The Best Sandwich Shop

Good portions and tasty food. Pricey beers compared to other places we went in Atlanta. Chocolate chip cookie was a little hard but tasty. Couldn’t break off without using a knife.

This day, I wanted a sandwich so bad, so I stopped by this establishment. I was greeted when I walked through the door. There was only 1 person dining in. I stood looking at the menu for a while, and the guy at the register and another guy standing next to him just sat there waiting. I guess I was expecting a little more customer service. Have you been here before? What do you have a taste for? Nope, none of that! I ordered the Sunset Blvd, and it left more to be desired. It had no flavor, it was just Blah, very bland! The best thing it had going was the bacon! The sesame seed roll should be an option because WHY! The $3 pickle was TERRIBLE, extremely sweet and vinegary (that might not be a word but you get the point). It was 12:30 in the afternoon and claimed they just ran out of potato chips! $17 lunch that I regretted. I ate half the sandwich and took everything else home for my husband to try. We mutually agreed on the bland sandwich and the disgusting pickle. Sorry I won't be back!

OMG!!! I got the hatch chile burger and it was AMAZING! Absolutely top 5 burgers... now I forgot to grab ketchup... that would have made it even better. But it wasn't heavy in my stomach... it was super flavorful and delicious.

This place is my top pick for best “Northeast Sub Shop” in Atlanta. Their unofficial chicken parm is packed full of chicken, sauce, and cheese and paired with the sesame seed roll is chef’s kiss. The Best Sandwich Shop also does “Philly Style” subs really well too, but be wary that once they sell out of meats for them during the day, they’re 86’d until the next day.

Came here for a quick bite before heading to Trader Joe’s as it’s been on my list to check out for a while but was not impressed at all. I had the hot beef brisket Philly “All the way”. The bread was good, felt freshly made but the brisket was as bland as can be. There was no seasoning to it, it was missing a simple ingredient like salt. The oregano mayo was subtle, the banana peppers is what made this sandwich. I felt like they sprinkled on some cheese just to say it’s Philly Style. I’d be lying if I said I’d be back to try another sandwich only because for $20 you would think, you’re getting what you paid for.

The Best Sandwich Shop lives up to its name, offering a wide range of delicious, fresh sandwich options at good prices. Everyone I’ve taken loves the chicken schnitzel and the meatball sub, both of which are fantastic. I noticed this weekend that Chef Shaun Doty has combined the two in a must-eat chicken parm sub. I have a secret soft spot for the Manna - it’s like a combo of a cheesesteak & a cheeseburger, and the one I frequently return to. Overall a great addition to the Ponce corridor, and a dramatic improvement over the old Moe’s.

Meh…. I was expecting a fantastic sandwich based on their name and was disappointed. The chicken tasted off and lacked any interesting flavor. The vibe of the place was lacking as well. Service was just average. I've had a way better sandwich for $20. I will try and find a homeless person to give this untouched half of a sandwich, too.

Hip spot with good service. I would call it the best sandwich shop in Atlanta but that’s already their name so it’s a bit redundant. I will say this, I had the Italian Pork sub All The Way and it was incredibly flavorful and fresh. It was not cheap but that is to be expected since the quality of ingredients. This ain’t subway and don’t come here if you want low price. If you want quality subs with unique flavors, go check out The Best Sandwich Shop.

I really enjoy this sandwich shop, the sandwiches are smaller than expected for the price however, they are mostly packed full of flavor. I say mostly because my last visit the schnitzel sandwich was dry and the first time I had it it was not dry at all. The service has always been great when I go. My largest gripe are the hours, they need to be open longer especially on the weekends.

Our friend took us to The Best Sandwich Shop while visiting her, and it was such a great place for lunch! We did take out and brought the food home, and it was so delicious! Pictured here is the Schnitzelbrotchen sandwich & the Cajun crinkle cut fries. The sandwich is so light but will fill you up just enough, the cutlet combined with the lemon vinaigrette and arugula & parmesan really is the perfect combination. The fries are so great too. Would definitely come back!!

