Sugar Shane's

Bakery · Atlanta

Sugar Shane's

Bakery · Atlanta

3

398 14th St NW suite a-1, Atlanta, GA 30318

Photos

Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by Sugar Shane’s
Sugar Shane's by The Infatuation
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null
Sugar Shane's by null

Highlights

Gourmet cookies, brownies, & blondies, gooey & decadent  

Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in Eater

398 14th St NW suite a-1, Atlanta, GA 30318 Get directions

sugarshanes.com
@sugar_shanes

$1–10 · Menu

Information

Static Map

398 14th St NW suite a-1, Atlanta, GA 30318 Get directions

+1 678 332 1391
sugarshanes.com
@sugar_shanes

$1–10 · Menu

Features

payment credit card
Tap to pay

Last updated

Aug 18, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@infatuation

The Best Chocolate Chip Cookies In Atlanta, Ranked

"In part thanks to their delicious offerings, multiple locations, and late-night hours, Sugar Shanes has become a must-stop for cookie lovers. Their chocolate chip cookie is thick enough to rival a slice of cake, with a crumbly texture that’ll have you reaching for extra napkins. And don’t overlook the special heating instructions on the box because they taste even better when they’re gooey and melty." - jacinta howard, juli horsford, nina reeder

https://www.theinfatuation.com/atlanta/guides/the-best-chocolate-chip-cookies-in-atlanta-ranked
View Postcard for Sugar Shane's
@infatuation

Where To Get Late-Night Desserts In Atlanta

"Open until 12am, Friday & Saturday Sugar Shane’s is hidden behind a halal grocery store on 14th Street, so just follow the steady trail of speeding gig work drivers doing cookie deliveries for Georgia Tech students to find it. As soon as you make it through the door, there's a rush of bright lights and loud music—look at it as setting the scene for your incoming sugar high. Expect giant, dense cookies so overstuffed that a heavy-lifting warning feels appropriate. And they're good. Flavors like the banana pudding are packed with big chunks of vanilla wafers and vanilla chips, while the Dashing Delta has pieces of Biscoff and an oozing cookie butter middle." - jacinta howard, juli horsford, nina reeder

https://www.theinfatuation.com/atlanta/guides/best-late-night-dessert
View Postcard for Sugar Shane's
@eater

The Most Instagrammable and Beautiful Desserts in Atlanta | Eater Atlanta

"Are cookies considered dessert? The cookies at Sugar Shane’s definitely fit the bill. The Atlanta-based company, with three locations in Midtown, Sandy Springs, and Ponce City Market, began during the pandemic, immediately creating a stir on social media with stuffed, bigger-than-your-face, eye-popping cookies. The flavors are a dentist’s nightmare, but oh-so-good, with combinations like the Bulldog — a white chocolate chip-studded red velvet cookie stuffed with Oreo cheesecake — and the seasonal Carrot Top — a carrot cake cookie with butterscotch and old fashioned glaze." - Lia Picard

https://atlanta.eater.com/maps/most-beautiful-instagramable-desserts-atlanta
View Postcard for Sugar Shane's

1hunnitjxy

Google
My girlfriend and I have been loyal Sugar Shane’s customers for over 4 years, visiting all their locations, and every single time we leave with a smile on our faces. The 14th Street location in Atlanta continues to exceed our expectations with every visit. The cookies are always fresh, delicious, and perfectly prepared, but what truly sets Sugar Shane’s apart is the incredible service. Tonight, My boy Uncle Mike went above and beyond for us—even though they were just 5 minutes from closing, he greeted us warmly, took amazing care of us, and even heated our cookies so we could enjoy them at their absolute best. That kind of attention and kindness means so much, and it’s exactly why we keep coming back. We feel truly blessed to have Sugar Shane’s as part of our routine and can’t thank the team enough for making every visit feel special. Keep up the amazing work—you’ve got customers for life!

