The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House

Steak house · Stafford

The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House

Steak house · Stafford

4

1201 E Bay Ave, Manahawkin, NJ 08050

Photos

The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by @TheInfatuation
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by @TheInfatuation
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by @TheInfatuation
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House by null

Highlights

Raw bar, seafood, steak & cocktails with live weekend music  

Featured in Eater

1201 E Bay Ave, Manahawkin, NJ 08050 Get directions

oldcauseway.com
@oldcauseway

$$ · Menu

Information

Static Map

1201 E Bay Ave, Manahawkin, NJ 08050 Get directions

+1 609 488 1327
oldcauseway.com
@oldcauseway

$$ · Menu

Features

payment credit card
Tap to pay
reservations
wifi

Last updated

Oct 23, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@infatuation

The Best Restaurants On Long Beach Island - Jersey Shore - The Infatuation

"Old Causeway isn’t technically on LBI, but before you insult our geography skills, know that we already heard it all in sixth-grade homeroom, and it still belongs on this guide. Not only is it the last turn before the bridge, but they also have a private shuttle that you can call to take you to and from the island. As the name suggests, there are steaks and oysters on the menu, and while you won’t be upset ordering either here, our favorite thing to get at dinner is the karate-chop pork chop doused in a pineapple-soy glaze. You could also just come for Happy Hour from 3-6pm, have a few drinks at the bar, and eat some spice-rubbed wings and jersey devils, which, for the uninitiated, are deviled eggs topped with fried oysters." - alison kessler, regan stephens, matt tervooren, tonya russell

https://www.theinfatuation.com/jersey-shore/guides/best-restaurants-long-beach-island
View Postcard for The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House
@infatuation

The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House - Review - Manahawkin - Jersey Shore - The Infatuation

"Old Causeway isn’t technically on LBI, but before you insult our geography skills, know that we already heard it all in sixth-grade homeroom, and it still belongs on this guide. Not only is it the last turn before the bridge, but they also have a private shuttle that you can call to take you to and from the island. As the name suggests, there are steaks and oysters on the menu, and while you won’t be upset ordering either here, our favorite thing to get at dinner is the karate-chop pork chop doused in a pineapple-soy glaze. You could also just come for Happy Hour from 3-6pm, have a few drinks at the bar, and eat some spice-rubbed wings and jersey devils, which, for the uninitiated, are deviled eggs topped with fried oysters. RESERVE A TABLE WITH RESERVE A TABLE" - Matt Tervooren

https://www.theinfatuation.com/jersey-shore/reviews/the-old-causeway-steak-oyster-house-lbi
View Postcard for The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House
@infatuation

Where To Eat Down The Shore: Long Beach Island - New York - The Infatuation

"Old Causeway isn’t technically on LBI, but before you insult our geography skills, know that we already heard it all in sixth-grade homeroom, and it still belongs on this guide. Not only is it the last turn before the bridge, but they also have a private shuttle that you can call to take you to and from the island. As the name suggests, there are steaks and oysters on the menu, and you won’t be upset ordering either here, but our favorite thing to get at dinner is the karate-chop pork chop doused in a pineapple-soy glaze. You could also just come for Happy Hour (3-6pm), have a few drinks at the bar, and eat some spice-rubbed wings and jersey devils (deviled eggs topped with fried oysters)." - Matt Tervooren, Tonya Russell

https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/guides/long-beach-island-restaurants-surf-city-manahawkin-ship-bottom-beach-haven-barnegat-light-harvey-cedars
View Postcard for The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House
@eater

The Jersey Shore’s Top Restaurants | Eater NY

"Live music on the weekends is the time to go to Old Causeway (1201 East Bay Ave.) — named for the bridge it sits next to — but it gets packed, so go early for dinner and then head to the bar. Oysters and beef are coupled here in wood-fired steaks and burgers topped with fried bivalves, but the rest of the extensive menu is filled with American classics and lots of seafood. It’s always a good time, which the owners are well aware of — if diners drink too much, they can always hop on the restaurant-provided shuttle home." - Stefanie Tuder

https://ny.eater.com/maps/best-jersey-shore-restaurants
View Postcard for The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House

Joe McCull

Google
Went there for 1st time and was meeting family member who was slightly behind us. Hostess was friendly and although she wouldn’t seat us until all parties were present, she gave us a fifteen minute window and held a table. Perfectly understandable. Place was packed. Jake our server was fantastic! Pleasant and quickly attended to us. Had the deviled eggs both ways to start. Better then mom’s. Pork chop melted in my mouth, salad entry was large.. we were there for late lunch. Can’t wait to go back for dinner. Ask for Jake, very nice young man!! Forgot—-the pork belly was as tender as cotton candy.