No nonsense sandwich place ! Just ordered two egg sandwiches to go . Simple but delicious . They were quick and nice in their service Also a nice place to go for breakfast . They have enough seating space

Great NY Deli style subs! I was looking for a spot in ATL with a chicken cutlet sandwich and the Schnitzelbrötchen was just what I was looking for. I do wish the menu was a bit larger (about 5 options). The restaurant itself is a little strange - my group got our sandwiches and sat outside on the patio but was told later by a waiter we could only sit outside if we were eating brunch. A bit confusing but good food nonetheless.

Bread is not good - tastes like an old, store bought thick hamburger bun. Turkey and cheddar tasted like they came out of a package from a grocery store. Subs were missing ingredients that I ordered. Super disappointing.

Quite disappointed. I got the schnitzel chicken. Sandwich said it would b hot sandwich and it was barely warm bread was cold and not toasted the chicken. Was warm and dry. We also got the sunset Blvd sandwich which was like a turkey club the bread was too much and a lot of sprouts which outweighed any of the other ingredients. There were NO sides available and It was 1;00 on a Monday with only 3 ppl in the shop. So two sandwiches and 2 drink for $33 was definitely NOT worth it!!

On the upside, it's a good space, in a good location, and the staff are friendly and chill. Apart from that, when we ordered they were out of many items (e.g. French fries) but weren't sure which ones. Our server made a lot of trips back to the table letting us know what we ordered wasn't available, or no wait it was available on trip 3, trip 4 back to the table asked if we did in fact want the thing they were initially out of but turns out they weren't out of it, but they didn't place the order for either because they weren't sure. Of the 11 table tops that were seated when we ordered none of them had food, it felt like something was going on. The sandwiches were bland and missing ingredients that were listed on the menu. Hot food was burned but you had to chase someone down for silverware before you could find that out. Contrary to the signs outside this place is neither memorable as the best or the worst, but it is entirely forgettable in an area with many more worthy options.

I noticed the sign outside saying Espresso Bar, so I decided to get a quick double. It was in the afternoon and relatively quiet inside. I went up to the counter and ordered my coffee, and I got one of the best eye rolls ever in response. I felt compelled to ask if this was a problem? The young man just shook his head and made my espresso. The double shot was actually pretty good. Too bad the employee felt so put out by having to do his job.

Absolutely delicious! This place knows what they're doing!!! The sunset blvd was also 10/10

This place has potential but it really hasn't come together yet. It's drawing crowds but getting your order to your table in a reasonable amount of time and, as you ordered it, proves a challenge. Also, the menu promises an intensity of flavor that just isn't there. How does the German and beer-adjacent sandwich shop serve overdone schnitzel? More and better trained staff would go a long way to improving it. Thoroughly enjoyed my cucumber salad...would like to try the Ukrainian beet salad. I'll give it another go in a few months...

Lirry, black girl with brown blonde hair says We close in 5 mins so..." this should be a training video about how NOT to treat customers. So rude & unfriendly. I drove so far & was excited to finially catch this place, & she ruined the experience. I told her it was my first time you would think she would explain how things work & be friendly shessh. It was just very stand offish, & you think I should provide a tip. She must not enjoy what she does. Hopefully the sandwich makes up for her rude a attitude.

This place should be much better than it is... in fact there should be no place better. And I really really wanted to like it because I like the signage and the general look of the place: it looks like a bougier version of a Italian sandwich place I might find in South Philly. They have the looks down, but there are some critical things off about the sandwiches themselves. First, the bread is wrong. Yes, it has sesame seeds like Sarcone's bread, which is great, but it's way too soft. It needs to be crustier and have some a bite to it. Second, the two sandwiches I've had range considerably in quality. I've had the Italian several times, and it's pretty good - the meats are nice and the pecorino is great - but the lemony arugula strikes me as odd: on an Italian I want acidity to come from red wine vinegar, not... lemon. Also some olive oil and/or oregano would be a nice touch. I've also had the Philly. This sandwich was flat-out B A D. Like inedible. The brisket was oddly cut (cubes? Why not thin slices?) and it was actually tough. Can't remember the last time I had a tough brisket. I fed most of the brisket to my dog who at least enjoyed it. Not only that, but the sandwich was bland... the meat was under seasoned, and there was no sauce or marinade or juice to liven it up. The only thing providing some flavor were the optional banana peppers I added. I get what inspired this: a Philly roast pork sandwich. But those things are juicy and savory as f*ck and this completely pales in comparison. I would like to recognize that delivery is pretty fast, and they've honored my substitution requests, which I really appreciate. I think these guys can do better, and I would be more than happy to update this review if they do. Until then the name is just a cutesy irony.

