Sid Gold's Request Room

Karaoke bar · Chelsea

Sid Gold's Request Room

Karaoke bar · Chelsea

4

165 W 26th St, New York, NY 10001

Photos

Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by Sid Gold's Request Room
Sid Gold's Request Room by Sid Gold's Request Room
Sid Gold's Request Room by Sid Gold's Request Room
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null
Sid Gold's Request Room by null

Highlights

Live piano karaoke with eclectic song requests and booths  

Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in Eater
Featured in Grub Street

165 W 26th St, New York, NY 10001 Get directions

sidgolds.com
@sidgolds

$20–30 · Menu

Information

Static Map

165 W 26th St, New York, NY 10001 Get directions

+1 914 848 9243
sidgolds.com
@sidgolds

$20–30 · Menu

Features

wifi
payment credit card
Tap to pay
reservations

Last updated

Aug 26, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@infatuation

The 13 Best Karaoke Bars In NYC

"Starts At: Two-drink minimum Your angelic voice deserves to be accompanied by a live piano, and you can make that happen at Sid Gold’s Request Room. This Chelsea bar feels like a ’70s Vegas lounge, with curved booths embedded in the walls and a stage in the back, next to a pianist with a list of a few hundred songs to sing along to. We’ve heard a lot of musical theater here, and we’ve also seen someone who looked like an extra from The Sopranos sing Frank Sinatra. There’s no cover charge, just a two-drink minimum." - bryan kim, neha talreja, molly fitzpatrick

https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/guides/best-karaoke-bars-nyc
View Postcard for Sid Gold's Request Room
@infatuation

The 9 Best Bars In Chelsea - New York - The Infatuation

"There are bars where you can sing karaoke, and there are bars where you can hear live music. Then there’s Sid Gold’s Request Room, a magical place where you can do both. Six nights a week, Sid Gold’s hosts live piano karaoke in their back lounge area. You can request anything from Elvis to Olivia Rodrigo, but you’ll have to sing your selection in front of a room of strangers. It’s a great time. Reservations are easy to get, and there’s no cover, just a two-drink minimum." - Bryan Kim, Matt Tervooren

https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/guides/the-best-places-to-drink-in-chelsea
View Postcard for Sid Gold's Request Room
@infatuation

Sid Gold's Request Room - Review - Chelsea - New York - The Infatuation

"At Sid Gold’s Request Room, you can listen to Sinatra live. Except it won’t actually be Sinatra—it’ll be some guy from Long Island who comes here every Saturday and does a pretty decent impression. That’s just one of the characters you might run into at this Chelsea bar with live piano karaoke six nights a week. Sid Gold’s feels like it was transported straight from 1970s Vegas, and it’s a magical place where all of your dreams will come true (as long as all of your dreams involve singing Billy Joel in front of strangers). There’s a bar up front, but you want to sit in the small lounge in the back where all the magic happens. Keep in mind that there’s a two-drink minimum, and don’t forget to tip your pianist." - Bryan Kim

https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/reviews/sid-golds-request-room
View Postcard for Sid Gold's Request Room
@eater

Detroit’s Biggest Restaurant and Bar Openings, Fall 2018 - Eater Detroit

"Popular New York-based piano karaoke bar Sid Gold’s Request Room is expanding to a second outpost on the ground floor of the Siren Hotel this year. Sid Gold’s is known for its eclectic approach to karaoke where customers can request songs and belt out their favorite tunes — anything from pop to punk to soul to classic rock — accompanied by a live pianist. It’s expected to seat roughly 70 people and will have a 1970s “sophisticated basement bar” feel, according to co-owner Paul Devitt." - Brenna Houck

https://detroit.eater.com/2018/8/28/17785640/new-restaurants-bars-detroit-opening-fall-2018
View Postcard for Sid Gold's Request Room

Kate Pangilinan

Google
Amazing birthday with an easy and affordable reservation system in the back for the piano bar. I came on a Saturday with 10 friends. I am so excited to be back and cannot recommend this place enough! Ben was our pianist and MC for the night and he was incredible and fun, but the bartenders and service staff were also so amazing.

