Makayla J.
Yelp
A Worthwhile Experience -- But Be Prepared to Wait
We recently dined at Simon'a and overall had a wonderful experience -- but there are a few things to be aware of before you go. They don't take reservations for parties under six, so we showed up shortly after they opened at 5:05 PM. We were told the next available table would be at 7:30 PM, which we expected based on other reviews, so no issue there. However, we were told we couldn't leave during the wait and needed to stay in the bar area next door (which is attached to the restaurant). That part felt a bit restrictive.
Sitting in the bar for 2.5 hours without any appetizer options was honestly tough, especially if you're hungry. I think it would be more reasonable to allow guests to leave and return closer to their seating time -- or at least allow them to leave for a bit and then return to the bar an hour before being seated. It did feel like the policy might be in place just to keep you spending money at their bar. That's my only real complaint.
That said, once we were seated at 7:30 on the dot, the experience improved drastically. Our server was incredibly kind and helpful with the menu, and the food was outstanding from start to finish. For appetizers, we had the onion rings (a full order easily fed four of us -- light, crispy, and delicious) and the artichoke dip, which far exceeded expectations. It was rich, flavorful, and clearly made with love -- not your basic, boring dip.
For the main course, I had the 6 oz Steak De Burgo. It was cooked to perfection, beautifully seasoned, and served with mashed potatoes and asparagus -- all of which were excellent. My husband ordered the New York, New York, topped with a creamy mushroom sauce. He loved it -- said everything was delicious and expertly prepared. His only minor wish was that it came with a baked potato instead of mashed.
The cherry on top? A complimentary slice of red velvet cake -- hands down the best I've ever had. Moist, rich, and absolutely delicious.
A gentleman with a backwards hat (perhaps the chef or Simon himself?) came around to check on us, which was a nice touch and made the experience feel personal.
Final thoughts:
The food and service were exceptional, and it was definitely worth the wait -- just be prepared for that long wait and know you'll need to stay nearby. We'll absolutely be back!