K. K.

Google
Super charged cocktail and food menu with lots of seafood forward options. Incredible service with great attentiveness and friendliness. Food was fresh and on point, cocktails were tasty and on point. Highly recommend. Accepts reservations u like the sister restaurant mud city. Would def come again

Daniela Cernansky

Google
We celebrated a 21st birthday party at this restaurant. The experience was overall spectacular, the service was very helpful and friendly. They mostly offer seafood, but have other selections such as chicken and pork as well. We went on a Friday night and it was very busy, so consider making a reservation. Also, it’s a bit pricey but worth it! 100% recommend!

Ryan DiStephano

Google
Still chasing that Fish Taco experience The Old Causeway is an establishment that I have frequented before. The first time I went, I thought their fish tacos were absolutely amazing, potentially the best I have ever had. This most recent trip, the food was still good but the fish tacos felt a little disappointing compared to the last time because of how amazing they were the first time. Overall I would say the Fish Tacos were really good, the Big Cheese was good as well, & the Pulled Pork Sandwich was great. This place is terribly crowded & the parking was awful. If not for the parking, this would get a 5 star review.

John Lewellen

Google
Okay this was really a great place to eat it was very loud because it has a big crowd the parking is a little tight but in due time you will find a parking place really enjoyed the place and the service was excellent the girl was very friendly and we very much enjoyed our meal great food

Bob W

Google
I had lunch here today. I had the seafood pot which had a mix of fish and seafood in a tomato broth. I expected it to be a spicy broth but it was on the sweet side. It was good but not exactly what I expected. I also had it with pasta which was a slim lasagna noodle which was an odd item to add to the pot. The food was good but I was a bit disappointed that the broth was not what I was expecting. When I mentioned it to the waitress on how to improve the dish, she said that next time ask for it in a spicy sauce.

Megan McGrath

Google
Love OC! I live about 4 minutes away, depending on the traffic. My boyfriend, his family and I are regulars for brunch, however I have been here countless other times. I have never had a bad meal. The hostesses, wait staff, and bartenders are absolutely wonderful and it’s worth every penny!

Darlene MsDove

Google
We went here based on a recommendation from a friend, and loved it! Great casual and fun place, really awesome food, and super service. They don't seat until your full party is there, so don't plan on arriving in spurts for larger parties. Kim was our waitress and she was awesome and helped with some recommendations. We tried the deviled eggs because the menu said it was a must try, and they were delish. The asparagus was cooked perfect with a lovely light lemon flavor. Fish tacos were super, comparable to some of the best ones I've had in San diego, and the Pork chop special was to die for! We will be back when we are in the area again. Forgot to mention the rocky road bread pudding - simply scrumptious and this could easily appease a party of 4 to share!
google avatar

Jessica Y.

Yelp
Sooo good!!! We came for brunch and the food was so good and service was great as well. I started with a Bloody Mary which came with a deviled egg and fried oyster which was so unique! My friend got the mimosa and if you want another, it's just $1 which is a great deal. The milk for my coffee came with a cute cow holder that my friend ordered online immediately after. For my main, I got the mud city Benedict which was phenomenal. They bread was so fluffy and crab is so fresh and tasty. I was so full after just one piece but ended up eating the whole thing because it was so good. This dish probably could've been shared amongst two people it was so filling. My friends split the Benedict and kings breakfast sandwich which they enjoyed as well. I can't wait to come back for dinner next time I'm in the area!
google avatar

Jon H.

