The Montauk Beach House

I stayed there in September – great room, super friendly service, very generous in every way, and they provided a bike (had a wonderful ride with little traffic, and they even promised me winter service for the bike). Plus, it's truly only 250 yards from the beach, which is simply stunning. So, the hotel – beautifully done, excellent service, and the perfect location!

I’ve been coming to Montauk for years but had never stayed here, and I’ve been missing out! The staff is so lovely - anyone we interacted with was friendly. Having the cafe and bar right on site is very convenient too. Drinks were great. Pool party was fun. Only thing I’d say is if you don’t want to a party scene this may not be the place for you, as they host pool parties and it can get crowded. I personally loved that aspect! Rooms were spacious and nice as well. Can’t wait to come back!

The room we had had practically no patio to hang out. It was way too small of a patio. Additionally, I think it’s absurd that you charge that amount of money for a room and we can’t bring our drinks down to the pool. and I’m not referring to alcohol. I had Gatorade in a yeti and I was told I couldn’t even go in with that.. We were going to order food, but the food on the menu is very limited and very odd so we wound up leaving, grabbing lunch somewhere else just going to the beach. I was very, very, very disappointed.

The location is the best attribute of this hotel. The price of the room per night was overpriced for the amenities. Shower was tiny. The bar was great to have onsite but the coffee shop made a really unpleasant espresso. We didn’t get a chance to eat in the restaurant or jump into pool but tgat was nice to have onsite. It’s clear we stayed there at the end of the summer season but overall it was fine.

¡What an amazing place to stay! We had the best experience in Montauk beach house, the hotel in general is spectacular and the attention to detail is on point. The staff was very friendly, helpful and attentive to give the best service to the guests, Adriana, the manager, was so caring and kind, she made us feel that more than a hotel it’s a total experience being there. Me and my family highly suggest everyone to go and visit this gem in Montauk, you will definitely feel that everyone there just want to give you the best time during your vacations.

We had an amazing stay at the montauk beach house. Both my kids 7 & 3 had a great time, pool was warm and very family friendly. We love how private this resort is. Food is incredible, we had the lamb burger everyday we were there. Highly recommend and will be back 🤍

Highly recommended this if you’re staying in Montauk. Walking distance to the beach, shops and restaurants. Pool, bar and restaurant on site are phenomenal. Lastly, the team at the Montauk Beach House are all so friendly and hospitable! You leave feeling like you have new best friends!

Great stay at The Montauk Beach House. The pool area and service was amazing! A++ Speical shoutout to Emma who always made sure we had full pitchers of water with ice and very attentive if wanted anything to drink or eat. Always checking in just enough to make sure we were good. Highly suggest the lunch by the pool. We ordered burgers by the pool which were delicious and even better not having to leave the pool area as we maximized our time in the beautiful weather. Also the location of the hotel is amazing walking distance to everything in town for breakfast, dinner and very short walk to the beach!!

I'd give it a 2.5 rating but half stars aren't allowed and it was better than just 2 stars. Glad we got an off-season rate (about 300 per night). Room was clean, smaller than expected. It was located by the air conditioning compressors so it had a continuous. low buzzing sound. Lighting was weird with warm bulbs by bed lamps and harsh fluorescent ones overhead and in bathroom. Our biggest thing was that there wasn't a mini fridge or coffee/tea machine like we typically see at even the most basic hotels. There was a small coffee bar in lobby where you could purchase coffee in AM or walk into town. Biggest benefit was how you were a 5 minute walk into town and the beach. Guess this is what you're paying for. Hotel had no info on activity suggestions but had free wifi so you could do your own searches. I recommend asking about location of your room before booking. Some may appreciate having the pool right outside your room door while others may prefer being on other side of hotel. Staff was cordial, if not slightly aloof. I wouldn't "not" stay again but I probably would try elsewhere next time. It was so-so experience. Definitely not worth the regular rate of over 500 per night .Oh, and beware of the minibar...there was a wine that retailed $28 that they were charging $106 for.