Ambria Sawyer

Google
MIKE! Was a phenomenal and his customer service was amazing. Warm & welcoming! He brought out fresh baked cookies. There cookies was super soft but not to sugary. My whole experience was 10/10. I recommend Banana Pudding, Strawberries (the frosting taste like strawberries)

Atalya Manchester

Google
IF Y’ALL DON’T COME AND GET SOME OF THIS!! I am a cookie fanatic and these sweets did not come to play. As soon as you walk in, you’re greeted with kindness and the smells bring you comfort. Go to the one and Midtown and Let Uncle Mike take care of you because he’s gonna get y’all right! ;) DEFINITELY will be coming back

Taylor C

Google
All desserts are always soooooo good! I’ve tried their cookies, brownies, blondies, breads, you name it. On top of flavor, Sugar Shane’s is a good bang for your buck. All the desserts are pretty huge. They’re open late and the staff is very kind and friendly, even within the last few minutes of business. I’d recommend going well before closing time if you want to have an array of options, as they can run out later in the night. Please try this place because you will not be disappointed! This photo is just from one of my trips? Where I tried the Banana bread, Oreo peanut butter cookie, and a cookies and cream.

Beatriz Rodriguez

Google
This was one of the places we wanted to visit on our trip to Atlanta. Sadly didn’t live up to our expectations. At first we thought it was welcoming and then it went left. While Mike was letting us know the different flavors etc, he stopped mid sentence because our family member asked her sons what they wanted( they were in the car) There was 3 of us standing there like ummm confused as to why he was so rude. We let it go and continued to order they ordered their 4 desserts and as I was ordering my 3, Mike again rudely says” I didn’t hear the last two things since you are talking amongst yourselves “ my response was I was talking to you, I just wasn’t screaming.( music was blasting) He said oh sorry and grabbed our stuff. Rang us up with such an attitude it completely threw the whole excitement of trying these off. Was hoping that at least what we got lived up to the hyped we’ve been seeing, sadly it did not. Wasn’t worth the trip over there nor the money we paid. Just saw there are different locations. I would say please go to a different location then 14th St Northwest. Hopefully you get a better experience than we did.

Carla Burke

Google
It was a nice and friendly spot and the cookies are delicious and home made. I will be back and tell my friends about this hidden gem I’ve found.owe yeah and the gentleman that served us was very nice and had an inviting personality!!!!!!

Meet The Penns

Google
First time here and soooo good! Will definitely come back whenever visiting in Atlanta. I loved the vibe of this shop being in a garage felt like a underground hidden gem

Eric Heppen

Google
Came here for a quick late night snack, new to the area and chain. Food here was great!! We got a variety of sweet treats to go (cheesecake brownie, cookie and cream, a chocolate one, and something else). We would come back easily. Location is a little sus and harder to find.
google avatar

Katherine G.

Yelp
Absolutely MASSIVE cookies. I was recommended this spot and decided to venture out on my way home one day. The location is really odd, as it's behind the line of restaurants and into a literal garage. However, once you find it it's very much worth it. I got the red velvet/vanilla swirl and the biscoff cookies, as it was my first time here. They were both served fresh and warm and gooey - basically to the point of falling apart. If you like cookies that are almost slightly raw and doughy, this is definitely the spot for you. The thickness of the cookies is great, and they are PACKED with chocolate chips / toffee bits / whatever is in the cookie you choose. They are certainly very sweet, but satisfy that cookie craving so well. This might be my favorite, or one of my favorite of the (literally) big cookie chains out there - think Crumbl, Levain, Chip, etc - be sure to check it out!
google avatar

Amanda P.

Yelp
These were the besttttt cookies!!!! The lemon cookie was my favorite! The classic chocolate chip was also really good with crispy edges 10/10 Cookies and creme was also a must!
google avatar

Reiley H.

Yelp
The location is a bit weird- it's in a garage behind subway. The workers were super nice and heated up my cookie for me. I wish I had asked them to heat it a little longer because the outside was warm but the inside was cold. The cookie was yummy and it was huge!
google avatar

Marquez C.

