Tara C.
Yelp
Pretentious.
As we walked up, two guys were being turned away. They were asked if they had a reservation, they said no and were turned away by the guy working the "magic red rope". We walked up just as they were leaving - we were also asked if we had reservations - we didn't. The guy working the door said, "just two"? That we were... the bouncer checked our ID's and off we went down the stairs. We walked into a nice but average looking space with a bar to the right and small, 2-seater tables to the left. In the back, there is a small room with a handful more tables, some a little larger. If they let you in without a reservation, you will be standing. Even if there are empty tables.
Next up, the drinks. Overpriced for average crafted cocktails. We ordered a New York Sour which was pretty good, but absolutely not worth a $23 price tag. We also ordered a Negroni Bianco. I'm still trying to figure out what ingredients the bartender used. One thing I can say is, there's absolutely no chance he used the correct ingredients for this cocktail, or ingredients that even go into a cocktail. So bad, between two of us, we drank about 1/3rd of the cocktail and left. The cocktail at the least, should have been drinkable - it was not. With that, trust your gut (and mine) - go to Bar Pisellino if you want a Negroni Bianco.
The Mulberry is trying extra hard, but it's not going very far. They can't even pass it off that you're paying for the view. There are no windows - you're in a basement.