Yelp
The Old Causeway is the vibe. No matter how many times I come here the bar and high tops are always busy and buzzing. It's no surprise The Old Causeway is popular. It's not easy to find a buck-a-shuck happy hour that's offered daily. Not only are oysters on their daily buck-a-shuck but clams on the half shell are as well! Do not sleep on their wings (also offered on happy hour)! Not the typical style of wings I go for but these are meaty, cooked very nicely for their large size, and the honey drizzle they're finished off with is perfection. As this was our second stop for the day we unfortunately only had oysters and clams, but that just means I'll have to be back soon to get wings and their OC chips topped with braised beef and other fixin's. The building, the bar, and all of the decor just makes it feel like you're in a shore town, and the restaurant is set in a perfect location for the feel and vibes. We were lucky enough to score 4 bar seats almost immediately upon walking in, and by the time we left multiple people were hovering waiting for seats. With how busy it was, service was never slow. The bartenders and the shuckers did a fantastic job keeping the drinks flowing and the oysters coming. Writing this review a few days after our visit is putting me in the mood to make the hour drive again soon! This was my fiancé's first time here and I know it won't be her last. She may have enjoyed it more than I did and that's saying something.
google avatar

Kelly P.

Yelp
I rarely leave the island during the summer because of the traffic but during the week this is the def go to place we will hit. Great happy hour and amazing food. Occasional the wait is a bit longer then I would like but.... Like I said great food so you have to expect other people like it too! Worth the trip for sure
google avatar

Lisa B.

Yelp
Always a great experience! We're locals and love going during off season, especially during a nice storm. The ambiance is always cozy and inviting. Great service and attention to our needs from our server! Hostess was very sweet and accommodating with our party. Brunch drinks were delicious- the menu is always super fun & different. Only complaint was the steak in the breakfast wrap was not a filet... super chewy and huge chunks. Server took care of it and we appreciate the hospitality! Get the Jersey Devil Bloody Mary & Chicken Fried Steak!
google avatar

Nicole F.

Yelp
Loved this neighborhood gem! Casual Atmosphere, large bar area with a few TVs and high top tables that are first come first serve tables. They have a dining room as well- still Casual but a little more polished table service. The quality of the food here exceeded our expectations. The 10oz filet was cooked medium as requested and it was very tender. The side order of mashed potatoes were creamy with some lumps (so good), the entree of crab cakes were unbelievable ! Filled with crab- hardly any filler. Drinks- Tito's blue (blue cheese olives ) vanilla old fashioned and black Manhattan were all well crafted. We can't wait to go back and try many other items from the menu. Our server was Kerwir- he hit it out of the park- great suggestions since this was our first time , he clearly loves his job. 3 cocktails, 2 mains, one side for $ $146. We left full and satisfied.
google avatar

Ed C.

Yelp
Review is based on happy hour in the bar area which seats about 25 comfortably. The happy hour menu is from 3-6pm and draws locals and regulars. I chose one dozen of the BUCK A SHUCK HOUSE OYSTERS ON THE HALF SHELL, an awesome deal and fresh as could be. I also ordered a pretzel with cheese sauce which was literally as big as my head. I topped it off with a couple OC IPA's. The bartenders and food service people were friendly and knowledgeable. The restaurant was clean, the vibe was happy. There is a ramp on the side of the building if you're not a stairs person. Plenty of parking, including an overflow lot. Five stars, no downside as far as I saw.
google avatar

Daniel M.

Yelp
Amazing place that the wait is definitely worth it went on a weekend so naturally it's crowded but we know a guy. Service was fast and friendly and atmosphere is nice. The mussels are fantastic. The sauce is a buttery garlic sauce that is like soup so use that bread to dip. The portions are on the large side so you will probably have leftovers as we did. The tuna Sandra had was amazing served over noodles. It was a bit spicy and cooked perfectly. I had shrimp and grits that might be on my top 10 meals ever. The texture and taste was amazing and flavor was fantastic. Wish we lived closer. Prices are reasonable for what you get. This is definitely a must try place. Enjoy
google avatar

Cassy B.

