Daniel B.
Yelp
The Halal Guys opened their second Atlanta area location in Midtown in November 2018 and I'm definitely a fan. The food here is delicious, filling, affordable, and served up quick.
The restaurant is located street level in the Modera Midtown apartment building (same building as Japanese restaurant Momonoki and Momo Cafe). You get 2 hours free parking in the Modera deck with validation from Halal Guys (ask at the register). The entrance to Modera's deck is just to the left of The Halal Guys' storefront. Metered street parking is also available. Use the Parkmobile app to pay for, monitor, and add time to your meter if needed. Zone 51554. Street parking is free on Sunday.
This is a fast-casual restaurant chain where you stand in line and servers behind the counter prepare your order, on the fly, in assembly line fashion (like Chipotle). The restaurant is new and clean with an open kitchen, self-serve drinks (both fountain and canned/bottled), and a small variety of table and counter seating. It's a small place. The inside can seat maybe about 20 customers while the uncovered sidewalk patio outside seats about 12. There are two keypad-locked unisex restrooms.
The menu is simple. You can get a sandwich ($6.99) or platter (small $7.99, regular/large $8.99) filled with the following: chicken, beef gyro, combo (chicken and beef gyro), or falafel. Sandwiches come wrapped in pita with lettuce, tomato, and sauce. Platters come with orange rice, lettuce, tomato, pita triangles, and sauce. Their sauces include their popular "white sauce" (a server told me it's mayo with herbs), hot sauce (it's legit spicy), and barbecue sauce (it's good). Sides and desserts include hummus, baba ghanoush, and fries ($2.99 each), falafel (2 for $1), and baklava ($1.99).
I really like both the sandwiches and the platters. I think the sandwiches are a bit tastier than the platters because you get to eat that warm, fluffy, and soft pita wrap; however, the sandwiches can be messy to eat and the platters come with more food. I'm not a huge fan of the pita triangles that come with the platters because they're thin and relatively hard. The pita that comes with the sandwich is where it's at.
I prefer the beef gyro over the chicken, but the chicken is fine too. To me, the beef gyro is almost lip-smacking good. It's got a nice, tender consistency (so does the chicken) and an almost addictive savory flavor. If you get a sandwich, I think beef gyro is the way to go and if you get a platter, you should get the combo (beef gyro and chicken).
The white sauce is a must and, if you spicy food, the hot sauce too. The Halal Guys' hot sauce is concentrated so if you've never had it before, you might want to start small. I like to get 2 or 3 lines of hot sauce in my sandwich or platter. Their barbecue sauce is actually pretty good too. It's smoky and strongly flavored. You can always ask for sauces on the side.
The falafel are yummy. They're delectably crispy on the outside and warm and comforting on the inside. At 2 for $1, they're a good cheap side to get.
Service I've experienced has been great. The staff has been polite, attentive, and quick. When dining in, servers will come by with squeeze bottles of sauce if you want more sauce. This place works well both for dine-in and takeout.
At the time of writing this review, if you check into Halal Guys on Yelp, you get 20% off your order.
The Halal Guys' first Georgia location opened in January 2017 on Buford Highway (https://www.yelp.com/biz/the-halal-guys-chamblee-4). More metro Atlanta locations are in the works and they'll probably be open by the time you read this.