Love the vibe and great small plates at bar - as a Montauk resident it is still fun - bartenders are friendly

The Montauk Beach house was clean and friendly. It's a block anyway from the beach and the shopping

This review is mainly for the restaurant as I have not stayed in the rooms but truly everything that I have tried on the menu (both food and drink) have been incredible, you truly can't go wrong. Just LOOK at these truffle fries, the soft shaved truffles are truly to die for. I would come back just for this. The truffle pizza is also the best I've ever had. The Call me an Uber cocktail and the Mexican Unicorn are the best cocktails. In terms of the staff, Yannis, Adriana, Walt, etc. are all great! We did a summer partnership with our ECOfashion Corp brands and we had a great time helping infuse sustainability into the hotel. They were very accommodating and we had a blast spending a lot of time at the hotel throughout the summer.

Not a bad spot to stay if you are in Montauk. The pool area is great for the younger crowd or people that like to have the party where they sleep, not my favorite to have the party and noise so close to where I sleep. It would get loud at night to try to settle down. The rooms were nicely decorated and the beds weren't bad. Not very sound proof and wasn't a quiet night of sleep though. Don't recommend staying here on a weekend at all if you plan on getting a night of sleep at all though.

The hotel guests above our room were partying all night. We called the night service and not one hotel employee spoke to the rowdy guests. There were ants in our hotel room then when we complained, the guest services contact suggested we may get a discount for a future stay. We will never stay here again! - Adriana D.

They have done a tremendous job activated the back of the property and pool area . It's visually stunning and the team have maximized the old Ronjo property . The Dj Adam is about the best DJ I have heard in the Hamptons . The drinks were great and the team welcoming . The crowd was sophisticated and hip . Probably not the place to do shots and bang beer cans off your forehead , Got to The point and stay there if that's your game .

5 stars across all boards! What a pleasant 6 hours we spent here. So during COVID, we weren't allowed to go to the pool and we had to meet a minimum due to our party of 10, but that was completely understandable because the plan was to spend most of the day there and we were lucky that it was scorching hot that day. Our waiter Ryan, was the BEST. We ordered 2 vueve cliquots, a bottle of 1942, and about 12 pitchers of the Love machine and Montauk make outs (they were THAT good). The food was phenomenal. We ordered a clam pizza, truffle pizza, and diavola (all amazing). Then we got 2x tuna tartars (so good with the kiwi addition), 2 x beet salads with goat cheese (bomb!), 2x smoked burratas (I'm not a fan of smoked burrata, but it was good), and a charcuterie board (gone instantly). Honestly, Ryan attentiveness was outstanding. Best server we've had during our whole Montauk stay. And the food was amazing - props to the chef! Would love to come back again next time again. The minimum requirement was worth the 6 hours we got to spend here.

A great place for vegans! My review is specifically for the restaurant. I have always had a wonderful experience with service, specifically Ryan goes above and beyond with customer service. The guacamole is delicious and I appreciate that they have a lot of vegan and gluten-free options which is not very common in Montauk. I've read mixed reviews about the pizza but I always get the gluten-free vegan pizza and it's delicious.

Came here Saturday and had a table by the pool. Great vibes, awesome dj, and a partnership with Tanqueray which meant free drinks (albeit exclusively gin-based). We ordered guacamole and pizza. The guacamole was great (had beans in it which was new and cool) but the pizza wasn't great. As a group we had a debate about whether pizza can, definitionally, be bad (like most food) or not (like boobs). 50% of the group decided the pizza was average and the remaining 50% said it's bad, but the consensus was "not good". The bar service was slow, and not just because they were busy but because the bartender was drinking with a beer with friends of his, which was annoying.

Have to laugh at some of the reviews here. First of all, Montauk, East Hampton aren't cheap, especially in the summer--people. Pool. We came here to bring our son to the pool for the weekend and could not have had a better experience. The communication from the staff was excellent. They continuously reminded us that there would be an adult pool party on Saturday, but that at our own discretion we could have our son at the pool. What a great time we all had. Maybe it was the crowd, who was fantastic. There were a few groups that were staying here and all super sweet. A bachelor and a bachelorette party. Our son loved the pizza bianca here. Drink pouches at the pool were delicious, filled with liquor. The room was perfect. We were on the upper level in the Moonlight rooms with two beds. Spacious, super clean and super cute decor. No fridges, tho, FYI. Super comfy beds and quilts and lots of pillows. The vueve cliquot sundeck was super cute and perfect for all your Instagram photos. Pool guy (David) and pool staff, again, stellar. These people remember your name, always have a smile on and are excellent. Sunday brunch menu was also delectable. Great time. We will be back.