Yelp
One of my favorite cookie spots in Atlanta, so good and great value for what you get. Mike is also a major Vibe, always so hospitality, makes me feel like a valued customer. I highly recommend, the banana pudding or the Betty white!
google avatar

Joshua M.

Yelp
Great service! Not much of a sweet person but they were really good. I had the cookies and cream and the chocolate chip. They do have a good amount of specialty cookies that are worth trying. Would definitely be back!
google avatar

Rachel W.

Yelp
Sugar Shane's is the best! I LOVE their goodies and how they frequently rotate flavors, providing a unique experience each time. I have a huge sweet tooth and this is the spot to treat myself to massive desserts. This location is a bit hard to find - there's no signage on the road, so you'll have to trust the GPS when it says to turn into a seemingly random driveway. There, you'll spot a small sign that'll direct you to continue down the driveway and around the corner. There's really not much parking, but people usually don't stay long so I've never had an issue with not being able to park my car. Sign up for their rewards program! They offer a $5 coupon on your birthday :)
google avatar

Symoni L.

Yelp
Sugar Shane's Cookies ! These cookies were so heavy. Each cookies is $6 and I feel it's great for the price. The Banana pudding cookie didn't taste like banana pudding to me. It tasted more like a macadamia with small hints of banana. The fruity pebbles one was very sweet but the cereal on its own was sweet so I expected that. Taste was just overly sweet. M&M one was so nice it was my favorite one maybe bc I love m&ms and it had pieces in that cookie I went to the Ponce location and once again the worker seems like she had an attitude and didn't want to work. She didn't make my shopping experience amazing Ambiance umm it was a cookie location in a food hall so nothing stood out
google avatar

Whitney B.

Yelp
Ordered through Uber Eats and it did not disappointment! We got the 4 cookie order and received the Strawberry Shortcake, S'mores, and Betty White. The cookies came warm and were extremely delicious. My friends and I didn't finish in one sitting, so we saved the rest for later. They came with reheating instructions that worked well too. I would definitely order from here again.
google avatar

Megan Y.

Yelp
I'll preface this by saying I'm not the biggest sweet tooth. Especially when it comes to cookies - I'm more of a cupcake gal. I came here with the $10 for 2 deal offered by Yelp. It's in a reasonably convenient location but the parking situation is a little stressful due to the hill and limited space to back up. The staff was super friendly, helpful, and hardworking. I came in wanting the fruity pebbles cookie but they didn't have it this week so I got the snickerdoodle and red velvet cookies. I tried bits of both and have to admit I liked neither. The cookie was way too thick and it was hard to enjoy a full bite with the additional toppings baked into the cookie. On top of that, it tasted way too sugary! If the fruity pebble cookie returns, I may go back to try just that one but I don't want to be disappointed.
google avatar

Amanda M.

Yelp
Came across the Sugar Shane stall at Ponce Market. I got the Cookie Monster and S'more's. Wow! These cookies were so yummy and gigantic! It took me two days to finish half of each one! They are pretty sweet so if that's not your jam, then you should pass. The size is also perfect to share, which is what it did with my boyfriend!
google avatar

Jinwoo Y.

Yelp
Food: Chocolate Chip ($4) - it was decadent and delicious. A very good quality chocolate chip. Not overly sweet and that slight hint of salt makes all the difference. S'mores ($6) - hands down our favorite in this batch. It's a step up from the chocolate chip and the sticky marshmallow adds a great touch. Banana King ($6) - it was good but a bit on the cakey side and didn't taste too much like banana pudding. Although I am a huge banana pudding fan, so def a bit more critical on this one. Cookies and Cream ($6) - my son always has to get this flavor. He enjoyed thoroughly but it was the sweetest of the bunch. A bit too sweet for my taste. Flavorful nonetheless. Service/Ambience: it was very difficult to find the store. It's hidden behind in the back of the plaza with a small sign that's pretty hidden. Finally found it and it may look like a hole in the wall but very clean inside and the staff is extremely friendly. Overall, a great place to get tasty cookies with a slight twist. Very good on flavors and good size for getting just enough without getting too full. Slightly priced higher than your normal cookies but that comes with the gourmet price tag. We would come back to try more flavors. They are also military friendly! 10% discount
google avatar

Leah S.