Stephanie S.

Google
Came here for karaoke! It was a Wednesday night and there was a decent crowd. FYI for people unfamiliar with this bar: you karaoke to piano music! No machine, no lyrics, so pick a song you know really well (and pull up your song lyrics on Google)! It's a bit more difficult than using a machine! We had so much fun and the pianist, Rob was pretty quick with calling people who signed up. This is definitely a unique experience that my New Yorker friend said is a very "New York thing". Two drink minimum per person, but the cocktails are pretty good. I had the Ginger Baker and my buddy had the Moscow Mule.

Anne Woo

Google
We went on a special night… Monday night when a regular was there who has been featured in a lot of places. He’s not in nyc anymore. Loved this piano night with professional singers.. drinks aren’t amazing but the prices are reasonable. We got a table and it was fun.

Beau Laughlin

Google
My boyfriend and I spent the day exploring Chelsea Market, Little Island, The Highline, and Hudson Yards. We decided that we would walk back to our hotel in Times Square. We love live music and this is how I can upon Sid Gold’s Request Room. Other than that I didn’t read any of the other reviews. At first it was a little hard to find, but we found it. When we walked in there was nobody in the front half of the bar except two bartenders. It was a Monday night. The asked us if we were there to see the piano and that we just needed to go behind the curtain. When we went behind the curtain to the other half of the bar we found piano karaoke of showtunes and musicals. The individuals singing were extremely talented. We felt like we were on Broadway. I wanted to sing Hello Dolly but I was too scared maybe next time after some practice. The next morning I asked my boyfriend what his favorite part of the day before was and he said the piano karaoke. He said they all just sang so beautifully and it was such a unique experience. I said that’s what I love about Mew York City you can go for a walk any place and stumble across one of the best times or nights you have had. Everyone was welcoming and kind at Sid Gold’s thanks for sharing your talents with us.

Olivia Leigh

Google
This is a cute little place to enjoy if you like to do karaoke because they have live karaoke in the back room. What I like is also that the front room is totally separated from the back room so if you just wanna enjoy a drink in the front during happy hour for example, you can do that.it also seems that everyone that comes here wants the music so it’s a great little environment in the back and so fine and you can request your own song. Definitely recommend if you’re in the area.

Jake Sweet

Google
I always have a great time at Sid Gold’s. The intimate space and unique interior make conversation easy and cute. Live piano accompaniment for karaoke is a fun novelty with some serious professional punch. Staff is always attentive if a bit busy and they allow pizza/meals in from outside which is rare and definitely needed.

Diane Johnston

Google
Did we ever luck out with the very talented, witty, charming and hilarious Nicholas Connell at Sid's. We sang up a storm and felt like I was at a friend's house (albeit a crazy talented friend). Shut down the bar on a high note! 🎹🎶💖 (We didn't eat so not rating food)

Robin Pianosi

Google
Can I give it seven stars? Reasonably priced drinks, good service, and BEST, MOST FUN KARAOKE EVER!! Ben on the piano is SO talented, and all the singers seemed to pick hits. It was our city highlight, bar none. We will definitely be back!
google avatar

RF B.

Yelp
This place is a gem. One of my family members did a show here before the karaoke session, and it was a great time. Excellent staff, fun ambiance, and an all around great vibe. Should be more places like this.
google avatar

Yvonne D.

Yelp
Stopped in to kill time/ pregame before headed to a house party. The bar had only a few people sitting at it but from the singing and laughs behind the curtain I'm guessing everyone was in the karaoke section! Bartender was friendly and helped me pick the perfect drink. The strawberry fields was delicious and well balanced. They have good music playing too. I plan to come back to do karaoke!

Louise H.

Yelp
Went here for their jazz and burlesque! The show was very good and the drinks were really tasty. Only taking off a star because the bar top itself has exposed nails underneath that I cut my leg on. The bartender didn't really seem to care and didn't even offer a bandaid or a comped drink.
google avatar

Natt A.

