Nadja Lewis
Google
Unfortunately, I have to update my review ( with one less star) and keep it as honest as possible. We ordered food from Coleys recently and went to pick it up. We ordered 4 items and it seemed as if the woman was confused or something as initially she was insisting that the order was complete with only 2 items.
We got home only to find liquid all over (inside) one of the bags, and it had leaked onto another container. So it was messy!
There was way too much sauce on the rice ( we ordered oxtail and rice), otherwise the oxtail was pretty good.
The escovitch fish had A LOT of sauce/seasoning; I have never had such a "soaked" fish and I eat plenty fish, especially when in Jamaica, so I know the true taste. Even if the item "comes with the sauce on it", there is no need to over-saturate. I wiped the fish as much as possible, I could sense it was meant to be tasty but the sauce or whatever was on it tasted like it was vinegar based (and way too much of it); be warned it is far from cheap. There was so much sauce that had leaked that it soaked the festival through and through; needless to say, I had to throw the festival away.
We also ordered saltfish fritters. After wiping and squeezing out as much of the oil as possible, the taste wasn't bad, but too much oil was used to fry them!
On the other hand, the oxtail meal also had a festival, and my relative said it was good. She also had purchased Coleys ginger drink and enjoyed it, though it is not for the weak, as it has lots of ginger 🫚.
She decided to order jerk corn. It looks nothing like what we saw online. Once again, there's way too much sauce on an item. Since when is "jerk" so wet? She hasn't tried it yet as it does not look appealing at all; we may end up throwing it away.
Disappointing experience, and the bill was close to $100!
Overall, I'd say most food items are okay but with too much sauce. Will I order from them again? Honestly, at this point, I'm not sure.