Steven H.
Yelp
I brought my date here for a Birthday dinner. If I am being honest Ashby Inn was pretty disappointing. After a pretty great time at RDV Vineyards. Ashby was supposed to be the icing on the cake for our evening.
The ambiance of Ashby is beautifully decorated with southern charm. The staff overall was pretty nice and attentive, which is why midway through my lackluster meal I just conceded that instead of sending things back and complaining, I'd just eat what was served and not come back.
My biggest gripe is that I'm tired of pretty Instagram picturesque food, that is flavorless, bland and overambitious. The food was lovely looking, but the flavors told no stories, had no depth and rendered me very underwhelmed. The highlight might've just been the amuse-bouche and bread with honey butter, even that deserved maybe a sprinkle of salt for the butter.
We ordered drinks; mine was the Thyme in the Bottle, my dates' drink I can't quite remember, but she sent it back. Both drinks were overly strong and if I was at a dive bar that would be fine, because my expectations would be lower and who doesn't enjoy boozy drinks. IT tasted like plain liquor and ice. However, super stiff drinks isn't always what customers are after, if I pay $15 for a cocktail(hers was $17) I expect to be blown away, I expect something that strays from the norm.
So let's get to the food:
Bay Scallop Ceviche: I was looking forward to this because blood orange and scallops are usually a match made in heaven. A month ago, I'd had the best Seared Scallops with Cara Cara Oranges in Phoenix and I was hoping this would remind me of that- it didn't. This ceviche was just bland. Not much acid, a lot of sweetness and no real distinct flavor. Everything was muddled and muted.
Georges Mill Tomme Panna Cotta: This was a boring dish. It basically tasted like cottage cheese and nuts.
Bacon Wrapped Monkfish: This was the only dish that was mildly satisfying. The fish was cooked well and it's wrapped in ham. Come to think of it, I've never eaten anything wrapped in ham or bacon I didn't like.
Lamb Loin: Two baby pieces of under-seasoned lamb, actually one piece was seasoned better than the other. It was so little food on the plate, it almost felt like leftovers from a real meal. Beautiful looking plate, however.
Dessert - Cotton Cake w/ Rhubarb: The cotton cake tasted okay, but the rhubarb pieces took away from the finesse of the dish. They were just kind of there. I don't know many people that like big chunks of rhubarb, because they can overwhelm the palette. A more pronounced sauce(there was a sauce), ice cream, etc would have been a better accompaniment to the cake.
To sum it up, the decor and service is pretty good at Ashby. The plating is beautiful, but the flavors are not there. It's like meeting a super attractive person and realizing they have no depth.
Also one of the biggest things that bothered me was that I made reservations and specified it was a birthday. The Ashby Inn literally made no special accommodations or gestures- this could've been as simple as a menu with the birthday person's name printed on it, two flutes of champagne upon arrival, or some special dessert or even comping the dessert we chose. Sadly there was nothing unique or memorable.
Flavor before presentation, please...