Yelp
This was my first time going here and I will definitely be back! It was such a fun piano bar where you can request songs and do your own karaoke up on the stage with the pianist playing the song. It was my first time singing in front of strangers (and not just in my own private karaoke room) and it was such a great experience! The pianist was so nice and friendly and everyone who was just at the bar was so supportive cheering everyone on. You don't have to be a professional singer to go out and have a good time on stage :) also, the drinks were great and reasonably priced at $15
google avatar

Angel H.

Yelp
What a fun piano karaoke bar! Love the vibe there. People were friendly and simply enjoying themselves. The pianist was amazing and very kind and supportive especially for someone like me who can't count beats. Song selections are fantastic and I really had an amazing time. Highly recommend this place! Will definitely be back.
google avatar

Jason M.

Yelp
I found myself at Sid Gold's Request Room for an after-work team member engagement event. I typically enjoy these events as it's a more relaxed environment than the regular work day and I can get to know my colleagues a little better. I quickly learned that in addition to a standard bar, Sid's was also a piano bar that offered karaoke. My participation in karaoke is usually on a case-by-case basis, so while it was tentative I would be participating, I was looking forward to checking this place out regardless. Located in Flatiron, Sid's is kind of unassuming from the outside, but once you enter you're greeted by a pretty spacious bar area. The space is somewhat rectangular with the large bar serving as the focal point. There is also a back room which houses more seating and the piano bar. This area was more intimate - the lights were low, and it was more appropriate for performances and private events. I felt there was a poor design choice in the seating back there - it was a combination of high tops and banquette seating, but the latter's material was too slippery and we all kept falling out of the seats. We literally had to press our feet against the table legs to stay put - no good. Sid's offers karaoke, and unlike most places that use a machine to play instrumentals, all of the music comes from a pianist. I thought this was a great touch and something that sets it apart from the typical karaoke experience. The pianist was great, he was really engaging with us and did a great job with all of the performances. The space can also easily be utilized for non-karaoke performances, or just a pianist playing. Looking at the menu, they offered a nice variety of food and cocktails. The food selection wasn't anything outrageous, but totally appropriate for a bar/lounge. The drinks looked good, they had a section of specialty cocktails as well as more traditional ones. I didn't get a chance to try the food as my work provided its own, and our drink selection was limited to well drinks. The drinks were fine - I had two rum and cokes and a vodka Sprite. They weren't that strong as I didn't feel a thing after 3 rounds, and the cola they used was flat. Service was good - everyone was friendly, plates were cleared, and despite us being a group of over 50 people, I never felt forgotten. Overall, I think Sid's puts out a good experience, I just wish I had better drinks and seats I didn't slip out of. However, I wouldn't hesitate to return here to try their specialty cocktails and food selection.
google avatar

Flora H.

Yelp
Love this spot! Amazing cocktails and a great vibe - casual yet nice. I've only sat at the small bar in front but there is also a piano bar in back with karaoke which looked like a lot of fun. This is going to be one of my go-to spots in the neighborhood!
google avatar

Evangeline C.

Yelp
Extremely talented folks in there. I came on a Disney musical night, and everyone, including the patrons were singing and dancing to the same tunes. It felt like I walked into a hang out spot of theatre folks. I came here for the gold drink, but it had no gold on it. I asked if they got my order wrong, and was shown a gold spray bottle that apparently doesn't put out much gold. Either way, I wouldn't come here for that drink, as seen from the beautiful pictures with gold in the drink. It's a two drink minimum, and I don't think it's worth a return.
google avatar

Gina L.

Yelp
Had the BEST time at piano karaoke here. Joe was great and we had lots of fun. Came here with some coworkers for drinks to celebrate a birthday and this was the perfect place. We didn't try any of the food, but they had great drinks & the service was exceptional. We are already planning our next coworker outing to come back here.

James M.

Yelp
Fun little neighborhood place to hang out with a piano player. But the smug obnoxious waiter ruined the whole night for me, with his nasty attitude.