Yelp
I've been told the causeway is hit or miss multiple times. My family and I decided to try it the other night before the busy season kicks in. The experience was very mid for me, but I have to say the service was fabulous. When we arrive, they had live music and we sat in the back, which was super comfortable and enough to just enjoy it and not have it be too loud. The interior is nicely decorated, and once again the staff was just really on top of everything. I got a lobster roll, which was good, but nothing outstanding. Their coleslaw is good, but not incredibly flavorful. My boyfriend got the pork chop and while he liked it, he said it wasn't a home run. My mother-in-law got a steak and asked for it medium, and it was really really raw in the middle so it was a little hard for her to eat. Overall, I'd probably go somewhere else on or off the island before coming back here. The food wasn't bad but it wasn't enough for the price point they have. We also tried a few desserts and they were average as well.
google avatar

Monica D.

Yelp
This and Mud City next-door, their sister restaurant, are my go to spots to on my way home from AC. On my last visit, I wanted a little bit of a few things so I got a single crab cake, fried green tomatoes, and Jersey deviled eggs. Unfortunately, the crabcakes feel like they're getting smaller every time, I wouldn't mind paying more for the larger portion they used to give. I also find the FGT are cut too thick for my liking, but they are tasty. The deviled eggs are always amazing.
google avatar

David S.

Yelp
This place is still at the top of my go to's. There's so many things on this menu that are just out of control. First thing that always hits me is their chicken wings are the best on the planet, the clams on a half shell are always ice cold fresh and delicious. Everything else on the menu is great. This is the place you want to go but prepare for a wait.
google avatar

Mark D.

Yelp
Always a favorite... buck a shuck happy hour or a full dinner out OC never fails. Be prepared, it's not quiet but hey you're at the beach... relax. The seafood boil pot is freaking amazing, a gem on the menu that should not go overlooked. Order extra bread you will need it for the exquisite broth.
google avatar

Ryan H.

Yelp
Who knew you could get wood fired steaks on Long Beach island! Absolutely delish and perfectly cooked medium rare prime rib. The horseradish sauce was to die for. But you guys, you have to try the side of carrots and brussel sprouts. The sauce on each was incredible. We got as an app. We will be back for years to come! Such good vibes inside and out servers were hilarious.
google avatar

Chris A.

Yelp
Amazing seafood, but amazing all around food. Eaten here many times for both business & personal, and it hits all 5 stars every time. Only downside, no reservations. But it's worth the wait!
google avatar

Tim S.

Yelp
Always a good experience here. Food is fresh and service is fast. Lunch specials were delicious.
google avatar

David B.

Yelp
We usually go for buck a shuck at happy hour (oysters are a good value - didn't love the little clams). This time we went for dinner and it was delicious. Seems they have more meat dishes than seafood, which surprised me. Started with the octopus has from the specials list, and had a fantastic hanger (hangar?) steak, also a special. Wife had crab cakes - really good. Server was friendly, but didn't listen well - we ordered tap water and got bottled sparking. And one of us ordered the seafood hotpot without the noodles, and got noodles. This place is always packed!
google avatar

ryan s.

Yelp
The steak was one of the best we've had - definitely the best choice. Some unique choices like that lobster Reuben which was great too. Always get shoestring fries with each order. Had a big slice of cake and some good drinks (like a boood orange mojito) not pictured too.
google avatar

Miche

Yelp
Great service & a very popular place! We shared the crabcake appetizer . We ordered the lobster tail and a filet mignon. Included a mushroom dish and brussels sprouts. Everything was absolutely magnificent and fresh.. so flavorful! Absolute heaven! Adorable, nostalgic beach, decor, and photos !
google avatar

Tatiana D.

Yelp
The best part about this place was the service. Great and friendly people. Great vibe and hangout place for food or drinks. I had the pulled pork sandwich. It had a bbq taste to it which wasn't but I usually like mine more on the sweet end. My friends had the Rueben and forgot the other thing haha but it was lobster with fries. They both loved there meals. A bit pricey but would go again.

Rich D.

Yelp
Great spot. Sunday Brunch is awesome. Bottom list mimosas and menu is outstanding. Wings are unique and delicious. Favorite spot if I am going off Island.
google avatar

Stephanie L.

