Jim R.
Yelp
UPDATE: Added a star back. I contacted Xanterra through the Oasis at Death Valley website's contact link, and a manager got back to me promptly (I had previously contacted them only by phone who required me to contact them through Hotels.com). He apologized and gave me a full refund promptly. Definitely much better, no excuse-making or buck-passing. So if you were in the same boat, I encourage you to use the "contact us" link on their website.
--
The location is great, the grounds are nice, the rooms are probably comfortable. This was supposed to be our splurge night, with a reservation at the fanciest restaurant they have.
But Xanterra, the concessionaire who runs this place, is a disaster. Soviet style top down management, nobody knows anything and nobody can help you when things go wrong.
We arrived just after dark, and the place was pitch black. Nobody was outside to greet us, and there's no signage to show you what to do, just the blank wall of the building. Hint: go up the ramp that says "passenger vehicles only" which gets you to the front door. Which still had no people, lighting or signage. Because there was a blackout. Apparently this happens several times per year, but it means that there's no light, heat, no hot water, no food in the restaurant and they sent most of their employees home. They gave us the option to check in, or cancel, no promises on compensation. They believed there would be compensation, but even in day 3 of the outage, they still hadn't heard from management.
We got a few free glow sticks and a fairly hostile reception once we found the single harried employee. It was basically "take it or leave it, your restaurant reservation is cancelled and we can go buy $20 burgers at the other hotel (with an hour long wait).
The next morning, the somewhat friendlier guy at the desk told me there would be compensation, but he wasn't authorized to tell me what it would be, I'd have to go through Hotels.com since I booked through them. I've since tried to go through hotels.com, and they have informed me that the hotel told them there would be no compensation of any kind. There was no management onsite, and the management had not been in contact for 3 days of the outage, and the policies did not allow the employees to do anything to help.
So in short, for $350 we got to camp indoors, and there's no compensation or even an apology. This apparently happens frequently, and they were unprepared and uncommunicative. There aren't a lot of alternatives in the park -- Furnace Creek is really where you want to stay -- but don't expect five star service when things go wrong, which they apparently do frequently. And maybe bring a camping lantern and some towelettes to clean yourself up if you don't like cold showers -- we were very happy we had our camping gear with us. Glow sticks just don't cut it.
I would be deeply ashamed if I was the manager of this hotel. I'd be deeply ashamed if I was the boss of the manager of this hotel and he or she still works there.