Anthony C.

Yelp
Been to this place twice. Almost a decade ago and had a blast then. Had fun singing in the back room. Last night I went with a big group of people. I put in 2 song requests and waited and waited and waited....oh did I mentioned I waited. I re-requested them as many of my group went up several times and people who came in after me were called up multiple times. The waitress was very nice and apologetic and made an adjustment on the bill and told me next time to let her know and we can get you up there. I just do not understand if you tip on a request or even say you are tipping in cash, why wouldn't a request room not call you up? If you don't like the request...which was a part of the list of songs offered by the pianist, take it off the list. I'm sure you don't care but I was rather turned off by this experience and would rather spend my money elsewhere.

Shelby A.

Yelp
Broadway karaoke was SO FUN thanks to the host and pianist Ashley Grace Ryan. She played every song so incredibly and followed along as if it were a professional performance for those of us just there to sing some piano karaoke. I brought a group of seven and we will definitely be coming back whenever Ashely is back!!!!
google avatar

Kat T.

Yelp
Obsessed with this place. The guy who plays the piano before 8pm (or whenever they switch) is SO lovely and SO good. The crowd is always encouraging even when you *cough--I* sound like a deaf dog getting its teeth dissolved. Love the vibe and love the future-retro-underwater-submarine-but-also-spaceship vibe. Groovy.
google avatar

Laura M.

Yelp
So fun, loved the diverse crowd. Unique experience singing karaoke with a live piano.

Brigid D.

Yelp
So fun! John was the amazing pianist who made me feel like I was a star singer! Great ambience, staff and drinks. can't wait to go back!
google avatar

M M.

Yelp
Effortlessly cool and authentic vibe. I take my friends here all the time- local and visitors alike. 6 pm shift is a mellow, safe space to sing and be entertained by folks singing their hearts out. John Khoury on Thursdays not only has a natural gift for harmonies and piano keys but he's also a super supportive cheerleader who will make sure you finish your song with grace, dignity and lots of laughter in case you mess it up! It's a special place, a very New York experience, I just loooooove the people I get to meet in there.
google avatar

Phil H.

Yelp
Back in the days when we were allowed to gather in bars and clubs to enjoy life pre-Covid, I frequented this cool-ass piano karaoke bar with my friend Karen S to hear her belt out some tunes. The gal has pipes and can really carry a tune. Ask her to sing Suddenly Seymour from Little Shop of Horrors as it's one of her faves. A few rum and cokes do the trick. This is actually two establishments in one. A more subdued by the books front bar to hang out with a drink, and the back bar behind the curtain which separates the two rooms. Now this is where the magic happens when you peek behind the curtain of the Great and Powerful Oz. Seating all around with a piano centering the room, and a stage area near it. I actually enjoyed sitting at the piano the times I was here. It's an intimate setting with some terrific talent performing at times. Wonderful piano players tickling the ivories. So many songs to choose from on their lists. Grab a cocktail, order up some snacks, and enjoy the show. If you're daring enough get on the stage, pick a song, and let 'er rip. Always tip your server and piano player too. Here's looking to when they reopen so we can all sing along.
google avatar

Tessie V.

Yelp
We had a good Valentine's Day here. And by we -- I mean me and my Penicillin. Stopped by for cocktails and grabbed a seat by the bar. The place is pretty big. There's a couch in the front which is perfect for a group of 4-5. They're a few tables for standing room, and the back in the piano bar. They're some booths and sitting tables. I popped in to check it out, and people were happily singing along to the pianist. He seemed very friendly. I definitely like the mood of this place. It's 100% calming and cool. I enjoy the way it's "hidden" from the outside. Drinks were good, the bartender was sweet. There is a happy hour. One star off due to poorly cooked fries. Despite not really hanging out in the area, I think I would come here to spend some time regardless.
google avatar

Monica T.