Yelp
I recently had dinner at the Old Causeway Stake and Oyster House. The place was fairly crowded with a bar like atmosphere and karaoke happening in the front room. The menu has an extensive selection of seafood, steaks and burgers. Service was good. My father had the Ruben and I had the steakhouse burger. Both were the cheapest thing on the menu at 18$. It seems to just be a really expensive place for the atmosphere. The burger was okay. It was a bit large and hard to eat with the avocado, egg, bacon and the texas toast. The sauce was abundant and the burger was salted as well. I wasn't able to eat the entire thing in one sitting and it didn't reheat particularly well. The coleslaw was just cabbage and vinegar.

Maddie L.

Yelp
Normally, I am not one to complain about service, but my family did not have a good experience at this restaurant. First, there is barely any parking so you have to drive far and walk along the side of the road to park, but they don't seat parties unless everyone is there. This is especially frustrating if you have older family members and they are dropped off. What is the big deal to allow people to be seated as they come? The restaurant isn't even that big and there were like 3 hostesses at the stand anyway. One of my family members (who is 25), ordered a drink but his ID was not scanning for some reason, and they confiscated the ID. Coming from working in the food service industry, many of us understand that that is their policy to hold it, but the manner and attitude in which our server told my family member about his ID was completely uncalled for. She acted like he was an annoying petulant kid. The bartender was okay and way nicer, and we requested for the police to come and run the ID, but the way in which our server handled this was extremely rude. Once the police ran the ID and everything was fine, like we knew it would be, she came back with an attitude, his drink, and his ID and didn't say anything. Overall, we had very poor service from our server. We had empty drinks for about a half hour before we had to flag her twice to get refills. One of my other family members got a burger and did not eat it because it tasted very wrong and off. They also made it wrong with the wrong toppings (when we pointed it out, she blamed my family member and said "well it's really hard to hear you"). My family member said it had a funky taste and we were concerned the meat was bad. When we asked the server to please remake or take it off the bill, she said that is the way the burgers taste because it is wood-grilled. At the end of the dinner, she sarcastically asked if we wanted a box so we can take the burger "home to feed our dog." Additionally 4 out of the 10 meals we got were cold when they came out. The steaks were tough despite ordering medium/medium rare. We are reasonable people and understand people may have bad days, but this was supposed to be a night of celebration for my family, and it was a very disappointing night, especially considering the prices.
google avatar

Ron B.

Yelp
Best oysters on the Jersey Shore. Great happy hour prices. Even though the place is always busy, we have always been able to secure a High Top near the bar or seats at the bar. Service is always great. Very good cocktails and beer selection.

ray H.

Yelp
Ordered the NY Strip. Might be the worst steak I've ever had. Tough and absolutely no flavor. $54 piece of leather. Fries were good. Can't believe they consider themselves a steakhouse that's a joke.

Jacqueline B.

Yelp
We discovered this restaurant online and decided to try it for Father's Day. Got there early for our reservation and they seated us right away. We ordered drinks and they had one of my favorites, Black Manhattan, which is rather unusual. Delicious. Dinner started with a great Oysters Rockefeller. From there we ordered steaks,2 filets and 2 sirloins, both cooked perfectly. Sides were great. Baked potato, Baked stuffed sweet potato, potato crisps, carrots were unbelievable. Service was excellent. Absolutely be back.
google avatar

Rosie P.

Yelp
Yesterday was my son's birthday and we celebrated it early with dinner here. It's a family owned local restaurant that serves delicious food all year round. We ordered: -oysters Rockefeller -fried calamari -jumbo lump crab couscous with fried pork belly -NY strip steak with the lobster tail served with black truffle butter -flat iron steak with a side of baked macaroni & cheese -fish tacos - not pictured We have dined here a few times before and the food is always just as fresh and delicious. The staff is attentive and service is great. There's usually live music and it's always busy. Will definitely be returning soon.
google avatar

Thelobsterrollking G.

