Ari H.
Yelp
This place is firing on all cylinders. I've been at least a dozen times and they never fail to hit it out of the park. I consider it to be Massimo's crown jewel, which is VERY high praise, considering he's one of the most consistently great restauranteurs on the planet. I've been to 5 of his restaurants now, Whelk, Le Farm, Jesup Hall, Kawa Ni & Don Memo and the only one I wouldn't give 5 stars to is Don Memo. Not too shabby.
Speaking of not too shabby, The Whelk, as I said, might just be the best of them all, worthy of a sixth star if that were possible. From the casual-yet-special vibe to the friendly service to the killer food- if I could eat here seven days a week I would.
Things to get... Well, the menu changes often, but there are a few staples:
For starters, the deviled eggs are heavenly, topped with fried oysters and pickled onions. My god!
The raw bar is another must if you like oysters, because they are always impeccable. So fresh, they don't even need lemon or mignonette.
The grilled octopus is another crowd-pleaser served in Mediterranean preparation with potatoes, paprika and olives.
And sometimes they have a killer fluke crudo with chili oil that's to die for.
For entrees, I'm a sucker for Norman's Lobster. It's essentially half lobster, half butter and all ridiculous! It's so damn good even if you have an allergy to shellfish, you still might want to consider getting it. It's worth a trip to the hospital.
The fish preps are also always strong, but they change so often it's not really worth listing particulars.
And if you happen to be with a non-fish lover, fret not, because they do a killer burger, chicken sammy and even a chicken entree that holds its own.
Lastly, for dessert, the go-to IMO is the pot du creme, made with wonderfully salted nuts that make this thing shine - and I don't even like pot du creme!
But, if you're lucky, during rhubarb season, they have a strawberry rhubarb pie with fire roasted marshmallow whipped topping that's even better, if that were possible.
Net, net... if you're thinking about going, stop thinking. You deserve this!