hungry and needed something in walking distance. perfect choice and best pizza I've had in a while

Meh. The food here was mediocre. They use pre cooked chicken and the dishes lack fkavor/seasoning. The service was quick.

Lady night in Louisville, hankering cheese, melted. Why not a meat lovers calzone? Sure! The wait was well worth it. Ooey, gooey cheesey! Yummy! Nice brew to go along with it, had a house salad for starters.

I've been here twice, it was pretty good (compliments to the cook) and we'll probably eat here again. But the service is different story, The older gentlemen who rang our order was pretty cool, but there was a woman who rang up our order the second time we went. It seemed like she couldn't be bothered by customers taking a little time to explore other items on the menu.

The owner is an absolute doll. So kind, welcoming, helpful, oh and did I mention kind! My mother and I shared the spaghetti and meatballs. It came out fast and was delicious! Will definitely be by here again when we come visit Louisville!

Went there while waiting for the Peter Frampton concert. Wife ordered a Hawaiian pizza extra sauce and cheese. She got that and was happy with it. I liked the ham in, it was smoked but thinly sliced, I think sandwich meat? I ordered spaghetti and meatballs with bread. Totally disappointed with that. It was premade, microwaved to temp and came complete with the aluminum foil tray and plastic cutlery. NOTHING FRESH and NOTHING prepped by any chef/cook. The meatballs were dried out and disgusting. The noodles with that off consistency/doneness one gets with undercooked and microwaved box pasta. The sauce had no soul. No Italian/Sicilian flavor but it sure was tomatoey!!!! The spaghetti was just bad. It was crap BUT I took it home, seasoned it up a little and refired it and it was decent. The bread was just bread sticks they took right out of the wrapper and plopped it on the order with some weird kind of melted butter and parsley "sauce" poured over the top. Bread wasnt toasted at all, barely warm and I took that home, toasted it better and that was edible as well. We might go there again maybe a cold sandwich or something would be better but I doubt it. I think there is minimal cheffery happening there. Minimal hands on cooking. I think the kitchen offers up mainly warm up services on food. The front service was good and nice. The dining areas clean except I noted a delay in tables being bussed and cleaned but it was dinner rush. Outside the restaurant you get constantly bothered by panhandlers. One guy in particular asking for money like its an auction :got 5 got 2 got 1?" He even bugs customers coming in and out. Overall I am disappointed with this place. Nothing fresh. I did spy a tasty looking sald that I doubt was freshly prepared but I don't know so dont hold me to that.

Seriously some of the best pizza in Louisville. The crust is so good and flavorful. Always a bit greasy, but can blot off with a napkin. Just great comfort pizza

Never recieved delivery order. Called several time and they hung up on me each time. Spent $43+tip!

** Warning NEVER order delivery** We waited almost 45 min past the original 45 min scheduled delivery time. All I was told after both inquiries was that the online ordering times for delivery was wrong. Why did they not call and tell us? It is now after 11pm and we are extremely hungry! Worst customer service I have experienced in a long time! This review is made before we have even tried the food! **Update - Our pizza was barely warm and the cheese sticks were cold! Sounds like we were forgotten!

Absolutely delicious. Just happened to be downtown. Quick friendly service. Small dining room but definitely worth it.

Working on 4th Street, my office always got pizza from Sicilian and it was tasty. Recently, my husband wanted pasta for his second Birthday meal, and we ordered Sicilian after work. Sorry we didn't take pictures, but we were very hungry by the time we got home with carry out. We got the Chicken Fettuccini Alfredo, the Lasagna, and the Chicken Parm dinners. They each came with a pretty substantial Side salad and a long breadstick. The Alfredo was creamy and delicious, the lasagna was saucy and meaty. The Chicken Parm was interesting. It was rigatoni with marinara sauce and strips of breaded chicken baked with cheese. I only wish it had more chicken on it. The flavor was on point. I also ordered a Sicilian salad for lunch the next day. It was full of ham, pepperoni and cheese. I ordered the House dressing which was a thick sweet Italian vinaigrette. So, if you are downtown and want some pizza or pasta, head to Sicilian's on 4th. They are open until 11:00 p.m.

Good pizza joint that we like to visit. They have good prices for the taste of the pizza. I have visited it few times when we are down on 4th street for concerts and events. We will be back

This place serves pretty decent pizza, mine was served up fast too. The staff wasn't all that friendly and the price was on the high side. Can't say I would return or not. I don't need to be entertained but I am not a fan of being made to feel like an inconvenience.

Still open during Covid and protest. Check their Facebook page for hours. They were able to bring it to our room. Pizza was pretty good. A bit too much edge crust. I didn't see cheese sauce on their menu or We would have ordered some to dip the crust in. I didn't care for the red dipping sauce. Too chunky. Plenty of motzerella cheese , pepperoni and sausage. Stomboli was more like a calzone. Did love the great amout of pepperoni that was in it! It would be a pizza we would order often if we lived in the area.

I ordered the pasta, spaghetti and meatballs to be precise. It looks like they bake the dish to melt the cheese and I loved the cheese. The sauce was delicious, pasta was cooked perfectly, then meatballs were delicious, and I enjoyed the slightly crispy breadstick. My dude got a small bacon pizza and ate the whole thing so it must have been good. The restaurant wasn't too packed inside, about 1/5 full, but they were constantly taking orders to go over the phone. What I really appreciate was the guy said "hey we are short staffed" but put the phone order calls on hold while we ordered, even though I had no idea what I wanted and asked for some help. Very clean all around and friendly staff. Parking is metered, but maybe the local folks know where to park. This is a order at the counter, no server type place currently.