Yelp
The old causeway... cute little spot beautiful band atmosphere as a whole was great. However when it comes to my lobster roll it was barely even edible. When this thing first came out and I first laid my eyes on it I was horrified. Burnt bun, dry lobster, no butter! Presentation killed this roll right off the bat dropping it 2 points to begin with. But then when I took my first bite and I tasted burnt roll and dry lobster I didn't know what to do. I was gonna eat it but how? I ended up ripping the burnt crust off and trying to repeat it that way. It could not be done, did not even finish half the roll it was despicable. Other seafood here was good but I only judge on the lobster so with that being said they received my lowest grade yet a 3.6/10. Yikes! Do not reccomend lobster roll even though it looks affordable. Sincerely, thelobsterollking

Wendy G.

Yelp
Dinner for 4 on 5/20/25. We've been loyal patrons of Old Causeway Steak & Oyster for years. My fiancé and I have always had great experiences sitting at the bar... stellar food, attentive service, and a warm atmosphere. But last night was a different story. It was the first time I had ever dined in the main dining room, and the first time my three kids had ever been to the restaurant at all. I even told our server that when she first greeted us. I was genuinely excited to share one of my favorite local spots with them. Unfortunately, the experience was deeply disappointing. We were seated quickly, and our server was initially friendly. Drinks came out, one of them flat, twice. Our appetizer, usually a favorite, was bland. Still, no big deal. We've all worked in hospitality and understand things don't always go perfectly. Then came the entrées. My daughters' and son's steaks (yes, steaks at a place with steak in the name) were ordered medium. Both arrived cold and bloody on the inside, clearly raw. One plate was visibly oozing. I tried to get our server's attention, but she didn't return until the very end of the meal. When I told her the steaks were undercooked, she defensively said, "Well, I asked how everything was earlier and you said great." I replied, "We had only had our first bites and had no idea the steaks were raw at that point." No apology. No offer to fix it. No manager brought over. Just a shrug, a "too late now" energy, and a suggestion to box them up which I almost did. I figured, if I was paying for two barely touched steaks, at least my dogs could enjoy them. But in the end, I left them on the table, deliberately... a quiet way of sending the message she clearly wasn't getting. Also worth noting: I had the crab cakes, which I've had before and loved. Last night, I took one bite and pushed the plate away. They were not fresh. But I didn't even bring it up... my focus was on my kids' meals, and I didn't want to create a scene. That said, any seasoned server should've read the unspoken cues: barely touched plates across the table. No one eating. That alone should have prompted a follow-up or a manager check-in. But nothing. Then came the bill: $197, with not a single item removed. When it came time to pay, she hovered over me while I entered the tip, clearly watching. I left a very small one. Which I've never done in my life. Even when service is off or food is bad, if the server is kind and tries, they still get 20% or more from me... sometimes extra, because I've been there and I have compassion. But last night was a rare exception, and she saw it. She dropped the check holder back onto the table with an attitude and walked away. My son, who works in a high-end restaurant, politely addressed her behavior as we were leaving. Instead of backing off, she got confrontational and defensive, even correcting him about what the check holder was made of (wood, she said)... as if that was the issue. He later returned to speak with a manager and was told there wasn't one available. Moments later, they sent the same server back out to deal with him again. Clearly on purpose. Incredibly unprofessional. This was an uncomfortable, embarrassing experience, especially in front of my kids. I've never left a negative review before, but after years of supporting this place, I can't stay quiet about how poorly this was handled. Mistakes happen, but how you respond matters. And last night, Old Causeway failed at every step.
google avatar

Chris W.

Yelp
I had fish tacos-pathetic! One tiny strip of cod the size of a strip of gum. The shoestring fries were way overcooked. I'll never come back.
google avatar

Keith A.

Yelp
5 stars for todays visit! 3-6 is happy hour in the bar area. Tables are first come first serve and if they are filled you either stalk the tables that look like they are finishing, get a table in the dining area, or leave. Sometimes if multiple people are stalking tables it can be annoying. This place is popular with a great vibe. Our wings were perfect, drinks were good, and atmosphere was chill today. Servers are always cool. Dont be a cheap azz. Tip on regular cost! Tried something new. Got the 2 battered lobster tails. While very expensive at $37 they were really good. Had a gift card so we splurged and split it.
google avatar

Lara G.

