Samantha S.
Yelp
The post-renovation report: It's a completely different museum than you remember, and likely to get even better. 4.5 stars, if you want to get technical.
Forget what you think you know. The space now is bright and modern, the exhibits are eclectic, and the whole enterprise feels energized and relevant. The combination of artistic endeavor and the celebration of craft and trade is enlightening.
You get the idea immediately. At the top of the escalator, you pass under a geometric hanging sculpture made of hundreds of fishing weights. Surprisingly modern and totally unexpected.
Then, a roomful of ship models in bottles (with a hidden case that reveals how it's done, should you want to know). There's another gallery with large model ships and a moody photo exhibit of ships being dismantled in India.
Just when you think the whole place will be about seafaring, other galleries show you furniture, objects, and fashion made in New York--everything from model staircases to deconstructed evening gowns. Now you begin to see how the waterfront is a jumping-off point to learning about the city's history and development.
Keep going, and it gets even more interesting: a spread of woodworking tools, arranged artistically; the remains of a ghostly boarding house; a video about JFK airport; an installation of archival footage of the waterfront; a scaled-down version of the spectacular "Mannahatta" (originally shown at the Museum of the City of New York in 2009, it visualizes the island in 1609); an oddly compelling documentary about life at the Fulton Fish Market; a massive photo collection about Occupy Wall Street; and another photo gallery featuring two artists whose work uses wide-angle lenses to explore the city.
The old building themselves are an attraction, with their antique graffiti, sloping floors, giant cogs, exposed joists. We saw almost everything in about an hour and a half. The gift shop on the ground floor is, like the rest of the place, very well curated. Admission is only $5 for adults. The security guards here are the nicest I have ever met; they were all welcoming and actually interested in the exhibits. One guy and I wonkily agreed that everything in the tool display should have been identified.
My only caveat is that this is still a work in progress. The elevators were not working today, so if this is an issue for you, call ahead. We were told there was a coat check, but we never found it. Some exhibits' touchscreens were not yet installed. The multimedia introduction, "Timescapes," is borrowed from the MCNY; it's fine if you're a tourist.
But I think the new Seaport Museum as a whole will appeal to locals. This quirky and impressionistic collection is a great way to explore your own hometown.