Yelp
I'd heard a lot about this venue but had never been until a friend took me one Saturday evening. We got there near the end of karaoke and I haven't done it by piano that much but this is one of those "must see" places. I didn't drink so can't speak for that but I can speak for the karaoke: the lady who did it that evening (her name escapes me at the moment) was awesome. She's very cool and apparently had a special story related to my song choice, the last song of the evening. I picked "All I Wanna Do" by Sheryl Crow, knowing the song pretty well but not being sure how I well I could do the piano version. The answer was "really well" since a previous singer who was amazing (she did Celine Dion credibly) complimented me as well as a cute gay man (in my experience, gay men will not spare your feelings when it comes to singing so when they praise you they're being sincere). That made me want to come back & sing again sometime.
google avatar

Alina H.

Yelp
This place is a great addition to any date night rotation or girls night! The pianist that night, Ben was incredible. I was pleasantly surprised by the attention to detail used in having his entire directly online and a link to his Venmo for tips. Of course I got up to sing and when I forgot the words, Ben helped me along. The place also took covid 19 precautions seriously, sanitizing wipes between sets and providing dividers between performers and pianist. The drinks were also good quality (something unexpected for a karaoke bar, and we had the Hemingway Daquiri and Negroni. Being in a place with this much laugher and life made me feel like a light at the end of the tunnel. I just want very glad to call this city my home.

Jennifer P.

Yelp
Beautiful venue. Excellent music. Really fun crowd and vibe. If you karoake - or not - it's a great night out!
google avatar

Raphael N.

Yelp
If you ever think about leaving New York, this place will make you reconsider and remind you of the great places left in the city. This place is an absolute gem. Every time my partner and I come here, we sing our asses off with the piano host and the crowd, and have an absolute blast. The drinks are okay, I personally suggest ordering simple drinks like gin and tonic or jack and coke, where you can't go wrong. The staff is really awesome, and make you feel welcome. Finally, the crowd is mostly 30s and up, not too many Gen Z's... Make of that what you will.
google avatar

Keith C.

Yelp
I must say, I'm a super cocktail connoisseur (it's not bragging if it's true), so for me this menu is lacking-- def not a dead rabbit, employees only or patent pending. If you're not ultra snob, I.e only way you're satisfied is if you don't know/can't pronounce +50% of the ingredients per each drink, then you'll be good! Drinks are mixture of "house mixtures" ( like the strawberry fields which is rum, lime, pineapple, cinnamon and strawberry), classic cocktails like French 75, aperol spirtz, mule, Daiquiri, etc.). They have wines, beers, small plates, pizzas and salads too. It's a cool atmosphere-- great retro record store at night vibe, with loud music and decently big bar which means a few seats if you're lucky!
google avatar

Christine A.

Yelp
Stumbled upon this little gem with a few friends on a Friday night. The front bar is quaint with décor from another era. Towards the back, there is a mysterious curtained off room and a person asking if you have reservations. ((note to self, make reservations next time!) When walking into the curtained room, you're automatically transported through to a simpler time - where there is art deco wallpaper and when people sang tunes accompanied by a piano. While we thought we were just going to stop in for a drink or two, Sid Gold's was the perfect location to spend a few hours and end our evening. The cocktails and other drinks were good and not overly priced. A draft beer is $7, a glass of cuvee was $10 and specialty cocktails (think ginger old fashioned) were $13. There was sporadic wait service in the piano room, but it was much faster to head to the bar yourself. The crowd was all supportive - there were no "boos" to be heard. Some of the singers were fantastic, others okay; none were God awful - at least on the night I came. Mostly, the crowd joined in on singing the songs too. There are little notepads all over to jot down the songs you request. There is a song list as well - but I wish there were more songs to choose from. Remember to tip the piano guy! The pianist (Julian Velard) on the day we came was very attentive and would cue in the inexperienced singers when it was time to open their mouths. Don't fret if you don't know all the words - there are lyrics you can read off from an iPad. The music ended at 1am, which is a bit early if you ask me, but I suppose pianists have lives too. Can't wait to come back and bring other karaoke-loving friends.

Jane A.