Yelp
This place must have a following since it was packed on a Tuesday night in July. We had fun listening to the live music (Chris Fitz) and were able to snag a table early on. We first ordered a round margaritas... which are probably not advertised on their menu for a reason. But then we switched to beer and ordered some apps. Anything you would normally order at a dive type bar was perfection.
google avatar

Cathy S.

Yelp
Wanted a nice place to bring my family. The atmosphere was quite noisy The service was slow and difficult to get our waitress but unfortunately the dinners were very disappointing, so much so I felt the need to apologize to my family. Everyone had an upsetting meal. I'll speak to mine. I ordered the filet with crab and asparagus on top. The steak was a bit well done not to my liking but ok. The really disappointing part was the crab. It was two 1/2" pieces which included the gristle! Also the asparagus were not prepped properly. Most of the stems were still woody. I hope they improve but I won't be going back there to be embarrassed and disappointed.
google avatar

Anne B.

Yelp
Food is great . But expensive. Very loud and crowded. But that's every we're down the shore . Right now it's ok give it 4 more weeks and every great place is full ,
google avatar

Rebecca M.

Yelp
Our first visit to Old Causeway was spurred by a random online story we saw calling it one of the best seafood restaurants on the NJ shore. So we were a bit surprised to see the menu looked much more steak and meat-focused -- but regardless, our experience was positive. The atmosphere is casual and relaxed, tavern-like, and service was fast and friendly. There are so many tempting starters (will be trying the wings, deviled eggs and grilled pretzel on other occasions for sure) but we definitely made a great choice with the bbq ribs, which had a bold spice rub crust. My husband's cioppino was the standout entree, with a ton of well-cooked shellfish in a subtly spicy tomato broth. My prime strip steak was cooked well but could have used much more seasoning. The crisp shoestring fries are generously served and a little too addictive -- one order is definitely more than enough for two hungry people. Overall, we were pleased and will def be coming back to sample more of the extensive menu!

Taylor G.

Yelp
The service has been absolutely terrible the last two times I have been here. The one bartender was extremely slow with taking our order and always seemed too busy socializing with her "regulars." My Dad and I have also always been willing to forgive their lazy service since their Oysters were always very good. Unfortunately this last visit we got a dozen of them and had to send them back before we even finished half of them. We had to spit out every oyster because they had chunks of shells in them due to poor shucking. Then as soon as we sent them back, the bartender immediately used the excuse "Sorry our guy is shucking with one arm back there." Although I appreciate the shucker's willingness to keep working while wearing a sling, but that's still a terrible excuse because management should've stepped in and had someone else shucking the oysters in the first place. As a result of all this, it makes our decision a lot easier now to never visit the Old Causeway again...and that's really a shame especially coming from a couple LBI local residents.
google avatar

Gregory R.

Yelp
Always a great time there We try to make it every trip down to LBI.. I love their mussels
google avatar

Christina S.

Yelp
I am only coming here to say ONE thing. Get the Bonsai Oysters. Get them. Love them. And get them again. Also - service is always fantastic - anytime we come down to LBI, we come here before getting on the island, and we are never disappointed.

Dea A.

Yelp
The food was fantastic. My husband had the seafood pot. My husband said "best mussels ever!" I had the crab cakes and a special appetizer Bree with honey and nuts AMAZING. I don't say that lightly. Highly
google avatar

Justin O.

Yelp
All I intended was to express my dissatisfaction in a review, only to be met with a dismissive and rude response from the owner. Rather than addressing my concerns with professionalism and courtesy, she chose to argue that the photo I included wasn't even of their crab cake. I can assure you, it was indeed taken at this establishment, and I have the evidence to prove it. The lack of accountability and customer care displayed by this response is truly disheartening. I didn't expect any compensation or freebies - I simply wanted to share my honest feedback. Instead, I was met with denial. Very disappointed again.
google avatar

Jay J.

Yelp
It's just always good here. A central jersey staple. Mussels in white wine - crab cake - calamari - steak with mash and a side of asparagus
google avatar

Zoe G.

Yelp
Won't tell wait time over the phone which kinda sucks when deciding where to go :-/ good food and drinks.

Scott C.