Nice amenities! Pretty cool folks. Near the beach! Still could be a little nicer.

There should be a sign on the door: "Millennials Welcome!" (there are emoji paintings in the lobby, need I say more?) I didn't book a room here, so I can only speak to the outdoor bar and lounge. My friend and I stopped by for drinks one night, they were tasty and strong! The atmosphere is beachy, welcoming, and youthful (tropical house, string lights, loungers and a swimming pool). Interestingly the service team seems to be comprised, almost entirely, of young men and women from Europe--doing a summer work stint in Montauk (our server was from Madrid). Grab a drink at the bar, and then head to one of the enormous striped beach chairs to snuggle up with your friends and take selfies. It feels like it's encouraged here!

This was our first getaway after having a baby. We were excited to finally enjoy some time together in our favorite town! As always we tend to arrive prior to check in and are able to use the facility. Upon check in we were greeted by what it felt like an annoyed front desk employee who was glued to her cellphone. She never showed or extended the grounds to us. I totally understand it's a stressful time to work during covid, I myself will be the first to say as a health care employee, but try to at least be somewhat pleasant and attentive. The parking is horrendous! It's first come first and there are no identifiers visible to let the hotel know who is exactly parking on the property. We had to wait for a spot which was taken by a costumer shopping next door. Later on we get a text stating our room is ready and to check in. Once we get to the room it was still dirty, I wiped down the end tables which had what looked like rings from a beverage. The toilet seat was soiled and outside the shower had rotted wood which contained mold. I wiped everything down anyway because we have a infant at home. I highly doubt they use any state of the art cleaning as specified on a letter which was placed on the bed. That evening we received a text stating they will have breakfast so we don't have to go into town and beat the crowds. The following morning we went to the lobby and no one knew what I was talking about. Apparently the delivery never came she said. We decided to head to the pool area and was asked to leave because they had morning yoga. The man who approached us was rude and should of offered us another area to relax in, but that was not the case. That evening we came downstairs to enjoy the fire pit around 930p and by the time we got someone's attention he stated they stop serving at 10. We were perplexed because the table next to us ordered cocktails from a different server and that was not the case for us. Lastly, after checking out early, we received a text around 12 stating if we do not check out we will be charged an extra fee. I had to phone the front desk and make them aware a second time that we checked out. This was beyond an awful, unwelcoming, and a disappointing stay! I do not recommend this hotel, they need some education on costumer service and cleanliness.

Disclaimer: I never leave a yelp review unless the experience is stellar or a complete abomination. Unfortunately this was the latter. Yes, okay we get it. ~MoNtAuK~ is cool and trendy. They get one star because the rooms are cute and the beds are comfy. The service? LOL--this is where stellar dreams of customer service go to die. The front desk staff is great, but the food and beverage team is a train wreck. Never in my life have I been so disrespected. If I could conceptualize the service in words I would describe it as ocean gutter. Whenever my friends and I asked for drinks while the property was completely empty (besides our party) I was greeted with eye rolls, "is that all" with attitude, "wow that's a lot of drinks" at best. Otherwise we were blatantly ignored. Please, reconsider ever entering the premises. It's the equivalent of lighting actual cash on fire. DO NOT COME HERE.

we chose this resort despite high cost for the amenities at the end of June. the restaurant, pool, and bar were closed and there was no mention of this by staff at check in. also, the staff were inattentive and the room was not as quality as advertised on the site. the hotel was minimally occupied and we were denied a late check out.

No mini bar or fridge ?!?! First time in my life to encounter this. At $450+ a night, this is not supposed to be a cheap motel. Not to mention the tacky "tip jar" next to the bed for house keeping. Seriously?? Completely inappropriate. Lack of taste and tact are not in line with the price.

