Tara C.
Yelp
This is probably our go-to dine-in pizza place now.
If you just do a head to head comparison of pizza to pizza, I think Home Slice still beats Toss, but it's close, and Toss has a lot of extras that put them over the edge.
Not least of which is actually being able to find a parking place and a table. There's some charm to eating your pizza standing on the corner of So-Co watching dogs and tech-bros go by, but it's not what you want every time.
So... Toss.
Lots of toppings. Really good pizza. I just stick with garlic and peperoni, but there are SO many options, and the crust and sauce are just right.
Lovely ambiance. It's got like an indoor/outdoor almost beer garden thing going on. At least so far it's not usually too busy. A healthy crowd, but it's stays fairly chill.
The service is a little meh, but it's not bad, it's just kind of a spread out restaurant, and they seem maybe a little understaffed? No one's been rude, just not very attentive. Again, compare to Home Slice... at least there is service?
For me, the champion, is s'mores. I can't fathom why more places don't have s'mores as a desert. It's fast for them to make. it's delicious. It's something that's kind of a hassle to make a home. Feels like an easy win. I'm not a HUGE pizza fan, so if I'm going to be hyped about going to a pizza place for dinner (which I'd liked to be, because my family loves pizza) than having those little extras on the menu is a big plus.
My one complaint, and it's pretty major, but I didn't dock a star for it, is some of the seating. OMG... the most uncomfortable stools you have ever sat on in your whole life. I truly almost didn't finish my meal my tailbone hurt so bad. I don't know what in the world they were thinking with those stools. There a lot of different seating options, so that's why I didn't dock a star, just avoid sitting on the bar stools like the plague. They are so awful.