Yelp
Arrogant guy behind the bar w/ beard ( use to work at ( Causeway boat rentals years ago ) $6 domestic bottle beer at " Happy Hour " ( if you want to call it that ) Sat down at side table to have something to eat and a beer. When paying my bill I asked waitress how much for a beer and she said $5.50.. I asked her why I was charged $6 at the bar and her response was " maybe they didn't have change lol" lol.. I didn't want to get the manager and cause a stink. If he did that 1000 times through out his shift that's $500 he's pocketing or making for the bar.. It's not about the .50 it's the principl!!! Just wanted to let people know to check their tabs because they're thieves!!! Their food is average bar food at best! Will never step foot in there again!!! Scott
google avatar

Keith D.

Yelp
What a great place! We went in for dinner on a Thursday night. Kitchen is open later than most. The clam chowder was great, the crab cake wrap and the shrimp and grits were better. We sat at a high top near the bar and had a wonderful time. Service was impeccable - shout out to Amanda! Definitely a new entry to the "Must Stop When On LBI" list.
google avatar

Paola C.

Yelp
I love this place! I come here every summer when I vacation in LBI and I'm never disappointed. Great ambience and great menu to match. Be forewarned that it can get busy and sometime there is a 2-2.5 hour wait if you don't plan ahead. If you're lucky, you may find a seat at the bar. They have steak, chicken, and all kinds of seafood from lobster, mussel, oysters, crab and tuna! Something for everyone. They're oysters are Delicious! I definitely recommend it for a starter. They also have live music on the weekends, which adds to the experience.
google avatar

Sydney U.

Yelp
We came here for lunch- the service and food was good! They have an extensive menu and great drink options. It is definitely more steakhouse vibes on the inside with dim lighting and table seating. They do have a large bar with bar seating as well!
google avatar

Mike D.

Yelp
A Thursday night, a rocking band, an amazing beer and wine list, and tons of options to choose from. Primarily a seafood place with all sorts of clams, fish, and a wonderful lobster roll, are the highlights but plenty of other options as well. Oh the pretzel with cheese sauce is a famous appetizer. We had the salmon bowl and tuna done rare just as I asked. Plenty of food. I found an ipa I've never had before, so bonus points ! Huge restaurant, room with the live music was rocking, our section was much removed and very quiet noise level, so you can choose how much music you want.
google avatar

John B.

Yelp
A first timer here, and I thought the place was amazing. Great atmosphere. Presentation and taste of food was fantastic. Sat near kitchen and saw other meals rolling out that looked so good. Reasonably priced Macaroni and cheese so creamy; put my wife's to shame. Pretzel itself average but cheese sauce took it over the top. Wings were perfect.
google avatar

Vanessa P.

Yelp
We came in for lunch and had a wonderful time. Dawn and Derek were amazing and helped with all of our choices. All of the specials are delicious! The atmosphere is relaxed and enjoyable. We will definitely be back!
google avatar

Jarrod G.

Yelp
This review is for the female bar "manager". The one with the charming forearm tattoos. She needs a lesson or two on "managing". Her service is consistently terrible! Every time we come in we complain about her attentiveness to guests. She clearly favors her "friends" or "locals" that are at the bar. You'll sit with an empty glass for 15 minutes while she's cracking jokes and laughing with people 5 feet away from you. She'll check on a handful of guests for additional orders or drinks but skips over you if she doesn't recognize you. We have to ask waiters and hostesses who aren't serving us to help us get her attention. She runs away from behind the bar leaving it empty for 5-10-15 minutes while you sit with an empty glass or waiting to put in food. Idk if they are short staffed and being cheap or if this lady is just that bad at her job, which is providing service to ALL guests, not just your favorites. We live in BHW and frequent there often, but no more. I can afford better service, and food, elsewhere. Hope the GM or restaurant group reads this and does something about. Your crappy service is losing a long time customer.
google avatar

Jacey H.

Yelp
I LOVE THIS PLACE. Our waitress Sabrina was amazing, she kept checking in on us and making sure we were good. Our food came out so quickly and you can tell it was all fresh. The food was delicious and I'm so glad we ate here. The restaurant is great and makes for a very nice lunch or dinner. Will definitely be back very soon.