Daniel P.
Yelp
I moved to the Cairns shortly after starting work at Amazon. I stayed for about a year and a half, and I recently moved out for a variety of reasons. Having read the reviews on Yelp and discussing the move out process with a friend who moved out a few months prior, I was unfortunately prepared for a stressful experience trying to get deposits back.
Here are some of my experiences:
1. The apartment was nice enough. Expensive rent, cheap finish, building starting to feel dated, but lots of space and storage with a decent view. The storage really didn't make a lot of sense, as the cabinets in the kitchen weren't placed where they could be used for cooking very easily. The walk-in closet cut off a lot of living space in an already awkwardly shaped bedroom. The appliances were as cheap as you can get while still looking decent and performed fine, though the fridge didn't have a good seal, so it was constantly making noise trying to seal the door. There's a nice deck on top with a good view in all directions and a grill. They recently re-did the deck, so it is probably even nicer now.
2. The location seems great and was the initial draw, but there is really nothing interesting nearby, so the area feels very isolating. The closest groceries are at Whole Foods, which is almost 3/4 mile walk away - not great with a couple bags of groceries. Nobody makes South Lake Union a destination, and there are no good bus stops near the building, so I spent a lot of money on cabs/cars. The nearby park also seems appealing, until you realize that it is currently a camp for a host of local homeless and there are perpetually people shooting up in the public bathroom - not a great place for kids/dogs to play. Car2Go vehicles are almost never available, since the Amazon employees start leaving with them at 4:30, going to Ballard, Fremont, Capitol Hill, and other outlying neighborhoods. There are 3 Zipcars in the neighboring building, which is handy. There should also be a lot of new restaurants in the area after the new buildings are built out, but that looks to be at least a couple years out.
3. Management changed frequently. Currently, the building is on its third manager in the 18 months that I lived there. The feeling I got interacting with management and its policies is that it is very corporate and driven by short-term views of numbers and maximizing short-term margins rather than personal relationships to encourage long-term leases. Every time the lease was renewed, exorbitant rent increases were demanded, even though much newer buildings had recently been built all around the Cairns. Month-to-month options were as much as a $400 increase. It was a struggle each time my lease was renewed to stay at something close to what I'd been paying. Given the explosion of housing opportunities in the area, this seemed short-sighted on their part, and it was needlessly stressful, since I was able to negotiate to a fairly constant rent rate by threatening to move.
4. Their automatic payment system failed to make my payments twice when my lease renewed and when I gave notice. I was immediately presented with a notice to vacate and late fees both times. Having consistently made automatic payments for 6-18 months, I would have preferred a more personal touch than a notice to vacate letter stuffed in my door and then having to argue to get the late fees reversed.
5. On moveout, they charged me to replace the carpet, charged me for professional cleaning, and quoted deposits totaling $125 less than what I actually paid in deposits. In an e-mail from them before they had inspected the apartment, "Since you have a dog, mostly likely we will need to replace the carpet and pet seal." I paid a $250 fee up front for the dog, $15/month, and a $250 pet deposit. According to WA state law, security deposits cannot be used to repair normal wear and tear. The carpet was in good condition when I moved out, visibly clean with no odors - in my assessment had only normal wear and tear. They pulled the carpet off the floor and claimed that spills which I had cleaned were dog urine from my middle-aged, very house-trained dog. I notified them that I had my own professional cleaning service clean the apartment before the end of my lease, which is not a requirement under the lease or WA state law. I paid $750 in security deposits, but they are claiming I only paid $625. If they are replacing the carpet after every person moves out of an apartment, and they would like tenants to pay for it, they need to charge this as an up front fee. I found at least one poster on Yelp had a similar experience losing their deposit and I talked with a very responsible friend who recently moved out who also lost most of his deposit. I paid plenty to live in this apartment building, I took care of the apartment, and I left it in good condition with only 'normal wear and tear'.
I was not able to get my deposit back after much wrangling. Disappointed with the management group.