What a disappointment! I came here because of the reviews and my boyfriend spoke highly of this place. He knows my standards when it comes service, so he said this is the place! We walk in and not one person greeted us. We looked around and then we just found a seat at the bar. The bartender walks up to us, I said hi and how are you. He hands me the menu walks over to his friend across from us and takes a shot with his friend. We wait for a bit and ask to order a drink and he doesn't know what a rocket fuel is and they are out of a fro' rose. Then he just walks away from us. We walked out after that. I refuse to pay for horrible service. So I can only rate this off service and experience. I didn't get the opportunity to taste the drinks and food. Which is fine by me since the service is horrible!

Absolutely fantastic renovated hotel right off the Beach in Montauk. From the trendy decor in the brand new hotel rooms surrounding the modern pools to the numerous open bars gorgeously set on the property, the Montauk Beach House is the perfect location for a weekend in the Hamptons. The resort-like hotel boasts of two pools, numerous over-sized day beds surrounding the gorgeous landscaping in the courtyard, two or more open bars facing the gorgeous pool yard, and plenty of up-scale rooms completely renovated from top to bottom. Upon entering the main lobby, guests are welcomed by classy interior design work which transcends into every other aspect of the hotel. Not only is the facility beautiful, but the staff is beyond friendly and accommodating as well. 5 stars to the Montauk Beach house, the staff, and the gorgeous design. We will definitely be back!

I hate that i even have to give one star as a rating . This place is horrible !!!! Highly overrated . Do not stay here and save your money . Give your money to an establishment who deserves it especially during these trying times ! Service is horrible , rooms are made to look pretty with zero functionality . No Fridge , no Mini bar, hot water runs to cold within a few minutes oh and we had an issue with our AC in August ( which never got fixed)!!! This place is a disgrace . The food at the bar and grill i wouldn't even give to my dog . Terrible terrible terrible . Back to surf lodge and Gurneys ! I'll take my 1099 dollars a night elsewhere .

Not even giving the energy to say what I was going to say. Horrible place with extremely rude people.

I was in MTK for the first time for a bachelorette weekend and we stayed here! The staff was extremely nice and helpful from the moment we stepped in the door and made coordinating with 20 girls a breeze! There is ample parking too, thankfully. Our rooms were right out front, gorgeous! Small but everything we needed, and I looooooved the little cabana lounge chairs you get in the sand right outside your room! The pools are clean and well-kept, the bars are speedy to whip up your drinks (though they should be a $15 a pop!), and there are always beach and pool towels available. It's a beautiful place and we enjoyed the food and baristas in the morning for our coffee! They also have some seriously adorable fire pits around tables that they'll light for you in the evenings, so friggin cute. The location is great, 1 block from the beach (and the Sloppy Tuna bar!), and the little town is super walkable and close so you don't need to get in your car at all. Cabs are easy to get too and the hotel has all the numbers on the wall. We loved our stay here, definitely wish it could've been longer but I would absolutely recommend this place to a friend. Hopefully I'll make it back here soon!

Do not recommend. Not worth the price. No private parking, so good luck parking your car. The parking surrounding motel is public and there's rarely a spot. The front desk only answers once every 20 phone calls. Also, there is no phone in the room. Wine and champagne in room... but no way to chill except ice bucket?! No room service. I had to call front staff on multiple occasions with noise complaints. Walls are paper thin and young girls staying above us with no respect for others. Due to my poor experience, the front desk offered to deliver the bottle of wine I was looking for. I had ordered rose. Plain rose. She brought sparkling. I can't drink sparkling rose. I never bothered to ask for her to get what I had actually ordered. Just another reason I won't be back. Just a motel with a slight face lift. I actually feel foolish that I paid to stay here.

Stayed here recently for our company retreat, very interesting resort. They housed us, fed us and put up with our frat-like antics for two days, so I can't really complain. Highlights: +The beds (even the bunks) are really comfy. Rooms get a bit cold at night, so perhaps turn down AC in your room. +Each room included a cool journal on the nightstand. I thought this was a nice touch. +Showers are awesome (rain on me style), some rooms have claw-foot tubs. +No jacuzzi or hot tub. Bummer. +Insanely close to town and the beach. +Coffee and alcohol bar on premises. +Great chefs (fare included lobster rolls, seafood paella, grilled scallops and mushrooms). Some things were a bit bland, but otherwise very tasty. +Hotel staff is pretty laid back. I think only one person got cut off the whole time. +I love the art in the main entrance. +I think they have bikes that you can borrow (parked in front of the place). +The wi-fi was pretty spotty, so if you're planning on vacationing+working...don't count on a solid connection. Set up a tether from your phone, if possible. +SCHMOOOOORREEEEZZZZ. If they get a jacuzzi/hot tub, this place is guaranteed 5-stars. Thanks for having us, Montauk Beach House!