Yelp
Do not book anytime prior to 9pm. No music. We were seated on the back right. CANNOT see the piano or singers. It was an awful table. We asked to move when the place was empty and the very nasty hostess gave us no time and couldn't care less. On top of this you slide off the booth seating. It's slops down.
google avatar

Mariam G.

Yelp
Decent bar if you're looking for a more elevated Irish pub feel - convivial and laid back. Doesn't look like the photos online which feel more glam.
google avatar

Francesca O.

Yelp
This place is always a blast! It's the best place to celebrate a birthday or to just go out with friends. The staff is always fun and the song selection is top notch. Can't wait to go back!
google avatar

Darya S.

Yelp
Atmosphere is pretty dead during the week, so check it out on a weekend night. The front part of Sid Gold's is a quiet, smokey, vintagey bar that's great for intimate conversations. I noticed a few (obviously doomed) first dates, and two women by the door catching up and getting their wine on (I could just hear them saying to each other, "It's 5 o'clock somewhere!" before getting started). When you go through the curtains to the back, it's a completely different section, with fancy booths on the sides and a piano stage being the focus of the room. If you're planning a group outing centering on karaoke and piano tunes, or need a date spot where you almost feel incognito, Sid is great.
google avatar

Tamara H.

Yelp
Yes. Good. Come here. Came for karaoke- the pianist is live and will sign along with you. Almost no wait on week days. The only downside is that all of the ppl singing HAVE to be professionals, I swear. So, my performance was probably pretty sad. :) You walk into a bar but don't settle there- keep walking behind the curtain and you will find a great back room where the magic happens. The cocktails were delicious as well.
google avatar

Karen S.

Yelp
I'm an introvert. People who know me are now laughing their asses off right now, but I really am! One quick cure of that is to get up on stage in front of a crowd of strangers and sing badly. Here's the thing that makes a piano karaoke bar the best thing ever... the crazy supportive atmosphere. From the pianist to the audience, if you start floundering they will save you. The best songs are the ones where everyone gets to join in on the chorus. There's zero pressure to perform, but if you do... High fives abound! The skill level is a great mix. And what you don't have in skill, you can easily make up with alcohol. The pours have gotten better, thank God, so my brokeass can still make a night of if for well under 50 bucks. But don't forget to bring cash to fill up the jar! The microphone may not smell like a beer, but if you sit at the bar, put bread in the jar and say, "Man, what are you doin' here?" I'm stealing Julian's schtick, but I'm sure the King of Banter doesn't mind. I usually come for Julian Velard's session on Wednesdays 9pm - 1am, but I need to start coming more than once a week. There are other performers in rotation and Joe McGinty's playlist is turning into the Magna Carta. Seriously, look at it: http://sidgolds.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/JoeSongList.pdf I would never judge you for clicking on the link and practicing before hand. Just don't listen to Aretha Franklin's version of "Bridge Over Troubled Water". Don't do it to yourself. That's just cruel. Of course Billy Joel is on the playlist, but so are Wham! and Madonna. If you can manage Borderline, you're my hero. I have never failed to have a great time here. Never. Piano karaoke is AWESOME.
google avatar

Jen P.

Yelp
Vintage fun. Be ready for a blast from the past. They were playing mo-town. The glassware and decor is kitschy. We had hot toddy, gin martinis and some other gin drink that smelled and tasted like grape cough syrup. All cocktails were potent, but grape/pomegranate drink was unappealing. We had a great laugh. The back room had karaoke. Too packed, but we'd love to come back. The service was kind and friendly.

Stacey S.

