The Cookie Odyssey

I’m a cookie connoisseur and try to visit all the main cookie places and this one was awesome! It’s right up there with Funny Face as the best cookie in the city. The banana chocolate chip is unique and outstanding in particular. Get the big cookies because the smaller ones just don’t have the same delicious texture and gooey center.

Absolutely yum cookies here! Affordable and gooey yummy. I love that they have only a few and the same flavors in the big and small. The texture changes with the size and both are delicious. Definitely try these cookies! They’re located in the little hut outside of the main cafe.

This cookie store offers special flavors. All recipes are carefully crafted to bring out their own unique flavor. The menu stands out from most other places. Even though there may be limited varieties of cookies available, I can guarantee you that whoever tries them will truly enjoy them! 🍪 😋 💕

TLDR: we got one of each of the mini cookies for about $9 and they didn’t disappoint All five flavors were pretty good, but my favorite was the house chocolate chip and the banana cyclops (which has a very soft piece of banana in it). I liked the mini cookies so that we could try all the flavors. The cookies themselves were crispy on the outside but soft on the inside

I have to say this is one of the most amazing cookies I have ever had in my life! I love banana anything and I stopped by one day to try their small cookie. I also tried the chocolate chip. They were soft yet crunchy on the outside. Needless to say in the last week I have been there 3 times. Owner is super sweet and she gave me a hug when I stopped in today. Even though I'm moving to Brooklyn today, I will definitely come back and get these from time to time.

Lovely little gem! Me and my cousin visited twice and were served by Costa (apologies for spelling) both times. Delicious cookies and excellent service by this kind man! Thank you.

Cookie Odyssey was part of my NYC cookie tasting quest. This place tied for first out of five places that I tried. The tied cookie establishments make a different style, so it was hard to rank one over the other. This place is a perfect blend of flavors and textures. I highly recommend!!

These cookies are heavenly! Everything you would want in a bite - fresh, top ingredients, chewy on the inside but crunchy on the outside, and in mini and regular sizes. (You can try all flavors with the minis!) The service is warm and hospitable.