Jose A.
Yelp
Checked this spot out last month on a Friday night (around 9:15 pm) a couple of days or so after it first opened. Pretty good food, though sorry to say that I don't think it was up to par with the other restaurants in the Great American Restaurants franchise.
So Stupid Good BBQ is actually across the street from one of the more popular Great American Restaurants, Mike's American Grill (next to the Planet Fitness off Backlick Road). That's in addition to another Great American Restaurant (Best Buns) that's located in the same shopping center complex just a few doors down.
Walked in and assumed I'd be seated, but apparently you have to wait in line and order/pay for the food at the counter first (so this isn't a restaurant where a waiter takes your order at the table). But the restaurant wasn't busy that night so didn't long at all (less than 5 minutes) to get through the line and place my order.
Restaurant was less than half full and it appeared to be open seating so just picked an open table. Food only took 7-10 minutes or so to come out, which wasn't bad at all. I ordered the Creekstone Farms® prime brisket ($19), a side of mac and cheese ($5), and a cup of water ($0). Stupid Good BBQ has a fountain soda system, which is where I filled my cup of water. They serve beer here, which seemed reasonably priced from $4 to $8. The only draft beer they had here was Shiner Brock ($5 glass, $18 pitcher). A limited selection of cocktails, liquor, and wine are also available here, also at very reasonable prices (from $5 to $8).
When I received my order I was provided a fork but they didn't give me a knife or the free cornbread that's supposed to come with the order; I had to go back to the counter to ask for it. But this wasn't a big deal - all the people who worked there seemed helpful and friendly.
I thought the prime brisket was extremely solid. Very good, though wouldn't put it up there with the best I've had in the DMV. One thing that irked me is they didn't have any spicy sauces available, which IMO is an absolute must for any elite BBQ restaurant. I asked one server what the spiciest sauce they had available was, which she said was the Carolina BBQ, but that sauce was very far from "spicy". So I asked another server what their spiciest sauce was; she responded that they don't really have anything too spicy, but that I could try a BBQ sauce not listed on their menu called "Texas Trails" that to her was the spiciest sauce they had. That sauce did have a little kick to it, but wasn't all that spicy either. So was definitely disappointed this restaurant didn't have a true
"spicy" sauce.
The mac and cheese (which came in the form of gooey shells) I thought was good, though nothing special.
Stupid Good BBQ also has a small dessert menu of chocolate bourbon pecan pie and bread pudding, which are made at an affiliated Best Buns restaurant a few doors down from this restaurant.
Stupid Good BBQ does have 3 TVs, though this wouldn't be an ideal place to watch sports, especially since they didn't seem to have a bar area.
All-in-all, this is a good restaurant, though I definitely wouldn't put it up there with elite BBQ spots in the DMV like 2Fifty and Monk's. Also thought the food was a bit pricy for what it was, though the drink prices I think are pretty reasonable. Expected more given the affiliation with the Great American Restaurants but I'd still rate it as a spot worth checking out. Would grade it in the 3.75 or 3.5 range but rounded up to 4 due to the friendly customer service and because the main prime brisket dish I ate was actually a really solid dish.
Will be back again sometime in the future though don't think I'd be making this a regular spot.