The place sucks 3 fold: 1-it says out front that it's an espresso bar. No menu was given to us for coffee, and when we asked our server if they had coffee he said he'd "check." When we finally got a latte it was cold. 2-service is bad and terribly slow. Servers don't know anything about the menu and don't offer any information to you. 3-ordered what seemed like their premier sandwich, the "Lebeau,." A cold tuna sub with veggies and sauces. Pretty straightforward. It came out 20 minutes after ordering, tuna was extremely dry, sandwich had little flavor. $16.50 - crazy. If you want less than mediocre food served to you late in an un-air conditioned garage, come here.

The food is not worth the price. I paid $15 for The Enzo. It's like a few lil slices of meat, no cheese, oil and vinegar, arugula, and average bread. No tomato, onion, pepper, nothing. I can't believe folks are rating it so highly. One could EASILY get a better and more filling sandwich from Jimmy John's or any given corner store. I'm guessing the name is leading people to think it's better than it is. It's incredibly mid and that's not a bad thing, just don't be charging premium prices.

I've had two hoagies so far and I keep coming back. The roll is awesome with lots of sesame seeds. Hoagie one - pork and broccoli rabe. I did it very plain to check out the flavors but they have a bevy of pickled toppings to spice it up. Hoagie two - chicken parm. It's on special but the bartender at the Wurst told me it's so popular it may become a mainstay. It was excellent. I scarfed it down, great sauce, not crazy with the cheese. My only wish is that they'd swap out one of the German style sides (which don't really go) with pasta salad. Beyond that... I keep coming back.

I had seen the Farmer's Daughter sandwich on the menu when I went to The Wurst next door, so I HAD to go back and try it!! After all, it is made with halloumi cheese!! It did not disappoint!! I will be back. Also two lovely patios to enjoy it on.

After a long day of walking around the sites we stopped by for lunch. My husband got the Best of the Wurst and I got Sunset Blvd. The sandwiches were great and the place was crowded even till the last minutes they were open.

Lame. They close at 3:00, but showed up at 2:00pm and cannot dine in. It's not going to take me an hour to eat a sandwich. If that's the case, put the sign on the door and say that dining in is not allowed after a certain time.

Sandwich was phenomenal and I loved it! Honestly one of the best sandwiches. Staff was very nice and I 100% will be back.

Had the Manna sub....so gooood. Sunset Blvd is next up in my to try list. So glad to have a fantastic sandwich shop in the neighborhood.

I got the distinct opportunity to try this place. And it was awesome. I had a meatball sub made by Chef Doty himself. It was so flavorful. The meatballs were perfect, the marinara sauce full of flavor and the bread so tasty. But...the fresh, thick slices of mozzarella really made this an outstanding sandwich. Can't wait to come back and try other items. But then again, you had me at meatball sub!

Came with hubs. I got the schnitzelbrotchen and some matzo ball soup. He got the immortal. Very sweet cashier named terry. Small place but delicious!

Ordered thru Uber eats. I don't live far so my food was still hot and fresh. Bread was a little on the dry side, but the ingredients are fresh and the sandwich was made with pride. I appreciate things like that. I got the chicken (forgot the name) sandwich and it was cooked perfectly. It was kind of salty and I would've loved a little more Mayo but it was still pretty good. Now that I think of it, I think that's what it was missing...more Mayo or some kind of sauce to balance the chickens saltiness. It had a nice lemon flavor and overall I will come back again. I also had the beet salad which was delicious. I love beets and I was excited to see this on the menu. It had beans in it and tasted sweet and sour, just how I like it. I think this place is going to do well and if they were open later it would be my after work spot to beat the traffic.