Yelp
I planned a birthday party here based on good online reviews -- no guarantee for success, particularly for a group of 8 non-performers at an amateur-performance venue. So I had to sort out a bunch of first-timer questions about group size, fees, layout, etc. and the booker could not have been more helpful -- PRO-TIP: book early, there's a strict limit to the number of people they will seat in the piano room (separated from the bar area by a heavy curtain so there's little-to-no interaction) which filled up quickly the Saturday night we went. Also, the 2-hour booking duration is non-negotiable. When your time's up, the next booking is ushered in. They don't serve food, only premium cocktails averaging about $15, with a 2-drink minimum. If all that seems restrictive, it plays out surprisingly well in practice. One of the reviews I read said the online photos make the place look more glam than it is but everything from the dragon's cave booths to the grand piano in the corner seemed pretty glam to me. The cocktail bar lighting makes photos look a bit hellish but that's part of the fun, like the singing. There was an obvious semi-pro vocalist the night we went but mostly amateurs giving it their best shot, trying to hit the high notes and read cues by piano player Ben Easton, who played his a** off and made everyone sound decent-to-great. If you plan it right, this place is a total home run.
google avatar

Cheryl K.

Yelp
I love this place! Walk in and there is classic r&b music playing in the main bar. Lots of 60's memorabilia surrounds the bar area. In the back of the house there is a room with booths and high tops and a piano in the corner. We didn't come in on this night to join the karaoke- just to have a couple of cocktails at the bar but the karaoke with the live piano player seems to be great fun. So much classier than typical karaoke. My assumption is you probably need to know the words to the song you request being there doesn't seem to be a big screen with the words flashing across. There is a food menu as well with light snacks - didn't try so couldn't speak to food. I would love to come back here with some friends for a fun night next time I'm in NYC.
google avatar

Marc K.

Yelp
This is only for the cocktails was served. Went last Saturday, ordered a Hemingway last time and it was superb. This time it was nasty and tasted like sour mix. Usually I would return the drink but the bartender gave attitude while preparing and looked miserable. Maybe a bad night for him. But the drink was awful and a waste of money. People were having a good time but I'd avoid the place on a Saturday night unless you want a crowd of young drunk birthday revelers. I'll stick to week night next time.

Jim S.

Yelp
First experience at Sid Gold's with the work family-wow, such an entertaining and unique night out (and definitely something I encourage anyone in the NYC area to check out for themselves). Even if you are not into piano or karaoke, I assure you it will be an evening well spent. Our gracious host *Tania*, was a ROCKSTAR. She was attentive, accommodating, downright magnificent. Also, I guarantee you will be blown away by how well (or like myself-how poorly) some people can sing. Regardless, with Tania taking care of your experience and Wendy Ip on the keys, prepare for a wonderful time. Please try Sid Gold's for yourself at your earliest convenience.
google avatar

Jasmine C.

Yelp
I went here on a whim with a couple friends and I loved it. I'm not one for doing live piano karaoke but with some liquid courage it was a blast. I came on a Monday night so there were only 2-3 other parties I like on weekends where it gets super crowded. The piano player is fantastic. He is not only encouraging but so helpful when you're just trying to put yourself out there and have a good time. Everyone was encouraging as well. However, I would say people who come here can sing and it isn't easy for those who can't to get up there (unless you come on an empty night like us!!)

Vo T.

Yelp
Great Atmosphere, great vibes, great music, and great drinks. This is one of my favorite places to frequent. Although I haven't quite built the courage to sing, just being here makes you want to try
google avatar

DJ D.

Yelp
This is my favorite piano bar in the city (sorry Marie's!). Really have to be a good singer to hold your own at this place.
google avatar

Cam E.

Yelp
Fun live piano karaoke bar in the Flatiron District. Tons of music choices for all genres. Everyone sings, even if you sound good, mediocre, or bad, or even worse. All good fun! Best drinks! Great times!
google avatar

Fred A.

Yelp
Man, I'm a sucker for this sort of place. The piano players generally can play most of what you want, as long as it's not Top 40. And I LOVE karaoke. But it's not for everyone...as some of my friends found out the hard way. Kind of dark, saloon/speakeasy-ish vibes. The booths have concave walls that reflect the sound super well. And the drinks, or at least beers, are fairly priced. And the crowd is super supportive. I never felt awkward singing Bowie, or ABBA, or...
google avatar

Josephine Z.

