Lindsay F.
Yelp
I have been here several times now and I am absolutely shocked by how many people gave five stars. I've always enjoyed the service, the ambience, and it is nice that they have a parking lot. Cocktails are good, albeit extremely small especially for the price. I would be surprised if the volume was more than 6 ounces for drinks that start at $12. Although they are creative and tasty.
Here is the problem: Great base ingredients and extremely poor execution of food, which came in tiny portions, unbalanced, and waaay tooo expensive.
The first time here I got the beef tartare...it was one noted. All I tasted was the beef umami- which was great! The ingredients were superb, the meat obviously fresh. And yet, after 3 bites, I was wanting some acid, some fresh crisp green and textural contrast. To give the servers credit, they openly listened to my comments.
Then, I came back for the charcuterie (technically and fromage, as charcuterie in French refers only to the meat, but I digress...) for $29. Two meats, 3 1" x 1/2" x maaybe 3" tiny finger sized wedges of cheese. There was some toasted corns, honey and lingonberry mustard as accoutrements. Oh yea. And 2 tiny wedges of watermelon, which were so tiny, I am embarrassed to admit they event mentioned it as part of the plate. These were even smaller than the tiny cheese wedges, and with more rhine. Okay. Fine. Small portions, I've lived in and dined in those overly pretentious places in NYC, Miami, LA and other places where they argue the small portions with higher prices are worth it for the unique and well composed dishes...Surdyk's sidebar is NOT the case. Instead, small portions for high prices and one noted dishes falling flat. The plate came with a bacon that was then pulled and treated as force meat and made into a sort or roulette, and speck. Okay. WHY, if a chef is about to showcase only 2 meats on a charcuterie board (again, prior definitions in this review may be re reviewed) would you not only choose two meats of the same animal, but then, the same part of the same animal, and then take the uniqueness of one of the meats (bacon and its crispy crispy saltiness) and render it more similar to a forced meat cured meat such as ... um... speck? The cheese was good, but begged for a difference on the palette, especially since the meats (charcuterie) were so similar. Again, the cheeses were TERRIFIC. A good sheep's milk softer cheese, and... two other medium/hard white cheeses from Europe that were quite similar. I used the mustard quite liberally to cut through the umami umami umami without an appropriate freshness that fruits usually give. Although, there were several pieces of dark high percentage cocoa chocolate that was nummyyy...
Come on, Surdyks Sidebar! You have all of the pieces and yet fail on the food dish execution! In the meantime, come with a small party and chill in the bar for good and creative cocktails. Or go shop the cheeses and meats in the store that is attached. When the Sidebar's food execution equates to the creativity, uniqueness, balance and deliciousness of the cocktails, then it will be a stellar place for quality food as well.