This place is trash. My wife and I had a family emergency and notified the hotel 4 days before our scheduled one night stay. Management refused to gives us a refund. At the worst time ever for my family this place could care less and kept our money. No phone call to discuss, only wanted to talk via email. DO NOT STAY HERE!!

We haven't even checked out yet and I can't get out of here fast enough. This is the most unprofessional staff I have encountered, the most rude being Nick. He is the only staff in sight, so we politely ask him if someone is around to help us with an issue in our room (one of many). He points to a dark lobby and sarcastically asks, "Do you see anybody??" I'm sorry? So you're telling me you don't have a groundskeeper or night maintenance in case anything should happen to your guests?! It is 11pm and we return to our room, which was blazing hot. Now you may think, "Why not keep the AC on?" Well we had, but the one time (out of the multiple nights we stayed here) the maid service had showed up to sort out our room, we had noticed they turned on the timer on our AC, causing it to turn off constantly. We noticed this on the remote and was unable to remove it. It's August and 90° out, so you could say it was a bit hard to breathe at night. Aside from a lack of AC, we also had a tub that would spray water when you turned it on and at one point I had to fix the toilet. Yup, I had to fix my own toilet. The rusty chain is barely hanging on to the flusher, so we had to open the tank multiple times just to flush. The website says you get a fridge in your room, you don't, and there's no phone in the room to reach the main desk. And don't bother eating or drinking at their "grill" because Maria will not write down your order and forget your drinks...3 times. It took 30 min just to get one soda. Not like the food is anything to brag about. My burrata tasted like they just kept regular cheese in some water and it had a plastic-like skin around it, and the pizza we split tasted like canned sauce on plain bread. I had to spit out the one bite I took. Charlene was a sweetheart and took over half way through dinner, as we saw Maria just hanging out with the other staff and completely ignoring her job. I came to Montauk to enjoy my bachelorette party with my sisters, and the best parts where whenever we were OUT of the hotel. I heard such good things about this place, but it was just one major disappointment. If someone goes wrong at night, you are on your own and the sub-par rooms are over priced and incorrectly advertised on their site. If you want to come and stay in Montauk, find another hotel

Not a great. Unfortunately had a bad experience with Rachel the front hostess and also with the manager there.

I stayed here last summer for my friends wedding and really enjoyed the scene. The rooms were spacious and well designed. Loved having two pools and being so close to the beach but also in the middle of all the action of down town MTK. The food was decent the drinks were great! The property as a whole was exactly what my boyfriend and I were looking out of our weekend getaway to MTK. I can't wait to come back!

The hotel is definitely one of the nicer hotels in montauk. The rooms are clean industrial modern design and there's always events going on at the hotel on the weekends. Hotel located 2 blocks from the beach and a block from the Main Street. The staff was very nice and accommodating. I highly recommend this hotel when visiting montauk.

This is a rating for the outside dining area. We didn't stay in the hotel, but I am most definitely looking into staying there next year. There are many lounge chairs and tables set up outside the pool with great music and a good crowd. We had about 14 people in our group and ordered many many drinks and food. The lobster wrap was huge and delicious, as was the fluke ceviche and Mediterranean plate. Our waitress was attentive and very nice. For such a large crowd, she took great care of our table. Everyone in our group loved this place and if I didn't do Soul Cycle the next day, I would have returned with them. Marking this as one of my MTK faves.

Came to Montauk Beach House because it was recommended by people in the area; it was a huge mistake. First off, service moved at a snails pace. It seemed like the staff there weren't remotely interested in greeting us, which is crazy because me and my guests were there to spend money and have a fun time. We watched the bartenders do shots with what I can only assume were his friends, and when we complained to a manager he basically shrugged off our complaints also he was flirting with a guest, it was obvious, and kind of gross. Also, and this is the big kick in the teeth: they charge $100.00 for access to the pool, which is crazy because it literally was empty. I grew up on Long Island and spent summers in Montauk. Please don't go here, it gives the area a bad name.

