The Cookie Odyssey

Bakery · Financial District

The Cookie Odyssey

Bakery · Financial District

35 Cedar St, New York, NY 10005

Highlights

Bakery offering delicious chocolate chip & banana cookies

35 Cedar St, New York, NY 10005 Get directions

cookieodyssey1978.com

@thecookieodyssey

$1–10

@infatuation

NYC’s New Restaurant Openings - New York - The Infatuation

"This Upper East Side bakery is from the Pi Bakerie people, who also have a Cookie Odyssey kiosk outside Pi's Financial District location. The cookies appear to be thick and soft enough for you to use as a pillow if you have a very small head. They’re $25 for a half-dozen, in flavors like Pecan Pie (self-explanatory) and Banana Cyclops." - will hartman, willa moore, molly fitzpatrick, sonal shah, bryan kim

https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/guides/new-nyc-restaurants-openings

View Postcard for The Cookie Odyssey

@davidcho

Maybe the best cookie in New York

Things I want to eat in New York

View Postcard for The Cookie Odyssey

Londoner

Google

It's one of the best cookies I've ever eaten. I suggest you get the small ones so you can try more flavours. 5 out of 6 flavours were awesome. The only one that it was just ok was the pecan pie. And it's only just $1.80 each. I highly recommend this place

Bonnie Gleicher

Google

at banana-chocolate cookie! Totally agree with previous reviews. So delicious, like a rich cup of banana pudding, gooey, delicious. Really liked the pecan cookie and the chocolate-chip cookie. The rest (the ginger, yuzu, white-chocolate dark chocolate) were four stars. Coming back for that banana cookie. 5 stars!!!!

Lisa Williams

Google

I love to bake, so every time I hear about a good chocolate chip cookie, I want to try it. Cookie Odyssey is a small kiosk with a pretty darn good chocolate chunk cookie. The flavor is good and, if you like a cookie that is 75% chocolate... you'll love this. My personal preference is a cookie with a little more cookie, so I found it a little rich but delicious nonetheless.

Cilka

Google

I’m a cookie connoisseur and try to visit all the main cookie places and this one was awesome! It’s right up there with Funny Face as the best cookie in the city. The banana chocolate chip is unique and outstanding in particular. Get the big cookies because the smaller ones just don’t have the same delicious texture and gooey center.

B E

Google

Absolutely yum cookies here! Affordable and gooey yummy. I love that they have only a few and the same flavors in the big and small. The texture changes with the size and both are delicious. Definitely try these cookies! They’re located in the little hut outside of the main cafe.

Wilson Tsang

Google

TLDR: we got one of each of the mini cookies for about $9 and they didn’t disappoint All five flavors were pretty good, but my favorite was the house chocolate chip and the banana cyclops (which has a very soft piece of banana in it). I liked the mini cookies so that we could try all the flavors. The cookies themselves were crispy on the outside but soft on the inside

Namkwann (NK)

Google

This cookie store offers special flavors. All recipes are carefully crafted to bring out their own unique flavor. The menu stands out from most other places. Even though there may be limited varieties of cookies available, I can guarantee you that whoever tries them will truly enjoy them! 🍪 😋 💕

Lauren Silverstein

Google

Such a cute little cookie shop nestled in FiDi. One of the best cookies I’ve tried in the city! Definitely try the banana chocolate chip one