Yelp
If someone told me that they needed ransom for a loved one and all they required was my last Dashing Delta cookie, I would have to think really hard about it. That's how good this cookie is. I know I'm being drastic, but seriously this cookie deserves all the praise. Hot gooey Biscoff cookie butter may be one of the best things to grace the Earth and it's the total core of this cookie. Everything I tried was yummy. Got it through DoorDash and LOVE that they gave me the option to reheat the cookies (with very clear instructions) at home. Absolutely can't wait to try more of their menu!
google avatar

Danny M.

Yelp
I must admit walking down towards a dumpster and into a vague looking back entrance isn't ideal; it must be deterring for potential customers. When you enter there's a bit of a make shift front display/checkout. The majority of the place is their kitchen. Most cookies are $6, chocolate chip is $4. Quite expensive considering it is the same price as Gideons Bake Shop in Orlando, but without the prime location, size of cookies, and complexity. Great cookie, but a $6 cookie.. probably not.
google avatar

Crystal B.

Yelp
I was really excited to try Sugar Shane's, but unfortunately I didn't enjoy my cookies. Both were different, one came in a dome shape and the other was more flat. I followed the warming instructions on the box, but with the white macadamia nut the taste was off, it just wasn't what I expected and the chocolate chip cookie was just okay. I'm a dessert fanatic, so this would usually be something I would rave about. I always strive to give honest reviews with helpful feedback if my experience isn't noteworthy. I feel like maybe the recipe can be improved so the cookies can be more chewy, moist and a tad more flavorful/savory. However, the packaging was nice and I loved that they wrote a personal handwritten message on the box. This was a mobile delivery order.
google avatar

Valerie W.

Yelp
I ordered a Betty White through Uber Eats app as an add on to my dinner order because this place had great reviews. Oh my gosh, the cookie was so good! I wasn't sure what to expect from the photos of the cookies and had somewhat low expectations. The white chocolate really melts in your mouth and it's a nice ratio of chocolate pieces and cookie. Don't be deceived by the size of the cookie as it's very filling. I ended up only eating half of it as dessert with my dinner and the other half the next day. Look forward to my next trip to Atlanta because I will definitely order from this place again.
google avatar

Reco M.

Yelp
The richest cookies and ice cream I've had in Atlanta! Ask for the cookies warmed! I knew it was packed with calories and I didn't care one moment!
google avatar

Maxine D.

Yelp
By far the best cookies in the city! This shop is tiny but has multiple (tiny) locations all over town, and I can see why! I got to meet the eponymous Shane on my first visit and he was lovely to talk to. But the cookies speak for themselves--soft, chewy, and uniquely flavored. Get the filled cookies like the Bulldog and prepare for a sugar coma!
google avatar

Jessica D.

Yelp
I saw Sugar Shane's on social media and had to try them. We got one cookie butter flavor and one cookies and cream. The flavors were amazing, but even though we got them heated up- there was no soft and melty core! Just a hard, well done cookie.....still great tasting but didn't meet the same expectations as their ads and other people's pictures.
google avatar

Ambe C.

Yelp
While everyone else was bringing in the first Monday of the year at the gym, I was at Sugar Shane's enjoying a Cookies and Cream cookie. This was my visit and I really enjoyed it. These aren't your average circular cookies but instead, a form of dropped cookies. The store had the menu of the day in visual form and online. Unfortunately, things got too sweet for me so, I couldn't finish the entire cookie. However, I definitely wanted to!
google avatar

C. G.

Yelp
Though the place is in the cut the smell of the amazing fresh cookies will definitely help you find it! Staff was cool and even went the extra mile to assist because it was my first time there. Cookies are nice sized and fantastic when warmed up. You have a sweet tooth and need it satisfied? Hit up Sugar Shane's!

