Tony's Meat Market of Montauk

The staff were very friendly. We can find lost items that we want there. The selections were good. They open from 5 am to 9 pm within minutes from the beach, so it’s very convenient.

Tony’s Meat market has a variety of ready- made food, meats, desserts, coffee, veggies, canned goods and pastas. While I work on a project in montauk, there were not many places open for lunch. Our staff come here to pick up sandwiches and salad. We tried “ the Hither Hills” sandwich and took it to Gorman’s dock to have a lunch. It was big enough to share and delicious. Some items were more on the expensive side, but compare to other places in Montauk, I think price was reasonable. When I come to Montauk for the summer, I will definitely come to Tony’s to pick up some salad and sandwiches.

Located in the Gosman’s Marina area, Tony’s is an addiction! You are greeted by the well stocked deli and pulled into the market by the delicious smells of homestyle cooking. Everything you might need is there - dairy, dry goods, even your favorite breakfast cereals. Don’t want to cook? Go to Tony’s. You’ll be happy you did.

Went here June 20th 2025 for lunch. I got a burger that was completely wrong due to people not being able to understand. Sent it back TWICE for them to send it out the same. Spent 20 plus minutes in there and an absurd amount of money. Was definitely not worth it. Do not waste your money, go somewhere else!!

This place is AWESOME! I am new around here as I’m opening up a restaurant a little down the road. I walked in with my service dog, Piper the Golden Retriever and I was very warmly greeted by Gill the manager and Monica, who was working at the register. I ordered a hot pastrami Reuben sandwich and I also got a bag of deep river chips and a soda. I’m eating the sandwich now and it is sooooo dang good I put it down to write this review but I’m going to keep this quick so I can get back to this delicious and enormous sandwich. The pastrami is fabulous. The break tastes like it was made fresh this morning. I didn’t mind the $24 it all cost because it was very well worth it. There is a huge selection of prepared food and a small grocery/sundries section. Tony’s is going to be my go-to spot this summer.

i ve been a regular to montauk since 2019 and am happy to have tonys here. not only meat but other basic grocery as well

Half gallon of Planet Oat Oatmilk $8.29. What? $5 at a up Island store. $11 for scramble egg and tomato on a onion roll. NFW! Started off as a nice local deli/meat market. Now just another price gouging store. Will not step foot in there again. Owners should be ashamed of themselves.

Open late on a Sunday! Score!! Lots of quality options for dry goods and condiments. Big butcher selection. Can't go wrong here. I recommend

We accidentally stumbled upon the market after visiting a nearby wine store. They have a large meat/deli counter. We visited twice once for some snacks and the second time for sandwiches for lunch. The sandwiches are quite large and can easily be shared. They had a nice selection cheeses, crackers, bread and almost anything else you could want. The people were helpful and accommodating. It is a small store but packed with lots of delicious food.

This place has an incredible selection of deli sandwiches and salads. Also a great selection of meats. But you will wait your entire life to have a sandwich made, even if it's not crowded. They are fully staffed but they don't seem to have a handle on what they're doing. So while I still go there, just be prepared so you're not aggravated.

This is a higher end market stocked with everything and anything one could ever need in nuevo Montauk. Stopped in for breakfast this morning, with four very specific orders. Everything came out perfect, no mistakes, and great quality. Picked up some octopus salad which was very good too. The variety in this store really is a site to be seen. You first walk in to a high, clean, counter, through the left entrance. There are a few folks working and asking if you need help, that acknowledgment is great. They take the order through a digital POS, giving me some confidence that the order will be correct. While they are making the breakfast to order, a little stroll around the market reveals a stocked butcher case, takeaway foods like grilled chicken to full meals of pastas. There are freezer sections with gelatos and unique proteins (chicken burgers). The fridge section has interesting cold beverages. While they were bagging up the breakfast, I had to get a little octopus salad too, just to see. It was good. You pay on the way out on the opposite side of the entrance. $80 later for four egg sandwiches, coffees and octopus salad, everything was good at Tony'$. You really don't mind spending the money when the service comes with a smile and the food is great.

Went here to get butter and a small bottle of syrup for breakfast expecting to pay premium prices. Lady at register told me $24 dollars for the 2 , I restocked the items and drove to The IGA at which it cost under $8. I understand there's only a few months to make money but that's absurd

Unreal one little piece of Lox. Come on for $14.00 dollars! I am a frequent shopper at this store.

In my opinion, this is the hands down best place to purchase your protein! The chicken and steak pinwheels are out of this world, and the steak burgers are well worth their weight in gold. For an added bonus, they also sell a rainbow cookie gelato that would bring a tear to your eye it's so good!

Fresh clean and delicious! Deli/baked goods with a fresh choice of produce. My sandwich was delicious

Great sandwich . Very clean and great staff. Great to hsve food back in this spot. I Loved the bread. The hero was like a semolina . You get what you pay for . Kelly at the Deli and the two cashier girls were very very nice .

There are other places to buy food without being charged 4% processing fees for a credit card. What a disgrace. Won't be back.

We are always looking for a good meat Market while traveling by boat and we were so happy to find Tony's. The prepared foods are fantastic and I had the best Mac salad ever. Try the sausage bread, it's amazing.

Beautiful market with prepared foods, beautiful steaks/ meats, cheeses, condiments, snacks, drinks. Great place to walk to from our boat for a nice spread!

This is the best store in Montauk. Don't miss it. The quality of their meat is excellent.

fantastic meat and deli market! friendly helpful staff! top of the line meat selection, deli selections , and fresh huge assortment of gourmet to go dishes. For breakfast, lunch, dinner ,cookout, fishing trip, day at the beach ... or to revive from a festive night out !!! Tony's has what it takes to make your day (or night) Did I mention how friendly and helpful the staff isWell they are! Lexa Tuma DiSpirito

I have nothing but praise for TONY'S Meat Market in Montauk. The people are wonderful. They bend over backward to help you. The food and large selection is delicious. Love the fresh bread and mozzarella. The meat is excellent. Grilling selections are top notch. Welcome to Montauk. You're a keeper! Great job Ray!

Very nice addition to Montauk. Deli is average but I wish you can order ahead because the waits are long. Prepped foods are also average but large variety and convenient.

Everything is excellent but it's expensive ... not just montauk expensive but too pricey ... very convenient to have a such a good shop in the harbor

Great food and really friendly staff. It's really nice to be greeted with an enthusiastic "GOOD MORNING" and a smile. Being open early is a real service to us fishermen!

We could not be happier having Tony's Market in our neighborhood. Excellent meats, produce, deli and provisions. they have great prepared foods, cheeses and meats for your charcuterie. It truly is one stop shopping for all your eating and entertaining needs. They also offer a full catering menu. The coffee is outstanding, place is spotless and the staff is friendly and helpful. what more could you ask for. By far the best meats in Montauk. Check it out ! You will not be disappointed.

A great new addition to Montauk. The deli/ sandwich counter has a wide variety of fresh made to order sandwiches. And a very friendly local crew!

Great food!!! Thank you for coming to Montauk! So happy to have you here! Friendly service and amazing Italian food. Can't get better than Tony's!

Got some pretty good steaks here. Will definitely go back here. Hope they stay open thru the winter.