Three Brothers

"Jacobs sent judges Kristen Kish, Gail Simmons, and Tom Colicchio to Three Brothers, a family-run Serbian restaurant. “It’s totally a throwback — cash only, it’s like walking backwards in time,” he says." - Regan Stephens

"If this family-owned restaurant changed even a little, people would riot. It’s been open since 1956, and is one of only two Serbian spots in Milwaukee, with the other a little less than two miles west. Everything on the menu is a family recipe, like in-house pickled cabbage that comes as a side to roast lamb, duck, and goose, or the burek, which is the best we’ve ever had. It’s flaky on the outside, packed with flavorful meat and cheese, and takes a half hour to bake because, well, good things take time. The dim lighting, tiny space, and vintage floral plates lend themselves well to a date or dinner with just one other person. " - kristine hansen

"If this family-owned restaurant changed even a little, people would riot. It’s been open since 1956, and is one of only two Serbian spots in Milwaukee, with the other a little less than two miles west. Everything on the menu is a family recipe, like in-house pickled cabbage that comes as a side to roast lamb, duck, and goose, or the burek, which is the best we’ve ever had. It’s flaky on the outside, packed with flavorful meat and cheese, and takes a half hour to bake because, well, good things take time. The dim lighting, tiny space, and vintage floral plates lend themselves well to a date or dinner with just one other person." - Kristine Hansen

"You’ll be hit by the homey mood at the door of this old Schlitz tavern, which smells like grandma’s house when she’s been cooking all day. Tucked away in a still-quiet nook of Bay View, the Serbian stalwart features cash-only dinners and 45-plus-minute waits for flaky böreks, both indicative of a night out in a different time. The flavors on the dinner menu run the gamut: Serbian salad, goulash, moussaka, chicken paprikash, roasted goose, chevapchichi (beef sausages). It’s meat-and-potato Eastern European fare for beating back winter." - Todd Lazarski

"We love to hop to Milwaukee and visit Three Brothers Restaurant and enjoy their famous cheese burek." - Eater Staff