Jada L.

Yelp
Hiiii!!! Yall were sweet from your Boston guests who got the extra surprise of banana pudding cookie. We'll be back soon! Thank you!!
google avatar

Jordan M.

Yelp
This place really was fantastic! Adding this to the list of places I stop when I come through. I had these two cookies and really thought about making another stop to get some more but didn't have time. The cookies and cream is my favorite. cookies and cream sounds like a regular cookie but the way they make their's is just phenomenal. They are big and delicious. You'll definitely only need one in the night.
google avatar

Erica E.

Yelp
Wow, after beginning so many reviews expressing how I don't truly have a sweet tooth... I'm here to say that I've been all wrong and Sugar Shane's has confirmed so. Man, it sucks to be wrong. I wouldn't really know because it rarely happens but here we are!! This biz started in 2020 at the start of the pandemic, and it's so wonderful to see them continuing to grow! I'm a hungry little woman and I'm not too good for staying my butt at home and ordering my hunger away with only a few taps. So when I found myself craving something sweet months ago and popped onto the delivery app, Sugar Shanes was calling my name. The cookie flavor options blew my mind and then I saw the pictures and I was sold. I think that by now I've tried all available flavors and each one seems to be a creation that is being made with love, talented bakers and some sweet additions into the dough. My personal fave? The huge S'mores cookie! The cookie itself is massive, thique af and filled with a huge marshmallow that just melts into the cookie, omg. They always arrive warm but if I don't eat them right away, reheating is such a breeze and the cookie loses nothing. I also love that there are reheating instructions included on delivery boxes!! Seriously can't wait to have some more cookies!
google avatar

Rachel P.

Yelp
I really hate that I didn't enjoy the cookies because the service really was great, but they were just way too sweet for my taste. I know, they're cookies, they're supposed to be sweet, but both the cookie itself and the filling were incredibly sweet. I was so excited to try it because of all the amazing reviews and exciting options, but I unfortunately don't think I'll be back ): might just be my preference.
google avatar

Nikhil R.

Yelp
If you are looking for a mega sized cookie, that is delicious and almost as big as a slice of cake, this is a place. Sugar Shane's has some of the best cookies I've ever had. The cookies are so large that the center of each cookie can remain a little on the underdone side and super gooey. My personal favorite is their cookies and cream cookie, closely followed by the s'mores cookie. Even though the franchise favorite is the chocolate chip cookies with walnuts, I personally think these other two cookies that I recommended are leagues above this.
google avatar

Nancy C.

Yelp
Cookies came in warm and fresh from a nicely branded box! Opening the sealed box was exciting, and you could smell that these cookies would taste delicious ! Omg the cookies are waaay bigger than I thought, and super yummy, very rich in flavor!! I ate two upon arrival, but these are meant to be slowly savored and enjoyed. Save some for breakfast, lunch and dinner... Cookies are a bit expensive, but basically each cookie is like two-in-one because of their size! Plus, you can tell these are "home-made" and not something out of a machine. That's really wonderful because I want to support local companies. The personalization on the box and QR code are nice touches, and so are the instructions of how long to heat the cookies for later snacking. If there any left after the first 24 hours..
google avatar

Carolina E.

Yelp
I had been wanting something sweet for DAYS and everything in Atlanta closes at 9pm or it appears that way (hint hint to the restaurant I wanted sangria from that closed early). I told my Canadian coworker if I couldn't find a semi decent acai bowl spot I wanted a delicious cookie. I remembered I read about this spot a few months ago when I was in town with my hubby but never had the chance to try.... Low and behold. We hopped into an Uber for a cookie adventure. The driver dropped us off in a back alley and I was very confused. You would never know it's there. It's the definition of hidden in plain sight! It made it that much more fun. The staff was amazing! I wish I would have gotten their names- they were great and helped us pick the best cookies to fill our cookie desires (& those of our family). They convinced us to do the 4 for $20 and I'm so glad we did because Sugar Shane's is too sweet of a place not to share! We also ran into Shane himself on our way out and he was a cool guy and thankful for our business. No complaints and would absolutely recommend to a friend! I'm in ATL regularly for work so I will make sure my coworkers get to try this deliciousness!
google avatar

Ann M.