Yelp, please give us the option to give no stars. Some places just don't cut it. I wanted to try this place out after discovering it. First of all, I am from South Jersey across the bridge from Philadelphia. By no means am I the end all be all on sandwiches, but I do know that bread is your foundation. The pictures made this bread look like a crusty, seeded bread ready to hold up to moist beef. Nothing could be further from the truth. Bread is pretty pedestrian at best. I got the beef thinking I would get cheesesteak beef (we don't call it a Philly) or Italian beef. It was brisket, bland, unseasoned brisket with unseasoned brocolli rabe and provolone. Artisinal sandwiches are the rage down here. So I paid 15.00 for a mini sandwich. I ate half, but I couldn't even get the 2nd half down. How hard is it to grab a salt shaker and shake it or to Sautee the rabe in garlic and olive oil. A good rabe sandwich has the clean bite of the bitter the rabe brings to it. I was between the beef and pork. I wonder if the pork sandwhich is a pork chop chopped up?

Good sandwiches, albeit on the smaller side. Very cramped space inside, but food was ready when I arrived. Sandwiches were delicious!

Just had a very nice breakfast sandwich & coffee there. Egg & cheese & bratwurst on good sesame-seed bread. Priced reasonably and in a good spot on Ponce. It's a new place and I do hope it lasts. I'll definitely be back for sandwiches.

Quality is high. Cost is really quite high, considering. The location is good if you live nearby. Has nice outdoor seating as well.

Chef Shaun Doty who created Bantam & Biddy has opened this very small 4 table sandwich cafe on Ponce De Leon near the end of Virginia Highlands. The adjoining restaurant is the Wurst Beer Hall. The specially subs are great and huge. Order at the counter and they call your name. Brisket sub was excellent. Their are somne outdoor tables. Light breakfast and coffees are available.

Ordered the brisket philly, and they forgot to put cheese on it. Meat was dry and bland. Also had the Best of the Wurst. The amount of peppers and onions was absurdly small, but the sausage itself was very good. Not worth the price.

This was my first time visiting TBSS and it was a pleasant experience. Customer service was great and I waited no more than 5 minutes for my order to be completed. The ingredients were fresh. I got the Sunset Blvd (ingredients listed in caption of the video) & my main complaint is that I didn't really taste the tarragon Mayo, which most likely contributed to the sandwich being a bit dry. Would definitely request extra mayo next time because i was looking forward to the flavor combination. I'll be back to try again/other sandwiches, but probably wouldn't be my go to sandwich spot. We'll see if the next visit changes my mind!

Very friendly staff and amazing sandwiches! They live up to their name with their fresh ingredients and authentic flavor.

Awesome food, absolutely love the chicken schnitzel sandwich. Quick and friendly service!

Great shop! Friendly staff and delicious food! As soon as I took my first bite I already was looking forward to my next visit!

I have been living in ATL 5 years from NYC, and honestly never thought I would see the day that someone in this city can actually make a chicken cutlet sandwich so close to how I know it to be. While it is small and takes a while when busy, they hit the nail on the head in terms of making a chicken cutlet correctly (breading actually sticks to the chicken, perfectly fried). The veggies are thinly sliced so it all comes together in a gastronomical euphoria of sorts. Now, if I am going to be petty, it is not huge but not tiny either and the roll is a little soft, but have no fear if you're craving the real thing.

Amazing classic NYC style deli breakfast sandwiches + coffee - can't beat the prices, friendly staff, and quick service. Just don't be late- breakfast service stops at 10:30 SHARP

This place lives up to it's name! All of our sandwiches were excellent and Jason brought such positive energy and was so accommodating with a few special requests that I proposed to him! Lol Try this place stat! Italian beef is the bomb!

I bought the schnitzel sandwich and it was extra crispy on the outside, the chicken was juicy, and the bread was toasted and had a good bounce, and the sauce and greens were complimentary to the rest of the ingredients. Will definitely come back and try out more of their food, including their sides.

The best sandwich shop! Vegetarian options for sandwich's! Fresh OJ! Delicious coffee! Local small business! Haven't checked out the beer hall yet, but it seems cool.