Just love this place. The pool and the DJ rock every weekend. The Stoli drinks are amazing and you can order by the pitcher. I recommend the strawberry fields. The staff has been helpful but some had trouble speaking basic English.

This place is a SCAM. My friends and I went during fourth of July weekend. They blatantly made up that we had to spend $1500 to eat there. Our other friends also had a table and the waiter told them a completely different story. They then OVERCHARGED our bill by charging a more expensive vodka rather than the vodka we got. The staff also does not seem to know whats going on after I called multiple times and actually showed up to talk to someone to ALSO hear the manager is "not on site". This may be a scenic place to eat but not worth the way they treat their customers. ESPECIALLY during a pandemic. I am still upset weeks later.

I reserved a cabana here for the afternoon with a couple of friends during COVID. We were told by multiple employees that we had to spend a $1500 minimum, however when we tried to ask for a manager to confirm this information they would say the manager was not on site. We spent this amount, as they had a card on file as requested as soon as we sat down. It was not until after the charge was placed that we found out from other friends who had reserved cabanas that same day that they were never required to spend that amount. When we tried to confront the restaurant about it, they denied it. Terrible to in the first place lie to customers and take advantage during a pandemic.

In these crazy times, this place sets the gold standard for how all establishments should work. They make all customers feel extremely safe, staff keeps a distance and they couldn't be more accommodating. If you're in Montauk, do yourself a favor and check out this hidden gem.

I came here, because my cousin was getting married. We got accommodations , so the room was a pretty good price a night when it's regularly 750$ a night..... yea 750$. We were first rooomed in the 300's rooms and immediately the bathroom door didn't work! We then noticed they don't really have any appliances in the room, not a crazy big deal but ‍ ( I would also like to mention I personally didn't mind my stay but if I was paying the regular price of 750$ for this k would be disgusted I wouldn't pay more than 200$ a night. Ridiculous. Totally not worth it!) After using the toilet, we later realized it was broken. They were extremely nice and switched us to a new room. The bathroom door is a sliding door, but there's about 2 inches of space in between the door and the door frame! No privacy :( I will say the pool is very nice the look of the whole place is "expensive" but 750$ a night for a shitty bathroom and just lack of overall ease - eh. Now again the place is very nice, gives a good vibe (the pool and lounge area are beautiful) but if you're thinking of staying here (and aren't LOADED) I would recommend finding somewhere else to put your money!

Stayed here for 3 nights. Not sure where to start. We paid $1900 for those three nights. The beds are uncomfortable. There is no phone in the room. Everything is supposed to be done via an app called "Alice" that we couldn't download (Android and iPhone). The walls are thin so got to listen to our neighbords' TV all night. No mini bar or fridge in the room. No iron. No closet. Not even a bench, sofa or chair in the room to sit down. Soaps and shampoo aren't bad. The bathroom is small and cramped. Poor shower design - water goes all over the floor. The hot water is either burning you or it's ice cold. So incredibly infuriating!! The bathroom ceiling is dropped so the shower head is lowered - if you are over 5 '10 ft you need to hunch down while you shower. (And get burned or freeze...) This is a glorified motel. We complained to the front desk and we were told that they can't do anything about the shower design. I would never stay here again. Save your money and your patience. So many other places with better value and amenities.

This is a very cute boutique motel. The rooms are small and have no refrigerators and no coffee maker. There are two pools at the hotel with great seating and pool service. Definitely a fun vibe. I would say this hotel is for singles in their 20's and 30's. Everyone else, stay at Gurney's or the Surf Club. The most annoying and frustrating thing is the walls and floors of this motel are paper thin. It's a two story motel. We are on the first floor (Room 104). The people in the room above us are louder than a heard of elephants. Every time they move a tiny bit it sounds like a freight train running over my head. It's non stop too. I'd say at least 80% of the time that we are in the room we can hear everything they are saying and what they are watching on TV and hear every move they make!!! This hotel is way too expensive for an experience like this. For $600/night invest in sound proofing!!!!!

