Jocelyn L.
Yelp
This is one of those tough reservations to get these days, another hot spot. I'm thinking it's a hot spot because the chef of Aphotic left and started this place? (We loved Aphotic back when it was still open!) anyway, my husband somehow snagged a 2-person reservation on a Friday night.
We arrived on time for our 5:30pm reso on Friday night. Music was blasting, funk music, that was extremely loud (have to shout to your dining partner) but a fun way (for some) to get your weekend started. However, I thought the music was way too loud, and actually a bit overwhelming for my taste. Our table was a tiny, cramped table for 2. The whole restaurant was cramped though, tables with barely any room between to get through before sitting down, barely any headroom if your daughter has dropped her crayon and you need to pick it up, barely any room to put a diaper bag in between tables on banquette seating.
We ordered the Garlic French fries, Shrimp, Artichoke Dip, Gnocchi with short rib, and Halibut with gigante beans. The Shrimp was good, and garlic fries good, but generally everything was just okay. The artichoke dip was too rich. The short rib in the gnocchi tasted dry. I just didn't see what the hype was about. Nothing seemed unique, or particular fresh ingredients that blow your mind away. One piece of the halibut did taste fishy, but the other pieces were fine. Actually the stand out favorite dish was the Carrot Cake, which had amazing cream cheese frosting (not too sweet or heavy), which paired nicely with the crispy bits of walnut and I think coconut bits. It was $18 for a mini cake - very pricy, but delicious, and we did take home some leftovers (just for our dignity, my husband could've finished it on the spot). I will say that I loved their Heath Ceramic dinnerwear. Nice touch.
Also, there was an article run the day before in the Chronicle about how Side A had terrific service, exceptional, how they treat you as if you're members of their family. We did not experience this amazing service. Yes, the service was good, but just as good as any other restaurant - nothing stand out. Not sure why they would write a whole article to highlight this. No special accommodations for our toddler either. He called the day before and asked if we could get a slightly larger spot since we'd have our toddler daughter joining us. They said yes, but when we arrived, we still got a cramped 2-top table squashed between those tables I described above. I wasn't expecting anything special for our daughter, but somehow was, since an article was run about how hospitable they are to all their customers.
I'm not terribly excited to return, although I think perhaps if we ordered different menu items, we would have had a slightly different experience. The food itself was underwhelming, and the ambiance was overwhelming (way too noisy and loud, cramped tables). What a weird combo. It'll be a hard sell for me to return.