Lu H.
Yelp
This is definitely one of the best omakases I've had - top 3 depending on what you value. The space is intimate - about two tables and the sushi bar, very typical of a traditional sushi bar. The omakase is not cheap ($200/pp), even by NYC standards, but it did "feel" ok with the amount of "courses" (21 in total) and the sushi pieces are just right.
Our experience was as follows, but obviously yours will depend on the freshness and seasonality of the fish (in plain English): halibut, Spanish mackerel, scallop, medium tuna, horse mackerel, baby shrimp, snapper, yellowtail, ocean trout, amberjack, Alaskan salmon roe, snow crab in egg custard, fatty tuna, black cod, sea urchin, sea eel, wagyu beef, tuna hand roll, soup with red snapper, egg, and yuzu sorbet.
Three things stood out to me - the rice (and the pickled ginger for that matter), was noticeably sweeter than every omakase that I've had in Japan or NYC. Less of the rice vinegar acid that cuts through the fish, much more candy like. If I read this review, I'd think that was odd, but it works very well with a lot of the pieces that had a salty component due to either the fish itself or the "topping". Second, a lot more pieces that I have not had (probably due to the season), which made the experience feel "new" such as a version of yellowtail, ocean trout, black cod, and wagyu beef! Lastly, there was quite a bit more torching of fish than I was used to, but wow, those were some of the most memorable pieces I've had. Key standouts: ocean trout (looks like a regular salmon, but with some salt at the top instead of the layering of soy), black cod torched in miso, and the anago (sea eel) that was done without the glaze - the natural sweetness was so good against the salt.
While I can't say with absolute conviction this was my favorite (Nakazawa still holds that spot for me), Zo has a strong argument (my husband thought on an absolute basis, this was the best). I thought the key difference was my preference for a more vinegar tasting rice and a relative price point. I think I can say with confidence, Zo has some of the most memorable individual pieces I've ever had. You must go if you love sushi and willing to splurge!