Ben N.
Yelp
Back home, I almost always visit a restaurant more than once before writing up a review. It just seems like the fair thing to do. (Except on those rare occasions when the place irredeemably sucks or an expensive place is mediocre or worse, meaning I'm not returning.) But on the road, I think everybody, including me, writes up reviews based on a single visit, fair or not.
I got to visit Tia Sophia's for a second time. First was during a work conference five years ago, and that was the best food of the trip. The wife and I spent a week in Santa Fe this fall, and I suggested going for lunch one day.
The first visit was excellent, but for whatever reasons, I deemed it not quite worthy of five stars. A second visit underlined the restaurant's attributes and seemed to soften the minor flaws. A half-decade later, I got the same "Atrisco Plate"--green chile stew, cheese enchilada, beans, & posole. Everything was just as superb, if $3 more expensive now. As I indicated before, the food here has that fussed-over, stick-to-your-ribs home-cooking quality that is hard to duplicate in a restaurant kitchen. A very similar plate at Tomasita's the day before was great, but Tia Sophia's amps it up a notch or two. Sopaipillas and ice tea were top-notch, too.
The dining area at Tia Sophia's is modest-bordering-on-frowsy--it's showing some age--and the service is amiable enough but seems a bit hurried. But the owners clearly take pride in turning out wonderful food; you get the impression that, instead of letting things slide during a half-century in operation, they've continued to fine-tune everything to near-perfection over the decades.