Shay M.
Yelp
This is the kind of pizza you want to bring home to mama. Oh and the cookies are dumb fire, so what are you waiting for?
I know your fridge is overloaded with turkey day leftovies, but once the dust has settled, you'll wanna scoot your boots down to Cass street for this MUST HAVE pizza pie.
Located on a hot little foodie block with the likes of Dave's HC, Harry's TC, Cass St. B&G, and Big Jim's RB, lies this absolute GEM of a pizza palace. It was important to mention those other spots as that's what initially brought me to the area. After shoveling down nearly an entire burrito, we began strolling past Square, when I decided to pop in and "just have a look". Well, what started as just having a look, turned into two slices and two cookies. I believe the total came in at around $18, which seemed pretty reasonable for what they deemed "the best cookies", and a couple delicious looking, thicker than a snicker, slices of pie.
Needless to say, if I couldn't finish the burrito, I had no business trying to eat pizza that night, so in the fridge it went. After scarfing down on those spectacular and rotund cookies (also a MUST HAVE), the pizza sat lonely in the fridge from Friday until Monday evening. Thinking I had probably wasted my money by leaving the pizza in the box for 3 days in the fridge, I figured I'd take my chances and throw that pepperoni in the oven at 450 degrees for 5-7 minutes. What came out was some of the best pie I've had in San Diego. Believe it or not, we did the same thing with a slice of the white pie the next night, Day 4, and it too was supremely delicious!
I don't advise leaving your pie in the fridge for several days, but if you do, just know you'll still have some excellent eats coming your way.
Absolutely bomb pizza, oh the crust, and some incredible cookies, makes this place a must see.
Thanks to the friendly and helpful cashier who recommended the cookies.
I'll most definitely be back!!!