NJ K.
Yelp
I find it unfortunate that I have to write this review, but I feel obligated to share my experience.
We came here with high hopes. We did arrive early (we were the first people seated), and initially, everything seemed primed for a great night. Friendly staff, interesting cocktails, and a really cool space.
When we walked in, the place was empty. The staff let us know that people generally arrive later in the night (we did come early, around 9PM, but we are out-of-towners), and the bar was recommended to us. The staff let us know that they had a reservation at one table, but could guarantee us seating at another if we stayed the night.
After discussing, we decided to stay the evening at this bar and support the staff who had -- up until this point -- been friendly and generous.
Interestingly enough, as the bar started to get more crowded, the staff let us know that we needed to move tables. This was not an issue for us, as they had let us know ahead of time that we would be guaranteed seating at another table. However, when the time came to move, they informed us that there was nowhere for us to sit, but we were "welcome to stand around the bar".
Ordinarily, this is not something I would take issue with. But the fact that this establishment went out of their way to guarantee us seating, have us stay for 2 hours, ordering drinks and food, only to shoo us away and renege their "guarantee" of a table once the place started getting more crowded, was upsetting. Had they been honest with us from the start and not gone out of their way to try and keep us there when the bar was empty, (and let us know that they couldn't seat us past 11), I would have had no issue.
As someone who has traveled to many cities, I've had the privilege of going out to different bars, clubs, lounges, etc. I am willing to overlook many things, and do not see myself as a "hard reviewer" (most of my ratings are 4-5 stars). One thing that I will not put up with is disrespect and blatant lies. Unfortunately, this was our experience at Stillife.
The only beacon of hope at this place was our initial waiter, Vince. He was cool, considerate, and helpful. This establishment would do well to promote him over their current management.
I would avoid this place (despite its cool decor) and find somewhere more willing to respect their customers.
Needless to say, we won't be returning.