Yelp
This place is a friggin' gem. It appears quaint and small when you first walk in, but keep walking and proceed past the heavy velvet curtain to what is a semi-glamorous piano room--rife with lively chatter and sing-alongs. The piano bar is truly a sight to behold--ready for song requests to appease your need to belch out your favorite songs--on live piano of course! How friggin' cool. The cocktails are solid here too--and although it's not the cheapest place to drink, it's definitely among the classiest.

Jeff M.

Yelp
I walked in on a Wednesday night with 40 people. We just randomly picked a bar nearby after a happy hour industry event. You'd think that an empty bar would appreciate a boost in customers, but instead they were angry an rude. So rude that they complained that we should have called to make reservations (at an empty bar), and we were an inconvenience to them. They can't support a group our size (at an empty bar), and found every excuse to be nasty. Ok, so you don't want $600+in new revenue? I suppose the owner of the bar may have a different attitude getting so much business on an off night. Seriously, this place better find new staff because you just ran off 40 people that could have been regulars, or at least paid your rent. I never give reviews since all bars have their off nights, but this was just insane and uncalled for.
google avatar

Josh K.

Yelp
Perfect happy hour spot in the Penn Station area. Why? - Piano karaoke, obviously - If you don't like piano karaoke, they separate the two areas and you can sit in the front bar. It's very difficult to hear one section while sitting in the other, so that's neat. - Good small bites selections at generally fair prices (deviled eggs were the bomb!) - Respectable range of cocktails, beers, and happy hour wines - Cool alcove style booths that make it easier to hear friends sitting across the table from you! Note: Do not ask for Piano Man. I repeat, do not ask for Piano Man! They are sick of it.
google avatar

William J.

Yelp
This place has decent cocktails, including a pretty solid hot toddy for when the weather's cold or you're feeling sick. It gets very loud though, and there is no escaping the sound of whoever is singing, so when they're terrible, it can be quite painful. I like to come here during the week after work before the live band shows up and I can just have my cocktails in peace. If you're more of an exhibitionist and prefer your karaoke in front of strangers, this is the place to show off. You'll feel like a star in front of that beautiful baby grand. The alcoves in the back near the stage make for comfortable seating, and the curvature of it creates a whispering gallery effect much like the one at Grand Central. I'm not sure if it would work as well during performances when the bar is loud, but when it's quiet and your head is positioned just right, you can hear the person across from you whisper perfectly. Interesting acoustics, I wonder if it was intentional.

Katharine H.

Yelp
Could've been A LOT better! This is NYC for goodness sakes! I'm very disappointed in the lack of quality. Piano player doesn't have much of a voice.
google avatar

Hawk A.

Yelp
I almost don't want to write as good a review as this place deserves because I don't want the line for singers to get any longer than it is, but I like these guys ... I've sung in five or six piano bars in the City and Sid's is hands down the best of them. It's not only a great venue with terrific cocktails, but the piano players are too much fun. If you spend much time here you will figure out who you gel with the best or whose song list works for you, but they are all very talented and fun. I'm a big fan of John Khoury and Leslie Goshko, and Joe McGinty is a legend ... Kind of hard not to have a good time. The service can slow down when they get busy, but I always get what I ask for and the staff is friendly. The menu is small but the food is good. The only thing they need is a good porter or stout on the beer list, but the Ginger Old Fashioned is pretty outstanding. See you there ...
google avatar

James A.

Yelp
Get a drink at the bar and head through the curtain at the back if you enjoy singing to a crowd. It's similar to open-room karaoke except here you're singing along with a live pianist playing your song on choice on the baby grand. True story: I took my girlfriend here for our first date (later found out she loves karaoke too) and we've been together ever since.
google avatar

Raisaa T.

Yelp
If you want karaoke please go somewhere else.. U won't get ur turn here. If u want good drinks, please go somewhere else the drinks are tiny here but not the price! If u want good service, definitely go somewhere else.. The bar tenders were soooo rude. Horrible experience. Hope this helps someone else in the future
google avatar

David T.

Yelp
So much fun! Great piano players. Our group thought we'd "pop in". Ended up staying for hours. How have I never come here before? Will be back for sure!