The Best Restaurants In Montauk - New York - The Infatuation

"Always popular with year-rounders, this Italian deli is about to become a Montauk staple, thanks to a new grab-and-go location in the center of town. The fact that the new spot is open until 2am makes it even more exciting for a neighborhood that typically goes dark for food by 10pm. The O.G. deli and grocery, however, is still the place to load up on picnic-ready homemade salads, whether seafood-centric or antipasti, plus hot sandwiches (we love all the parms), melts, and made-to-order subs. Those subs are also sold by the foot if you’re sharing with a crowd." - melissa kravitz hoeffner, team infatuation