Yelp
I was drawn to this place because of the variety of cookies but I didn't like the texture. I was expecting soft and gooey but they tasted more like cookie dough. The ordering experience was good and the person who was at the counter was really nice. You should definitely give this place a try, again, the texture thing may of just been an issue for me.
google avatar

Nicole J.

Yelp
I've been wanting to try this cookie spot for a long time and finally did. I wish I had read ahead of time about the parking and where the restaurant was located. It was a little hard to find at first. Once inside, I had to make the hard decision of which cookie to try. I decided on the oatmal chocolate chip. They even warmed it up for me. The cookie was so big and delicious and I can't wait to try more in the future.
google avatar

Tamira M.

Yelp
Satisfy your sweet tooth with Sugar Shane's! I had the pleasure of meeting Shane and tasting his cookies at the Roswell Mimosa Festival. This one man show was in high demand and a crowd pleaser. The friendly customer service by this business owner, Shane, was a plus! The chocolate chip cookie with the sprinkle of sea salt was so good! The chocolate chips were perfectly melted. The only thing missing was a glass of milk to replace my mimosa...lol!
google avatar

Marie B.

Yelp
*BLACK OWNED BUSINESS* Here's the question everyone wants to know, are they better than Crumbl ? YES. The cookies are oddly shaped but I think it's that way because they are stuffed. They come with reheating instructions and take the instructions! They taste waaaaay better when they are warmed up. The cookies are on the pricier side. I was lucky enough to come on a Wednesday when they are 4 for $20. They are literally right behind the subway, down the little hill if you're confused like I was about parking. They do offer online pick up and THEY DO NOT ACCEPT CASH.
google avatar

Ashlynn L.

Yelp
A hidden gem literally! This location is located behind subway and it kind of threw me off a bit but I like the aspect of where it's located. The items they have all vary and no two flavors appear to be the same. The cookies and cream so goey and flavorful and the slutty brownie was definitely a treat, with a mixture of a brownie, cookie, and what appears to be Oreos in the center your mouth will be full of flavor. I love that their boxes include reheating instructions as I waited until I was home to enjoy them. The instructions were clear, straight to the point, and easy to follow. Once I warmed them up using the given instructions I fell in love. The cookie and cream is definitely my favorite! I'll definitely be back to check out more flavors. They also have several locations (midtown, Sandy springs, and probably nice city market) and they offer pickup and delivery options as well! The service is nice and the employees are friendly. Inside isn't that big but it's enough space to go in and get what you need. Definitely a spot worth checking out if you've got a sweet tooth!!
google avatar

Cathy L.

Yelp
I was at Sugar Shane's Friday, 10/13. to get a few more of my 'favorite cookie' I did a Yelp review saying the caramel butterscotch was the best I had ever eaten. There is a large picture of that cookie by the checkout area. I was ready to order 6. But the man working there said they hadn't made that cookie in "months". I nicely went round and round with him, until he agreed that they "possibly could have made them on his day off". (wrong location, wrong date, I was mistaken...). Not good customer service AT ALL. I bought the oreo and the chocolate chip that my daughter wanted but was sorely disappointed that I didn't get 'mine'.
google avatar

Rebecca H.

Yelp
BEST COOKIES EVERRR. dare i say, better than NYC's Levain's?? the s'mores was probably my favorite. sooo yummy

Sarah D.

Yelp
The guys were super nice and explained stuff to us because we were from out of town. Everything was delicious and they made sure our stuff was packed up good because we were using scooters to get around the city. The cookies were delicious and fun options. The entrance was in the back which we almost missed until we saw someone coming out of there.
google avatar

Bree M.