We spent a memorable day at the Montauk Beach House! It's a fun, laid-back place with 2 pools, comfortable lounge chairs, a well-stocked bar, and great food. They had a DJ and a band for entertainment the day we were there. All the staff were friendly, responsive, and accomodating. The crowd was fun and pretty much all young. We didn't stay overnight, although we would've liked to - they told us they are booked every weekend the entire summer! All in all, a quality day and we WILL be there again

Our recent stay at The Montauk Beach House was beyond our expectations. The attention to detail is far above anything we have ever experienced before in Montauk or just about anywhere else. Just as an example my 15 year old said that this was in his top three vacations ever and it rained almost the entire time we were there. Rooms were meticulous. Staff was warm and helpful. The breakfast was perfect. Overall a great experience. We will definitely be back.

This is great place!!! great service I enjoyed a lot, drinks were delicious food great as well, the pool very relax, staff so lovely And the beach is just right across the street, I can't wait to come back soon!

Ok, I get it. People might come here for a scene rather than the food, but there is a limit. I mean, I've had better food at a giants game. McDonald's is gourmet to this. The hummus doesn't even taste like chickpea, it's made with food coloring and tasteless paste. The burger patty was for sure frozen and hardly edible. My brother is sick from some fish tacos. Come on guys, get it together just a little!

I was told this was a great spot to stay in Montauk, and that's about the only good thing about it: the location. It's definitely within walking distance to the beach and all the downtown area has to offer. However, a certain level of service and accomodations are expected when you pay the amount they charge for a room, and the hotel didn't live up to its high costs. We brought our own floaties because we saw other people do it on their Instagram account, and were told by the pool staff we couldn't have them when we arrived in a very condescending tone. It was really embarrassing lugging our enormous floaties out of the pool area while everyone stared at us. One of the main reasons we picked this hotel was because it had a pool to float in, so this was a major disappointment, especially since they advertise that you can. Then, when we came back to the pool and were ready to order a drink, it took an hour for the waitress to even notice us. She served everyone else. Just not us. I have never encountered such a rude, stuck-up staff! Lastly, we asked to check out a little later than 11am, and were basically told we had to leave. Even though people can't check in until 3pm. Yes, it has a convenient location and nice decor, but I'll never stay here again, and want to warn anyone who's looking to choose from the 100s of other adorable hotels and vacation rentals in the area. We dined in a lot of them, and already have our next vacation spots picked out.

Terrible all around, made a reservation when I arrived they told me they were no longer letting people in, so what's the point of taking a reservation. Literally I had a Seinfeld moment anyone can take a reservation but they don't know how to hold the reservation. When I tried to discuss this issue with the manager he got completely nasty with me, it could be that he had a Napoleon complex or the fact that he got bullied in high school and wants to throw his weight around, whatever the case may be there are much better places to attend that actually hold reservations and treat their customers the way they deserve to be treated

Completely Screwed over LARGE wedding group renting out 5+ rooms... Allowed cops to be called on patrons who were outside their rooms not making more noise than normal conversation at 11 pm on a Friday and Saturday night. Treated like dogs on time out. There was a bar and a pool club but we were not allowed to enjoy these amenities due to "noise ordinance" . Coordination of room locations done so poorly that people staying for a triathlon were located right above the paper thin ceilings where if we dropped a dime on the floor the obnoxious overly excited to exercise patrons above us would complain. The actual room itself is a poor attempt at being fashionable. Poor lighting. With a cheap renovation and even cheaper coat hanger that fell down during the night with three tuxedos hanging off it. I believe it was three tuxedos exceeding its weight limit. Staff was not helpful and Drinks were as expensive as a rooftop in Manhattan.

If I could give ZERO, I would, but yelp doesn't allow that. I've never felt more disrespected by someone who claims to be a manager. Went for some food and drinks, went in our bathing suits, decided we wanted to take a dip in the pool, well within seconds the "manager" and some other employee came over, told us RUDELY to get out of the pool, walked us back to our table and told us that are giving us the bill and we have to leave because we were not guests staying there so we couldn't use the pool. The way we spoke to us and went about the situation was absolutely embarrassing. If I ever chose to stay there, absolutely not. He never gave any kind of "warning" about not being allowed to use the pool if we were not staying. If you want to have people like the vibe (which absolutely sucks, unless you want to be some sort of "Instagram famous" person, walk in) don't treat your guests with zero respect and talk down to them. I'll never step foot in there again.

