Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co

Pizza restaurant · Morningside Heights

Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co

Pizza restaurant · Morningside Heights

1

1215 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10027

Photos

Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null
Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co by null

Highlights

Brick-oven pizza with fresh dough, truffle & buffalo chicken  

Placeholder
Placeholder
Placeholder

1215 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10027 Get directions

slicedbyharlempizzaco.com
@slicedbyhpc

$10–20 · Menu

Information

Static Map

1215 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10027 Get directions

+1 646 490 6900
slicedbyharlempizzaco.com
@slicedbyhpc

$10–20 · Menu

Features

payment credit card
Tap to pay

Last updated

Aug 7, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

Jay-Z Spends $100K at NY Nightclub - Eater NY

"A third space for Harlem Pizza Co.’s brick-oven pizza at 1215 Amsterdam Ave. in Morningside Heights." - Stefanie Tuder

https://ny.eater.com/2018/2/20/17031490/jay-z-balling-nyc
View Postcard for Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co

Gary Wilson

Google
Small slice for $3.25, but a decent amount of cheese and sauce Chewy, crispy crust is medium thin, the thickness is required to hold the topping. Very good sauce flavor. The cheese is undercooked, it's basically just melted, but the crust is overcooked. Crust flavor is good. I'll give it an 87.

Lazarus

Google
Got three slices of pizza here through too good to go. Thick, heavy, dry cheese, sauce was too thick and not tomato-ey, very sugary marinara sauce. More importantly I got diarrhea. I'm not certain it was from here but the only other thing I ate was a cream cheese and smoked salmon bagel from a bagel place. Crucially, three friends ate bagels too and didn't get diarrhea whereas only I got pizza here. It is however possible something else caused it so I won't speak in absolutes. Nonetheless it is worth mentioning. Regardless the pizza was very poor and I do not recommend.

Angelique Josette Olmo

Google
Love this place. Buffalo Chicken is topped with blue cheese and the mushroom truffle is lovely. Crust is crispy, ingredients are fresh. One thing is the painting of the legs and bottom of a woman at the stairs. It's clever and cute for a strip club maybe but really there is no excuse to have that in a pizza place.

Max Zinner

Google
Awesome slices with fantastic fresh dough sourced locally. I highly recommend the truffle pizza as well as the buffalo chicken flavors. This is a really really great addition to the neighborhood and Columbia community and will definitely plan to return soon!

Yvonne Strumecki

Google
So disappointed. They completely left off an ingredient on our pizza (a sweet sausage/red peppers pizza without onions is just WRONG on so many levels.) The bbq sauce wings were so dry and overcooked that they were tough to eat. We won’t be ordering from them again.

Kristen M

Google
got the porcini truffle slice and it was very good! i was impressed. great location near Columbia.

Chris H

Google
Walked with a coworker to this location, they were not open at 11. After waiting for roughly 15 minutes, they opened at 1122a. Walked inside to be disappointed at the options. They had just 3 classics: cheese, pepperoni, bianca. All the other slices were their own. Definitely not an old school pizza shop, more for the younger college students.

Gabriel Rosario

Google
They randomly followed me on Instagram, so I decided to try them out. I had a Margherita slice and it was DELICIOUS! The locals are very fortunate to have this great pizza spot. I will gladly come back and bring friends next time.