Yelp
I found this place on yelp while having a late night cookie craving. The picture's on yelp definitely matched with the cookies in the store. As an avid cookie connoisseur I would have to rate the warmed up chocolate chip cookie a perfect 10/10. Perfect size, crunch and chewiness and plenty of chocolate chips. Eating that cookie felt like the warmth and excitement you get from your first kiss. The customer service was excellent as the lady was kind enough to give us a yelp discount and a free sample. I took some additional cookies and the reeses brownie home. That brownie was one of the best chocolate peanut butter combinations I've EVER had. Both items I have tried so far remind me of home made but also 5 star chef quality. I will definitely be back here soon! Such a wonderful local business!
google avatar

D. K. C.

Yelp
Allow me to begin by giving you an adjective that describes my state of being "Bliss!" I was recently introduced to Sugar Shane's via a conversation of friends and was excited to give it a try. All of my peers who visited promised me it was worth the trip. As such, you know I had to go! Upon walking in, you are met with the aroma of melting morsels, brown butter, toasted nuts, and sweet memories. The staff greeted us at the door with a warm welcome which added to the comfort of the shop. The cookies were on the table awaiting my arrival which provided an eye-teasing, mouth watering, pick-a-cookie race of sugar driven emotions. LoL! As we began to talk cookies, we were schooled on the art of Shane's by the man himself..... Yes!!! Shane was in the building at the mixer which added to the excitement as we wanted to guess what batch was up next. LoL! Now, you have to go to understand my next statement, but I promise you, trust me when I say... you CAN'T pick just one. With that in mind, my friends and I walked out with a Red Velvet, Cookies & Cream, Banana Pudding, Strawberry Cheesecake, and a Chocolate Chip Salted Walnut Cookie. Oh my goshhhhhhhhhh. Each cookie provides a Mouth pleasing, Flavor enchanting, Body tingling experience. The robust flavors in conjunction with the perfect balance of sweet and gooey make for an overtaking of bite after bite goodness. Furthermore, the fact that Shane put the cookies in the warmer and handed them to us WARM..... Oh myyyyyyyy!!!! The force of cookie power was so enjoyable. HaHa I absolutely recommend stopping by to fulfill your cookie desire. There is something for everyone. Make sure to ask if Shane is in and say Hi to him. He is a Cookie Ghuru! **To note, availability changes throughout the day.
google avatar

Trice V.

Yelp
We were only visiting GA & needed a nighttime snack These cookies were freshly made and delicious, held up very well on UberEats delivery!
google avatar

Christine G.

Yelp
Let's get into it First off finding this place was a struggle I definitely had to ask for help. The monarchy was sooooo tiny below a huge lounge sign and a subway sign. The location is at the bottom of the hill , around the corner and through a garage. See picture ! Parking - its free ! Yay but super limited but again you can't sit down so it shouldn't be super crowded. I was there on a Friday mid day and found a spot. The store is literally the whole kitchen. There is a counter and a clear glass in front of the cookies you order. I love being able to see the whole production actually. They were even making cookies as I was inside. Also they don't accept cash !!! So don't try it but they accept all virtual forms of payment /cards. Cookies: I believe that day they had 8-9 flavors to buy. I only tried the three that interested me. They place them in a box and on top of the box they give you reheating instructions (which are accurate) and freezing instructions if you not as hungry as me. Haha. Cookies and cream : That was great! The outside seem crunchy but the inside was so soft like batter almost which I love a good gooey cookie. It had whole cookie pieces you can taste and wasn't over sweet. As much as an Oreo might give you. I didn't warm this one. Carrot cake : I had this one warm. And oh my word !!!! It didn't taste like carrot but it had the cinnamon, cookie , crunch taste of a carrot cake. I enjoyed it so much I had to take my time ! Favorite!!! Banana Pudding : So crazy thing is I don't like nor eat banana pudding. The lady told me that it didn't have an over powering banana taste and was made with real bananas. So I trusted her. I also had this one warm. Breaking it in half the middle filling started to pour out ! I could taste the cookie which gave a cake taste and I could taste the fresh banana I think I even saw a piece of it inside the cookie. Second favorite. I totally recommend you trying them out. They were on food network desert wars ! And they are delicious. I will be back for more flavors, I'm not sure how often they rotate or change.
google avatar

Tracy H.

