Bailey
Google
I'm disappointed to share this restaurant didn't really land for me.
I came on Tuesday as I had the day off and I promised my mom we'd go on a mini road trip together. I'd had this spot on my list for a while and it seemed like the perfect fit, so off we went.
Located in downtown Athens, we were able to find parking on the square, though we arrived at like 11:15 for an early lunch.
To our surprise, the restaurant is connected via one door to U.G. White Mercantile, which we've visited before. They have cute gifts and such.
The interior of the restaurant was fine; I remember reading about it and feeling like it didn't quite hit the fancier vibe the menu was bringing, but it was ultimately okay. I liked the exposed brick but didn't care for the straight line of paintings on the opposing wall. The health score posted was in the high 80s, which seems a little low for a restaurant of this caliber, but not a dealbreaker for me personally.
Our server was nice enough but was also just adequate. Some of the other waiters helped ensure our drinks were always full, and she took a very long time between when we were actually done with our meal and when we got to pay, which was strange because it wasn't super busy.
They have lunch specials that change daily, in addition to sandwiches/burgers and quite expensive entrees -- can't imagine ordering one of those for lunch but to each their own! Mom and I both decided on the fried chicken with chili honey for our meals; I wanna say it was $14, which is reasonable I feel for the food/atmosphere/service.
I enjoyed the sweet tea to drink; mom said it was a little too sweet for her but if you're like me and enjoy some extra sweet tea this'll hit the spot. For our sides, I selected garlic mashed potatoes and added the crispy Brussels sprouts for an upcharge. Mom also got the mashed potatoes and she chose charred grilled beans as her second.
The chicken we were served was a wing and I believe a deboned thigh. This is not at all my preference and I wish the menu had said what to expect. I also probably should've asked...but oh well. I will eat chicken thighs at least, but this one happened to be heavy on the qualities of a thigh I don't like -- lots of dark meat, and a sort of slippery/greasy quality. Meat aside, the breading didn't feel like it was super well bound to the chicken (ie, it sort of sloughed off) and didn't have much of a crunch, even the bits that didn't have the honey on it. The honey was fine but not very chili-forward (good for my mom, not so for me). I also thought the breading was not super flavorful. Lastly, the portion felt a little small for the price paid, but it is a lunchtime portion I suppose.
The sides were fine. The garlic mashed potatoes were whipped super creamy; I like mine a little more rustic, with potato skin and chunks still in there. Unobjectionable but not remarkable. Mom's charred green beans were actually pretty good and probably my favorite thing I tasted here. The crispy Brussels were definitely crispy; however, most of them had fallen apart into individual leaves, which took on a sort of unpleasant charred quality and didn't provide much to bite into. The pearls of what I think was goat cheese were not particularly appreciated and, again, I wish this had been described on the menu. Didn't hate it, but could've done without it.
All in all, I didn't hate it but it certainly didn't reach the high heights I was imagining/hoping for. If I were to return, I'd try a burger or pimento grilled cheese, or something else other than what I actually had.