Overall I wasn't that impressed. The rooms are small and have been refaced, not remodeled. The bathrooms are so small and the stand up shower leaked water all over the floor because it's basically a flat plastic piece floor with barely a lip to keep water inside. The bathroom is SO small the sink and mirror aren't even inside. There is only one small said mirror in the entire room, I would love floor length ones. No mini bar or mini fridge either and the tv is so small (not that we watched it). At the pool there are several exits, but only one is opened, so you have to walk all the way around to get out and then back to go to the bathrooms, which also, did not have mirrors in them! Check in is 3pm and check out is 11am and they are strict on this. My friend was a nursing mother and they could NOT provide her with any space to pump, they offered her a tiny 2 stall bathroom outside of the pool (the one with no mirror) and it stunk, literally. They wanted her to sit on a toilet in the stall and pump there. She was so mad and was forced to wait until 3pm when the room opened. I will say it is a nice location to the town and the beach, even though it's not on the water. The pool is really nice, but open all the exits! The large orders of margaritas were delicious. Tasted fresh made and not from a bottle. The staff was nice too, I would stay again if I had to but defintely isn't my first choice.

I went to the Montauk Beach House over July 4th weekend. My boyfriend and I had a great time there. It just opened that weekend so we were the first to stay in the room. The room was decorated very nicely with furniture from Restoration Hardware which was beautiful! The bed was very comfortable and it's in the great location. The toilet wasn't working when we first got there but they fixed it fairly quickly. The pool area was very nice with beds all around the pool. The pool wasn't heated when we got there but they worked on it and it was heated the next day. They have 4 outdoor showers by the pool with hot running water which was great! I loved that! They also have a DJ by the pool playing music for part of the day and into the night. It's sort of like a club atmosphere kind of like you're in Miami. I really do love the music by the pool but it went for too long into the night. Instead of having the music by the pool go on too late, they could just keep it near the bar area when it gets really late, which would be fine. The staff was ok but they should have been more customer service oriented. For a place like that, they really should care more about their customers needs. They left us two bottles of Voss water in the room, which was nice, but don't try asking them for one more they won't give it to you. They also sell coffee in the lobby but they didn't have decaf, so it would be best to go across the street to the bakery for that. Except for a few things stated above that need improvement, we had a great time at the Montauk Beach House and we are going back there for two more weekends before the summer ends.

I like the Montauk Beach House. I like the location, daytime landscaping, music (maybe they could mix up the genres a little bit more) and the room. The bed in the room was nice and had never been slept on before. I like the shower and the soaps. Speaking of showers, they had four between the two pools and oh yeah the pools were nice too. I used the drawer in the room as my room safe,... it had a skeleton key. There's no free coffee in the rooms but you can buy really good coffee in the hotel lobby, but it's expensive. I met the owners, they were pretty nice, they were cool and nonplussed. So we liked it enough to make another another reservation, while we were still at the hotel. So we get online and there's a hickup with the Internet booking reservation, so I think, we're right here at the hotel, let's go to the front desk. They ended up having a little bit of a hard time and came to the conclusion well sorry, somebody must've booked the room. I was a little insistent that no, it was a glitch in their system and that they should honor our requests until they find out who this mysterious other person was that booked the room. What ended up happening was, we did book the room, it was our reservation, not someone else's. It was awkward how they handled it, I think they could've been more gracious to a repeat customer that's right there in their face instead of some mysterious person that's not there. They have nice LCD TVs, but they were not set up to utilize the HD cable box, I programmed the tv. I also figured out how to turn off the blue light on the air conditioner that was bothering my girlfriend because it was so bright. They could use a shade to black out the room more at night on the window that was facing north/west. In the end what matters most maybe is that I'm really torn, I like really nice accommodations, but I also like low-key, no-frills, inexpensive hotel rooms and the old Montauk that is probably gone forever. The real beauty in Montauk can be found surfing out at Ditch Plains when the Up Islanders (cityfolk), bring their aloha spirit to the year-round locals.