Elizabeth C.
Yelp
San Francisco's oldest diner is still serving up amazing food in the year 2024. I had the Vegan Thing and it was ridiculously delicious. It's quite literally a delectable mess - soft tofu - serving as sort of mock eggs, Soyrizo crumbled into every bite, hearty hunks of potato, gooey, sliced mushrooms (I detest mushroom but it was more than tolerable as it was just a small amount), silky vegan cheese melted all throughout - topped with beautifully fresh guacamole. A hearty vegan meal. My brain says this is breakfast food but honestly - I could go to town on this at any time of day. We were a large group - EVERYONE loved their food! Everyone also commented that their fries were "real fries" - thick but not too thick - perfectly cooked - flawless.
This is a legacy business. I yearn for the days of the old St Francis Fountain - that had heart and felt like a home away from home. As it is now - we were ushered into the side/attached room that smelled old and damp and funky - and had a cafeteria vibe. I don't know - the charm of the St Francis Fountain I used to frequent is all but gone. At least they still have some very sparse holdovers in some original decor on the walls - that's about it.
We mostly dealt with the manager - I forget how to spell his name but apparently it's pronounced like "Ronny" I think. He was okay. He seemed to barely tolerate us from the get-go. Maybe it was an off day - I'll give him that. He was disconnected - disinterested - almost dismissive. No, we didn't slip in just before closing. No, the place wasn't slammed. We were all happy, quiet and respectful - not sure what rubbed him the wrong way. We weren't impressed.
The bathroom. It's not very clean. I had to clean pee off the toilet seat, there was pee on the ground, it smelled like pee, etc. A bit gross - but! Not the grossest public restroom I've used. Still, I expected a little more from a food establishment. It can be awkward if you're pee-shy - it's basically *very* near a booth - facing the booth, to be specific. You go there making eye contact with someone on one side of the booth and come out making eye contact with someone on the other side haha. No biggie. The door was too loose for my comfort. I peed while leaning forward and holding tightly to the doorknob. There's a flimsy slide lock to keep the door closed and it's hanging on for dear life. It's also loose enough that it seems like the door will flap open, just enough, for the restaurant to see you sitting on the toilet. It would take someone 10 minutes max to break out the drill and re-align the lock. Just putting that out there.
So do I recommend this place? Yes - for the food! For the history! The atmosphere is lacking (yes, even for a diner). The service was bare minimum. The bathroom is gross and a bit strange. But seriously - the food is top tier and the location truly is magnificent.
Updating the menus was a wonderful and strategic move! This keeps them competitive and will turn diners into loyal customers. They should consider leaning into their history a bit more, tho. The history is what keeps us coming back - generations of our family have eaten there. It's sad to see a little less of that history each time we return. Having a conversation with a local who's been there for decades - I learned we weren't alone in that thinking. We moved a long time ago but return to the old neighborhood to see how the Mission is getting along. St Francis should print up some historic photos, frame and hang them. Print up some of the articles written about them. Add some throwback decor. Right now, it just seems like a rundown building that's seen better days. If they remind people of why it's a little rough - it would be embraced and not unfairly judged..... Just my two cents.
Go to St Francis Fountain. Eat the incredible food they're serving up - put money into the owners hands to keep the place going. If you have a little time, familiarize yourself with that location and then go eat there with fresh eyes. It's pretty cool. We don't want to lose this place like we lost Roosevelt Tamale Parlor (another location - right there - that was rich with storied history).
Go. Eat. Tip. Keep it alive.