Dustin F.
Yelp
Lived in Phoenix off and on for about 10 years, never been, and had wanted to try it out since it's a historic location. Choose as a late Valentine's Day dinner. Pros - decor and history around the building are nice, my Baron's Manhattan cocktails were delicious, and I enjoyed the rolls/biscuits and New England clam chowder that came with the meal. Cons - I ordered their most expensive steak, The Arizona Cut 24 oz bone-in ribeye at $80 and upgraded to the twice baked potato for $12.
Upon delivery, I noticed the $12 potato was about the size of a banana, disappointing and overpriced to say the least.
The steak, ordered medium rare, at first glance looked good. However, with a poke test and cutting into it appeared to be underdone at the center to the point of being between rare and medium rare. My girlfriend looked at it and thought the same.
She said I should and I considered sending it back. However, we had been observing for some time the couple behind us appear to have multiple issues with corresponding visors from our same server. With that our server essentially never visited us to see how things were going. I decided to eat as much of it as I could given there obviously appeared to be an issue in the kitchen with cooks at a steakhouse not knowing how to cook a steak to temperature.
After we finished, we decided to order their $15 bread pudding, which is one of my favorite desserts to order if available. Again, at first glance, it looked good. However, the bread pudding was not even warm. This time, our server stopped by and asked how it was. I gave her my honest opinion and told her it wasn't that good. I could make it better myself at home. The server essentially tried to play my comment in stride, making a joke to the effect of saying they can only do the best they can do and everything can't be to everyone's taste.
As we were leaving I stopped by our neighbors table and jokingly asked "over or under?" He said they had to send it back 3 times.
I grew up in the restaurant industry, so I am sympathetic to those that work in the industry, but will be brutally honest as price point to me sets the standard for quality of food and service to expect. For example, I've dropped $400 for two at a Cowford Chophouse in Jacksonville, FL that had excellent service and food in a renovated old bank building with rooftop seating g and bar overlooking the river. One of the best experiences I've had and would highly recommend.
However, after dropping $265 for two with tip, for me, it'll be the first and last visit to The Stockyards. This is unfortunate because I like to support small/local businesses.