Jeff O.
Yelp
For many many years, critics penning positive reviews of Upper West Side restaurants would always preface their positivity by stipulating that the UWS was, generally speaking, a dining wasteland. There was some truth to the observation, but it became less accurate and more lazy with each passing year. And as time went by, the observation also seemed to betray a certain insecurity, as if critics feared losing their street cred if they praised a UWS restaurant without tacking on a condescending disclaimer about the neighborhood's food scene.
Anyway, the wasteland pejorative is rarely seen anymore, and it really would be a cringe thing to say nowadays, because the UWS of 2023 is practically overflowing with excellent eats. Some of those eats are available at entirely new, real-deal destinations, such as the Times' newly crowned best restaurant in all of NYC, Tatiana at Lincoln Center.
But some of them are also available at offshoots of restaurants that started in other parts of NYC, did well and decided to open their second (or third, or fourth) location in a neighborhood that, according to critics, desperately needed more quality comestibles. During the past 10-15 years, the UWS has welcomed carbon copies of countless respected restaurants, including Legend, Crave Fishbar, Grain House, Han Dynasty, Vin Sur Vingt, Joe's Steam Rice Roll, Orwashers, The Smith, Vanessa's Dumplings, Mimi Cheng's, William Greenberg, La Pecora Bianca, Chama Mama, RedFarm, Jin Ramen, Jing Fong, Motorino, Tacombi, Le Botaniste and Felice.
Song'E Napule, which got its start in the West Village, is one of the latest entrants into this category, giving UWSers a new option for Neapolitan pizza (one can never have too many such options, imo).
It's been an immediate hit -- don't assume you'll be able to walk in without a wait at prime time -- and the small, boisterous space boasts a super-fun vibe. Decor is quite modern, except for the wood-burning oven, a real beauty covered in colorful ceramic tiles.
The libations list is compact and interesting (don't miss the cocktails with Blue Curacao that call to mind the coast of Capri), and it offers refreshingly reasonable prices -- you can get a quality glass of Falanghina for $14, and a stiff drink for a dollar or two more.
Pies are properly charred and exceptionally rich, thanks to generous toppings (including a hearty fried eggplant) and a signature swirl of cheese fondue that often adorns the pizzas.
Close your eyes and you can almost imagine yourself in Italy, but make no mistake, this is really and truly the Upper West Side.