This place left a lot to be desired, especially considering the name, I had high expectations

This town needed a good sandwich shop. Sandwich's are reasonably priced for their size and delicious. I tried the Philly and schnitzel. Both were amazing and left me with a second meal for later. I'm going back soon to try more.

Had lunch with two other people this week. We were each hesitant to say but we all thought our sandwiches were bland and not finessed. I had the brisket sandwich and the meat was in large chewy chunks, too large for one bite so I was literally taking chunks off the bread for a second bite. Others had the Manna ground beef and the Schnitzel chicken subs. None of us took our other half of sandwich home. There are many places in the area that make excellent sandwiches so I will not return, sorry.

I have never had a better restaurant experience than the one this restaurant provided today. I ordered catering Sunday night to pick up on Monday morning and they were extremely flexible to work with. Upon entering the shop, are greeted to a very welcoming environment. They have some of their peppers and other ingredients shelved on cases for sell and it has a very small town feel in a great location. I was greeted by the owner and the kindest staff ever. They had all of the food ready even though I was ten minutes early, and it was an a plethora of food. I have ordered catering for the same place at other shops before, but none of them even compare to the quality and quantity of food provided. When the owner learned that I had walked to the shop (it was a very short walk), he insisted on helping me back to where the event was held because there was too much food for me to hold. Once on location where we were all able to try some of the sandwiches, every single person was left more than satisfied. I'm short, this truly is the BEST sandwich shop!

Was excited to have a few sandwiches from best sandwiches especially after Kevin said it was great. My opinion is quality is great with the Enzo and the sniztzel but what falls short and makes the sandwiches just OK is the bread. Horrible choice. Correct the bread and you have somthing here if not it may be ok for Atlanta but doesn't hold a candle to chicago and New York shops. And forget about Italy it's not in that realm. The bread needs to be crispier like a French and soft in the middle.

Such a welcome addition to the neighborhood - finally a place to get a serious sandwich. The bread is great abd the fillings are even better. You can't go wrong with any of the choices, but the chicken schnitzel, the meatball, and the Manna, are particular standouts. Chef Shaun Doty even combined the first two into a chicken parm sub special recently that made me question why all sandwiches are not this delicious. Sandwich existential crisis warning.

Best sandwich shop is a relaxed, no frills, delicious sandwich shop focused on subs (hot, cold, Philly). They also have breakfast sandwiches that come on their classic sesame seed sub rolls, which are great and affordable. I got a bacon, egg & cheese breakfast sandwich and a large latte (very good) for ~$10. This place is slowly becoming a go-to weekend spot for me due to the location and quality for the price. Further, the Shop is connected to the Wurst Beer Hall, which hasn't yet opened as of the date of this post, but would be a lovely place to come watch a game inside at the beer bar or just to hang on the front or back patio and chill with a pint. Very excited to go back!

it's just okay. i was really excited for this place but it is just okay. i only tried to the schnitzel and the chicken parm so maybe i would enjoy their cold sandwiches more, but there was just a lack of flavor in them. it tasted fine, but i would not say the best

Came here for the first time, and the staff was not very friendly or informative...if someone is new wouldn't you want to help or explain something to them to get them to come back? While I was ordering I felt rushed. A lot of the menu items were not available, so I ended up building my own. Also, don't claim that you are the best sandwich shop if you only have one kind of bread. They also have no sides, which I get it's about the sandwiches - but come on, make it more interesting at least have something unique. I was surprised by the lack of variety, they have like three different spreads that are basic and nothing special. I'd rather go to Subway or Publix and spend a lot less money on a better quality sandwich, with more options. Turkey was not good and bland as was the rest of everything on my sandwich I couldn't even eat the whole thing. If you are going to keep the menu simple, do it right. The fact that I'm saying that I'd rather go to Subway speaks volume because I don't even like Subway. Will be sticking to Publix (or literally any other place) until further notice.

This place is super super super good!! I got the sunset Blv and my boyfriend got the chicken parm sandwich. SO SO GOOD HIGHLY RECOMMEND!