Yelp
I'm always in the hunt for a good cookie. These are totally worth it! They look odd and not appealing but the flavors are on point. The peanut butter is my favorite (which I ate before snapping a picture of it...so good)The cookies and cream is phenomenal as well. I love the customer service and friendly staff. The gentleman kindly named all the cookies. Directions are provided on how to heat them. They are delicious heated up in the Airfryer. Definitely a great cookie, not crazy about the location but I'd definitely return.
google avatar

Allison C.

Yelp
Holy moly these are such wonderful cookies! The flavors are excellent and I just love that Sugar Shanes provides reheating instructions. We did exactly what they said by retreating the cookies in the oven and they were absolutely PERFECT. It was a little hard to find this place. It can be easy to miss and you have to enter through the garage. But there is a mini private parking lot next to the garage and just over a small hill on the gravel. Be warned - we went into buy one cookie and came out with 4. You will probably end up doing the same. NO REGRETS.

Jay F.

Yelp
My son (a Tech student) took me here yesterday on the way out of town for the summer, and the Banana Pudding cookie was truly the most incredible dessert I've ever had. You may think that banana pudding and cookies together in one bite might not meld, but I promise, you're wrong. It's the most amazing bite ever! Mike at the front was so friendly, genial, and warm and greeted my son like an old buddy. I'm very thankful there are local places like this around campus that make our kids feel at home.
google avatar

Stephanie G.

Yelp
Watch out Insomnia, I think you have found your match! Was craving something sweet and stumbled across this cookie place so wanted to give it a try. It's an unconventional place because they're in the basement (literally in the back part of a building) but then you are greeted with the smells of sugar and butter when you open the door to their bakery. It was quite an impressive production as people were baking cookies and boxing orders - mind you I came in at 8:30 at night and it seemed like they were busy. We got the Late Night Oreo and Betty White. The inside is super soft while the outside is crunchy. Its not overly sweet either. I did pop them in the air fryer to heat them up and they were delicious. Now I'm super obsessed with this place and can't wait to try their other flavors.

Johnny S.

Yelp
Good deserts price is good kids will love the brownies and cakes good friendly staff and yummy yummy desserts
google avatar

Brandon M.

Yelp
The cookies and especially the banana bread were extremely delicious. I highly recommend following the heat instructions for the cookies as they are much better nice and warm. I loved how thick the banana bread was and the icing was the bomb.
google avatar

Jasmine N.

Yelp
Perfect cookies! Every bite was delightful and service was great. I was surprised at the location and it was hard to find at first but it's inside a garage. Can't wait to go back and try more flavors.
google avatar

Amber M.

Yelp
Let's give Shane a round of applause!! He did his big one with this creation of heaven in a cookie. Omfg every time I took a bite all I could do is sing. Moist Warm Delicious Homemade Amazing customer service I highly recommend sugar Shane's. This is a very good cheat treat !
google avatar

Eryn H.

Yelp
Best cookies ever !!!!!! I love sugar Shane's and I am not even a cookie person. Crumbl cookie don't got nothing on sugar Shane's ! I like their chocolate walnut , banana pudding and birthday cake cookie but I have not had a cookie here I don't like and I've tried all of them.
google avatar

Kiah R.

Yelp
Been here a couple of times, I haven't had a bad cookie/dessert and makes my taste buds holler. It's more than a cookie, it's a heavenly experience!! I can't wait to try more, the cookies they have are what is available, they stay cooking cookies all day everyday but sometimes they will run out of a flavor because people will buy it up *glares* but they will make more but it may not be ready when you arrive. They do deliver, I just haven't done it. When you walk in they let you know what they have available at the time, they've always been friendly. They are cashless so bring a card.